4 ms·
> People needs to start looking at local self-sufficiency of energy and materials to some degree. This is a complete, unrealistic pipe dream. Yes, we've obviou
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
> People needs to start looking at local self-sufficiency of energy and materials to some degree.
This is a complete, unrealistic pipe dream. Yes, we've obviously seen a "deglobalization" occurring, and many countries are feeling the pain of being completely dependent on critical fuel and materials from one or a few other countries with shaky political systems.
But the idea that "local self sufficiency" is possible on a wide scale, without sending us all back to the stone age, is quite frankly nonsense. I remember reading an article a while back about how something as ubiquitous as a cheeseburger is only possible with wide, nation-crossing supply chains.
Saying "we should look at local self sufficiency" makes people think of planting a garden in their back yard, when in reality it would mean virtually all of the advances in human comfort, health and convenience over the past couple hundred years or so would have to be given up.
- iasay 4y agoI'm not suggesting that we send ourselves back to the stone age. I'm suggesting that we stop shipping resources half way around the planet and then send the trash back because it's cheaper. The last 50-80 years at least has been a race to the lowest cost with no consideration for any consequences such as the environment, security and stability. UK is a fine example. We had a great steel industry here. But it's cheaper to buy it from China and India and it helps us hit our pollution targets not processing it here. But we just pushed the problem to where the side effects aren't immediately visible. The real issue is our consumption and use of materials. This is the reality: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iy63PEgmm8w https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iy63PEgmm8w
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- b112 4y agoOr how about in BC, where sawdust is shipped by the gigatonne to China, gets made into particle board, and comes back as cheap furniture?
- lamontcg 4y agoIf you had non polluting shipping and the costs were still cheap enough there would be nothing intrinsically wrong with this. The problem is the market externalities of the pollution of our current shipping methods, and likely the imbalances in the labor markets and regulation. If you fixed those, then it would probably no longer make sense to do that, but you can't fix those systemic problems by banning the symptoms of them.
- mmmpop 4y ago> I remember reading an article a while back about how something as ubiquitous as a cheeseburger is only possible with wide, nation-crossing supply chains. I'm the article was informative but I know where a few cows are and I know how to at least field dress a carcass, so I bet I can wrangle me some hamburger.
- School-Cotton 4y agoSure, but >90% of people don’t have whatever upbringing (or interests/hobbies) that led you to have that knowledge, so at a population scale the point stands.
- smackeyacky 4y agoI'm sure you can, but it doesn't scale. The only way we eat is industrialised agriculture. You will be fighting your neighbours for that cow and wasting most of it. Similarly with "backyard plots" and that other great modern stupidity, the vertical indoor garden. Like anybody will be lazily reaching over to pick a tomato from their indoor vertical garden instead of the monstrous greenhouses that most tomatoes come from these days.
- lovich 4y agoI agree with you that we rely on industrial agriculture and the amount of space someone needs to fully feed themselves is larger than most peoples available space, but I and others totally reach for the shit we grow before resorting to buying in a store, I don’t know why you think that can’t subsidize some need for shipping food
- smackeyacky 4y agoFor basics like potatoes, carrots, onions etc. this is possibly doable but it isn't going to replace a families worth of food. For an individual or a couple, maybe. But certainly not all year. If you use the old-school Australian "quarter acre block" you might do a families vegetables for part of the year. As a supplement, it's worthwhile. As a substitute it's non viable.
- poulsbohemian 4y ago>a cheeseburger is only possible with wide, nation-crossing supply chains. I know you are just giving an example - I get your concept - but frankly all the ingredients for a darn good cheeseburger are produced within a two hour drive of where I live, on an industrial scale. Maybe I'm just really lucky, but on the other hand if you go back just a bit more than 50 years ago, most small towns had their own dairies, bakers, butchers, local farmers and rancher, they had various kinds of factories and industrial producers - and maybe this is one place where we need to go back in history.