3 ms·
> Yes, that means less for the executives and shareholders. They may have to sell some of their properties, oh dear. Based on retail business profit margins, i
by lotsofpulp 4y ago
> Yes, that means less for the executives and shareholders. They may have to sell some of their properties, oh dear.
Based on retail business profit margins, it would mean higher prices for customers. Not that that is a bad thing, less consumption would be great.
- Retric 4y agoCompetition limits how much they could raise prices, automation and efficiency increases are needed to compete.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoWho is more efficient than Amazon/Walmart/Target/Home Depot/Staples/Costco/etc? They set the bottom price, and if they are earning 2%-4% profit margins, then their costs increases will have to end up in either prices increases or them no longer selling the product. The funny thing is that it is Amazon coming along and greatly increasing demand for labor (in conjunction with reduced supply of that type of labor) that caused all the other warehouse jobs and retailers to increase pay. And I hope the labor continues making gains in their quality of life at work and pay, but I do not see this happening without an increase in prices for products (like we have already seen).
- Retric 4y agoThat’s assuming they keep their margins the same. The thing is Amazon isn’t manufacturing anything so their “thin” margins aren’t as sensitive to increased labor costs as 2-4% suggests. Paying 18$ for something your selling for 20$ is a 10% margin, taxes and CC processing fees are similarly inflexible. So if 2-4% of the final price is profit then they could raise their internal costs by 10% and still be profitable.
- danaris 4y ago> if they are earning 2%-4% profit margins They're not (depending on the product). My wife used to work in Halloween costume design for a wholesaler (and some of her costumes did end up in Target and Walmart, which was cool to see), and the retailers' margins on those were at least 50%. As I said, the margin does depend heavily on the product, but do not assume that across-the-board average margins are anywhere near that razor-thin.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoThat is irrelevant because the entire organization’s profit margins are where increased wages would come from.
- danaris 4y agoMy point is that the entire organization's profit margins are not likely to be anywhere near 2-4%.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoThat is what their 10-K filings say.
- Retric 4y agoThey are incentivized to hide investments as operating expenses for tax reasons, which muddles the picture.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoSource? What are the incentives? Why do the most highly valued companies in the world report much higher profit margins? I would need a good reason to believe the executives and owners of retail businesses do not want to report higher profit margins.
- Retric 4y agoThe incentives are simple, profits are taxed. To simplify, if you want to say develop new software you can call it a capital investment and pay for it with after tax money or call it operating expense and pay for it in pretax money. Guess which one is a better deal.
- lotsofpulp 4y ago
- Spooky23 4y agoTreating workers like shit and churning them limits the workers they can hire and retain. They even know this - Amazon is running out of eligible workers to hire. But the need to hit quarterly metrics forces the line management to make strategically bad decisions.
- Spooky23 4y agoIn the Metro NY and upstate regions, there is a supermarket chain called Shoprite that is unionized. Where I live, none of the other chains are union shops. The only visible difference as a consumer is there are less (or no) automated checkout lanes. Prices are no different than anywhere else.
- danaris 4y ago> The only visible difference as a consumer is there are less (or no) automated checkout lanes. ...Really? That's a straight detriment in my book, as a customer. I would generally prefer to support a union shop, but I'm extremely fond of self-checkout—and, in fact, further upstate, Wegman's has introduced a self-scan app that you can use to tally up your total as you shop, and just scan a code at the self-checkout register with your phone on the way out to pay. One of the worst things unions can do is try to "protect jobs" at the expense of technological advancement, customer service, or improved product.
- salawat 4y agoDoes Wegman's pay you for providing them free labor? You're subsidizing them at your own cost with self-checkout. After all, you are: -Updating their inventory tracking system -engaging with the regulatory framework of purchasing on their behalf -being subject to their annoying "loss prevention hot days" where they turn the merchandise scales on. I've started to take a different view toward these jobs over time. Being an employer is a high bar in the U.S., and if we (the taxpayers proxied through the markets/Federal Reserve) have an objective to have people participating in the workforce, then these "automated" checkouts cost workforce participation. Which also means fewer training opportunities for low skill workers, fewer jobs of last resort, etc. Not everything is necessarily $$$. Be a hell of an economics project to really suss out the difference in flow of money in grocers who took different approaches.
- danaris 4y agoI could not care less that doing the scanning myself saves Wegman's money. It saves me mental energy and time because I don't need to deal with a human cashier, and I don't need to spend 10 minutes emptying a full cart, scanning every item, then packing them all back into bags and fitting those back into the cart.