3 ms·
I wonder if some of the quality and reputation issues could be fixed if the road constraint were removed. Then more robust building code rules could be require
by gumby 4y ago
I wonder if some of the quality and reputation issues could be fixed if the road constraint were removed. Then more robust building code rules could be required and enforced.
The way to get rid of the road constraint would be airships, as discussed in a HN submission in the last week or so.
If that worked, than manufactured housing could change the granularity: subassemblies would be worth building in a factory and moved onsite (imagine a stack of 8’x12’ walls, already drywalled and with code compliant electrical fittings) or, on the other direction, multistory building could be transported the way doublewides are transported and then joimed in situ today.
- brudgers 4y agoModular buildings tick all your requirements and are ubiquitous in the US. There are technical (aka, legal) differences between “modular building”, “mobile home”, “trailer”, “motor home”, and “recreational vehicle”. “Manufactured home” is a trade association term and useful because a manufacturer might build both modular homes and mobile homes on the same assembly line and they may even be hard to tell apart because most of the difference is in the paperwork. As I said there’s a legal layer.
- gumby 4y agoThanks!
- sillysaurusx 4y agoAirships? I feel like you glossed over that little detail. Even if the safety were better than cars, being physically in the air is terrifying to most people. That’s not a deal breaker, but it’s certainly a hurdle. If you’ve been next to someone on a plane who had to down a whole bottle of xanax (metaphorically) just to get through the flight, you realize how traumatic it can be for some people. And then you’ll get stories like “mother of five perishes with all five due to airship failure”. Tesla has had relatively few such horror stories, and look how much it’s impacted them. (On the other hand, “how little it’s impacted them” might also be accurate.) But I really want to know what you mean by airship. My mind immediately went to FF7 Highwind.
- benoliver999 4y agoAirship to transport the house, not airship as a house
- kQq9oHeAz6wLLS 4y agoNow, lets not dismiss that idea...'cause that'd be rad
- mbreese 4y agoI took it to mean transporting the pre made houses by airship instead of over existing roads. Less traveling public, more heavy transport. By removing the “must ship by road” requirement, you could have many more shapes and sizes for the prefabricated home components. Transport of the components by airship would be one way to avoid roads. (It brings a whole host of other issues too, so it’s not something I find all that practical, but I’m not the parent)
- KennyBlanken 4y ago....I think they mean delivery and transport by airship, versus delivery by road. I don't see how that would work, given mobile homes weigh roughly 50 pounds per square foot, and that probably doesn't account for personal belongings and furniture. Even very large cargo helicopters seem to top out around 20 tons.
- gumby 4y agoYou just need the structures, not the fittings, but weight is indeed an issue where you can’t easily find ballast to swap for your cargo.
- dqpb 4y agoLol. Next time someone criticizes an idea of mine, I'll try responding with: "Easy, we'll just use airships."
- gumby 4y agoA fair and amusing point. But we may finally be reaching the viability point of a return of airships (cf for example, last month’s https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31592448#31593040 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31592448#31593040 ). For large objects the road constraints are more significant so when the constraint space opens up new opportunities emerge. And a lot of housing is needed!