27 ms·
> Lucky for a start that he was born in the US not, say, the Congo. The US was created by its citizens. Any country can do that. As for Steve Jobs, I worked f
by WalterBright 4y ago
> Lucky for a start that he was born in the US not, say, the Congo.
The US was created by its citizens. Any country can do that.
As for Steve Jobs, I worked for a company in the 70's that had everything Jobs had - and much more. It could have easily become what Apple became. But what was missing was the company didn't have a Steve Jobs that had the vision to create what Apple created.
I'm sure there were many, many contemporary companies in the same boat - unable (in retrospect) to see their hand in front of their face.
I had many opportunities to become a billionaire. I didn't not because I was unlucky, but because I was stupid and unwilling to take the risk necessary.
- wwweston 4y ago> The US was created by its citizens. Any country can do that. Every country is, in aggregate, created by some portion of its citizens, but I don't think that necessarily implies every country has an equally plausible path to the positive social conditions of the US (in fact, it's an open question if the US has a plausible path to keeping its positive social conditions). There was a very narrow window of conditions that applied where enough enlightenment thinking, reflection on classical thinking, local colonial strength, and enough self-interest for a broad number of colonial Americans met a concept of the public good, and we still got a union that needs a hell of a lot of perfecting. If you take the culture of the early 19th century US and backport it to the late 18th, I'm not even sure you'd get anything half as enlightened. The point isn't that people shouldn't try, of course. The point is that even the state of a given functioning industrialized democracy is partly a matter of lots of factors that no one has control over, which makes it reasonable to describe them in terms of luck. > I had many opportunities to become a billionaire. I didn't not because I was unlucky, but because I was stupid and unwilling to take the risk necessary. It is wise to realize when one has lost a roll of the dice because of a passed opportunity to cast them. It's also wise to realize that luck would have played a role if you'd taken the opportunity.
- WalterBright 4y agoWhy is it wise to have a negative view of opportunities that present themselves? > that needs a hell of a lot of perfecting It still works better than any other system. It wasn't that many years ago where what to write on bathroom doors bubbled up to get the attention of the US President. Or the fake crisis that there are many very rich people in the US. Or the drama over who is bending the knee and who isn't. The fact is that many of our headline problems are trivial when put in historical context.
- wwweston 4y ago> Why is it wise to have a negative view of opportunities that present themselves? Recognizing that luck plays a role in the outcome of opportunity isn't a negative view, only an acknowledgment of what can't be controlled alongside what can, much like the one that you made tacitly when you used the term "risk." > It still works better than any other system. If we're speaking in general terms about market democracies, I sure know I like living in one, and yes, people living in most of those (including the US) could stand to appreciate how some things are actually working relatively especially by historical standards. On the other hand if we're speaking in specific terms about countries, there are others which get notably better metrics than the US on things like the economic freedom index, high net worth individuals per capita, life expectancy per health care dollar spent, or bankruptcies per capita, which indicates some pause about how strictly to regard "better than any other system" and further room for optimization that clearly has substantial positive impacts on quality & length of life elsewhere.
- WalterBright 4y agoThe economic freedom index weights various things, and while it's a stab at things, it's hardly definitive. The US is also working hard to wreck its market economy. It's a big economy with a lot of momentum, but fire enough arrows into it and it will die. > live expectancy per health care dollar spent Health care is so dominated by the government it can hardly be considered a market system anymore.
- ketralnis 4y ago> > Lucky for a start that he was born in the US not, say, the Congo. > The US was created by its citizens. Any country can do that. That's a very strong claim. Are you saying that Congo just doesn't want to be prosperous? That every country that isn't currently the richest in the world just... didn't decide to be become the richest in the world?
- WalterBright 4y agoThe path they chose is one that does not lead to prosperity. There's nothing inherently wrong with Congo or the Congo people. What I find most sad is how few people want to emulate the United States, and how many want to emulate disasters like the Soviet Union, Cuba, Venezuela, etc.
- robbiep 4y agoHave you looked at the United States recently?
- WalterBright 4y agoYes, and I see millions that are walking thousands of miles for a chance at getting in the US. What do you think they are seeing?
- robbiep 4y agoI see a borderline failed state. The fact people are rushing there from other failed states is no signifier of confidence as far as I’m concerned. Generally I see it as a warning sign for western ideals, and a great tragedy waiting to unfold if the shit hits the fan. When pressed, I’ll express my concern that a population of people who have had it so good for so long have done so little to agree about what it means to be human and autonomous and as a result have completely failed their founding fathers.
- WalterBright 4y ago
- ukulele 4y ago> The US was created by its citizens. I'm a US citizen, and I love the US and benefit from it, but I certainly didn't create it. That happened long before me -- I just lucked into it.
- WalterBright 4y agoIt was still created by its citizens. Any country can do it if its citizens have the will to. There's no law of nature preventing it. Modern Americans have a sad habit of trying to reframe the Founding Fathers as villainous.
- teh64 4y agoThe US was also created by its geography. Lots of space, lots of natural resources, etc... Even the best people can't make gold out of nothing, so to speak. Everyone can be the US sounds a lot like the Mitt Romney "I couldn't pay for college, so I sold some of my stocks to pay for it" [0]. It's quite out of touch to be born in the richest country and then be surprised why other countries can't make it. It "takes money to make money". Thats not the only criteria, but it helps quite a lot. [0] https://slate.com/business/2012/04/romney-sold-stock-to-pay-for-college.html https://slate.com/business/2012/04/romney-sold-stock-to-pay-...
- WalterBright 4y agoLook at the difference in outcomes between North and South America. Venezuela is resource rich. The country is mired in poverty. Russia, too. Japan is very resource poor - but they're a rich country. > Even the best people can't make gold out of nothing Yeah, they can. That's what the tech sector does.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]