3 ms·
> I have not seen a single case of a death pronouncement for COVID which has not unambiguously been from COVID. How about this one? https://wpde.com/news/natio
by josephcsible 4y ago
> I have not seen a single case of a death pronouncement for COVID which has not unambiguously been from COVID.
How about this one? https://wpde.com/news/nation-world/man-who-died-in-motorcycle-crash-counted-as-covid-19-death-in-florida-report-07-18-2020 https://wpde.com/news/nation-world/man-who-died-in-motorcycl...
- n8henrie 4y agoThe conversation was regarding my personal experiences as a physician caring for people dying of COVID, so I was using "seen" literally, not as in "read" or "heard of." Do you think that news report "moves the needle?" Did you read this part in the article you posted? "it is unclear whether or not his death was removed from the overall count in the state." Do you think that patients' right to privacy may make it difficult to know the details surrounding a death, leading to widespread, unfalsifiable, conspiratorial speculation?
- josephcsible 4y ago> The conversation was regarding my personal experiences as a physician caring for people dying of COVID, so I was using "seen" literally, not as in "read" or "heard of." Just because you've never seen something happen firsthand doesn't mean that it never happens, or even that it's particularly rare. For example, none of my computers have ever gotten ransomware, but I don't deny that ransomware is really common today. > Do you think that news report "moves the needle?" This feels like asking why you should bother voting, since one vote never really moves the needle by itself either. > Did you read this part in the article you posted? "it is unclear whether or not his death was removed from the overall count in the state." Yes, and it makes my point even stronger. Even for the most egregious, indefensible false COVID deaths like this one, we can't confirmation that they've actually been corrected. That leads me to think there's no hope whatsoever that any of the false ones that aren't this blatantly obvious will ever be corrected. > Do you think that patients' right to privacy may make it difficult to know the details surrounding a death, leading to widespread, unfalsifiable, conspiratorial speculation? If we can't get details of the death, why should we default to the assumption that it really was because of COVID?
- n8henrie 4y ago> Just because you've never seen something happen firsthand So are you arguing that, because I've never seen it, then it must be common? > I don't deny that ransomware is really common today. You'll need to be more precise for this to mean much of anything. I don't know a single person who has ever had a single personal computer affected by ransomware. Clearly ransomware must be a governmental conspiracy and/or the common flu. > This feels like asking why you should bother voting It wasn't intended to feel like that. It was intended to feel like asking whether you think one news report -- or even several individual news reports -- are meaningful evidence of widespread fraud in the setting of a very large denominator of deaths. > Yes, and it makes my point even stronger. No, it doesn't. It means your point may not be a point at all, and it seems like you have no evidence behind your speculation that this was ultimately counted as a COVID death. > If we can't get details of the death, why should we default to the assumption that it really was because of COVID? Do you really think that the details of an individual patient's medical record should be opened up to try (likely in vain) to satisfy the curiosity of some dude on HN -- who is likely so entrenched in his or her position that the results of the inquisition will be of little consequence regardless?
- josephcsible 4y ago> So are you arguing that, because I've never seen it, then it must be common? No. I'm saying that it's not necessarily rare just because you've never seen it. > You'll need to be more precise for this to mean much of anything. I don't know a single person who has ever had a single personal computer affected by ransomware. Clearly ransomware must be a governmental conspiracy and/or the common flu. You're making my point for me. I acknowledge ransomware is a real problem even though I've never personally been exposed to it. I'm saying you should acknowledge that incorrect COVID death labeling is a real problem even though you've never personally been exposed to it. > It was intended to feel like asking whether you think one news report -- or even several individual news reports -- are meaningful evidence of widespread fraud in the setting of a very large denominator of deaths. But the whole point is that the "very large denominator" is inflated and untrustworthy. > It means your point may not be a point at all, and it seems like you have no evidence behind your speculation that this was ultimately counted as a COVID death. We have solid evidence that it was originally counted as a COVID death. People then looked for evidence that it was ever corrected but failed to find any. How is that "no evidence behind [my] speculation"? > Do you really think that the details of an individual patient's medical record should be opened up to try (likely in vain) to satisfy the curiosity of some dude on HN -- who is likely so entrenched in his or her position that the results of the inquisition will be of little consequence regardless? Are you saying I should just blindly trust that all of the ones we don't have information on are correct? That seems like it'd be a stretch even if we didn't have any evidence that any were ever misclassified.