6 ms·
He apparently came under surveillance after the FBI received a vague tip from someone who said Afifi might be a threat to national security. Without exaggerati
by ck2 15y ago
He apparently came under surveillance after the FBI received a vague tip from someone who said Afifi might be a threat to national security.
Without exaggeration, this is exactly how innocent people, some of them teenagers, ended up in Gitmo (and are still there) via vague tips from people who didn't like their neighbors and decided to deal with it by reporting them.
- wavephorm 15y agoTerrorists are the new communists. Merely being accused is a crime.
- onemoreact 15y agoI have thought that would be a great way to attack the system. However, I suspect accusing large numbers of people would simply create suffering and would do little to create real change. Worse yet it would probably be used to promote increased monitoring because look at the X number of suspects out there. Still, it's sad to think the most effective / damaging / and possibly profitable approach for a risk averse terrorist might be to pretend to be a overly helpful.
- DamnYuppie 15y agoSounds eerily similar to the Spanish Inquisition and the Salem Witch hunts.
- rdtsc 15y agoThe thing they don't realize is that this kind of attitude can and will be exploited by evil people to exact personal revenge on others. From a system-wide point of view, this irrational crazy behavior is a vulnerability. And it just begs to be exploited. If you want to burry your neighbor -- submit an anonymous tip about them being a terrorist, child pornographer or a illegal music downloader. With a bit of luck, their life will be completely ruined. I remember stories from Soviet Union how neighbors would make up stories about each other and denounce them as conducting anti-party propaganda, because say, they insulted them or moved the fence too close. It was the amazing ease and predictability with which this process worked.
- bh42222 15y agoThis is exactly how "law enforcement" used to work behind the iron curtain. An anonymous tip that you were anti-communist could get you arrested.
- jasonlotito 15y agoHe wasn't arrested. He was observed. So, this is not "exactly" how it used to work behind the iron curtain.
- mgunes 15y agoThe Stasi extensively "observed" people before an arrest.
- tptacek 15y agoAnd so did Hitler. Does that end this pointless debate? You can't argue from a position that says "surveillance" and "arrest" are the same thing. They are simply not the same thing. The police cannot arrest you at will. An arrest is a big deal.
- burgerbrain 15y agoAccidentally down voted you. Readers should note that the vast majority of people observed by the Stasi were never arrested. At one point in history, their mere pervasive and unjustified "observing" was considered bad enough...
- raganwald 15y agoThat is very different than how things used to work on this side of the iron curtain: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McCarthyism#House_Committee_on_Un-American_Activities http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McCarthyism#House_Committee_on_...
- bh42222 15y agoNature loves symmetry!
- tptacek 15y agoThe teenagers you're talking about were taken from Afghanistan, right? Not San Jose. People make comments about people from the US being "sent to Gitmo" for daring to stand up to authority here, but it's worth noting that nobody has been taken from inside the US and held in Guantanamo. Having noted that, I think we find we don't even need to litigate Gitmo here. Which is a good thing, because I think you'll have a hard time finding a lot of people to disagree with you in interesting ways about it. Of course military and intelligence agencies shouldn't have taken innocent people from Afghanistan and stuck them in a brig without due process rights. Thankfully, that has little to do with what the FBI does in San Jose.
- DamnYuppie 15y agoThe issue I have with that is as it stands right now how would any know if this is true or not? The NSA and FBI can effectively keep things secret as they don't have to disclose all that they are doing.
- tptacek 15y agoWe might as well not discuss at all then, right? How can anyone prove the negative?
- burgerbrain 15y agoNot all discussion needs to adhere to strict logic and proof. It's called speculation, and silencing it is not acceptable.
- InclinedPlane 15y agoThe truth is that US citizens are being detained by our government and jailed in a space station (codenamed "Camp RT") orbiting the Sun between Earth and Mars.
- burgerbrain 15y agoThe US DoD acknowledged fact is that American Citizens have been illegally^ detained, in some cases in Gitmo. This assertion that it somehow matters that they weren't kidnapped while currently in the US is puzzling to say the least. ^They don't admit this part for obvious reasons. And they also say waterboarding isn't torture...
- jasonlotito 15y ago> Without exaggeration, this is exactly how innocent people, some of them teenagers, ended up in Gitmo But that is exaggeration. The tip led to him being observed, not being ported off to Gitmo. So it's no where near being "exactly" like these innocent people being sent to Gitmo. If anything, your only hurting your case by sensationalizing it. Does it not stand on it's own? That this was done with a GPS device as opposed to being tailed by people doesn't strike me as a big difference (if only that the GPS device is more accurate and less invasive).
- pyre 15y ago> That this was done with a GPS device as opposed to > being tailed by people doesn't strike me as a big > difference It's easier to do at scale. What's the difference between having a cop watch a street corner vs installing a security camera? You can install a lot of security cameras for the same cost as hiring a police officer or FBI agent. It's the same case here. They can track a lot more people via GPS devices when they don't have to pay for agents (agent salaries + car + gas) to tail someone. I mean, at ~$400 a pop, how many GPS devices can you get for the cost of a single agent? And a list of GPS coordinates is something that can easily be processed automatically to look for patterns.
- raganwald 15y agoThis is the key to the whole thing, and very much like what we observe with startups and disruption. Say you make something cheaper, and you increase demand. It gets cheaper, cheaper, and then suddenly it breaks into an entirely new market and demand goes through the roof. People invent new uses for it. Surveillance is like that. It’s more than just being cheaper than having an officer follow a suspect around. It has become so cheap that agencies can now (or will very soon) be able to simply follow everyone, everywhere, without the slightest need for justification. Collect all the data, store it away, and if you later suspect them of a crime, you can open up the archives and look at everywhere they have been and everything they have said in their entire lifetime. By following everyone, everywhere, law enforcement can effectively go back in time. Joe Blough is a drug dealer? Interesting. Whose car has been on his street in the past five years? Who called him and who did he call? Who is on his Facebook or in his Google+ circles? Look at that, he plays Settlers of Catan with Thomas Rapido. Pull up Tom's data. Interesting, he’s married but his car has spent a lot of time at stripper clubs. Bet his wife doesn’t know that, call him in and threaten to tell her if Tom doesn’t cooperate with us.