4 ms·
>However, it’s important to realize that environment is generally fairly constrained in these studies. A Twin study is hardly comparing Sierra Leone with Japan,
by gruez 4y ago
>However, it’s important to realize that environment is generally fairly constrained in these studies. A Twin study is hardly comparing Sierra Leone with Japan, or the Netherlands with North Korea. Extremes like iodine deficiency, disease, or fetal alcohol syndrome are similarly exclude.
except if you look at the other comparisons made (eg. "Unrelated children—Reared together—Adults "), the correlation factor can go quite a bit lower than 0.7-0.8 (eg. 0.04). The fact the correlation can go this low casts doubt on your theory that the environment is "constrained".
- Retric 4y ago0.04 seems unusually low I have seen studies more in line with this one: “Same person (tested twice) .95 Identical twins—Reared together .86 Fraternal twins—Reared together .55 Biological siblings—Reared together .47 Unrelated children—Reared together .30 Parent-child—Living together .42 Adoptive parent – child – Living together 0.19 Identical twins—Reared apart .76 Fraternal twins—Reared apart .35 Biological siblings—Reared apart .24” So siblings reared apart had less correlation than unrelated children living together.
- gpt5 4y agoUnfortunately, these numbers don't state the age of the child when they were tested, so they are not very useful.
- pyuser583 4y agoThey don’t state lots of other things. Like what “raised separate” means. Was one raised in a Soviet gulag while the other was raised in an Israeli kibbutz?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]