2 ms·
> "If someone was going to be really good at programming they would have found it on their own. Then if you go look at the bios of successful founders this is i
by lapcat 4y ago
> "If someone was going to be really good at programming they would have found it on their own. Then if you go look at the bios of successful founders this is invariably the case, they were all hacking on computers at age 13. What that means is the problem is 10 years upstream of us."
1) Founders are entrepreneurs. The article seems to be focused on non-entrepreneurial roles, which is a very different situation.
2) We don't seem to have the same attitude about other professions such as medicine, law, stock trading, etc. Do successful surgeons have to operate at age 13? Do successful lawyers have to try cases at age 13? No, that's nuts. So why in tech do we have such a fetish about teenage hackers? This already seems like a kind of bias, and maybe we should correct that.
- BlargMcLarg 4y ago>So why in tech do we have such a fetish about teenage hackers? Same reason it happens for teenage artists, musicians, etc. It's possible, and where there's a possibility, you can bet there will be a bunch of profiteers and elitists trying to push it as the new normal. You can bet your sweet dollars if it was possible to do so as surgeons (by changing the culture and opening up possibilities), the same would happen there. Of course, it also completely discredits that people can become amazing at something starting from nothing in old age.
- ddarden 4y agoThere does seem to be two different mindsets. In most cases everyone has a combination of both of them. The first is the “shakedown” mindset. This is where you are in a situation where you have to try very quickly to figure out what level a person is at so that you can figure out how much info to give them or how to communicate. Some people take the shakedown mindset to an extreme and use it almost exclusively. They tend to by hyper-competitive. Then you have the collaborative mindset. This is where a person is in a more naturally open mindset and they more readily assume that everyone around them are contributors, people they can learn from, non-threatening, etc. The prevailing mindset on HN is probably collaborative. One common misconception, is that what would benefit the group is less shakedown and more collaborative. But that isn’t always true. It is possible that we should teach shakedown skills. How to perform shakedown in a positive way. A way that would naturally lead to the collaborative process. Truly everyone has something to contribute but contribution has to be delivered at the correct collaborative level to be effective.
- rustybelt 4y agoIf surgeons were able to begin honing their craft at 13, they’d probably be better than the ones who started in their twenties. Programming’s low barrier to entry creates issues that don’t apply to other professions. How many virtuoso pianists didn’t start playing until adulthood?
- lapcat 4y ago> If surgeons were able to begin honing their craft at 13, they’d probably be better than the ones who started in their twenties. If you don't count the dead bodies they leave behind on the way. > How many virtuoso pianists didn’t start playing until adulthood? How many virtuoso pianists are there in the world? How many professional programmers are "virtuosos"? How many companies even need virtuoso programmers, and how many companies could afford to pay them? I don't think it's a useful comparison. It's also important to recognize that a ton of kids learn how to play musical instruments, but very few end up as virtuosos. Hacking around with computers as a teenager means very little by itself.
- rustybelt 4y agoI agree with you on the first point. I will not be signing up to have a seventh grader remove my gallbladder. Regarding pianists, I think you can replace “virtuoso” with “professional” and the point still stands.
- lapcat 4y ago> Regarding pianists, I think you can replace “virtuoso” with “professional” and the point still stands. Does it? Professional piano playing doesn't seem to be a particularly large or lucrative profession compared to others such as tech. If you're Elton John or Billy Joel, then great, but otherwise not so much. It makes sense that the music industry is populated largely by people naturally attracted to music, because the route to financial stability, much less financial success, is very precarious.
- rustybelt 4y ago