4 ms·
> Specific performance is drastic, and arguably unconstitutional in many contexts Specific performance is not all drastic (and not remotely arguably unconstitu
by dragonwriter 4y ago
> Specific performance is drastic, and arguably unconstitutional in many contexts
Specific performance is not all drastic (and not remotely arguably unconstitutional) in the case of agreements to transmit specific tangible or intangible property.
It is impermissible, and often argued further to be a violation of the 13th Amendment, for personal services contracts, but that’s not even remotely at issue here.
Now, arguably, since Musk’s end of the deal was to pay cash while Twitter’s end was to provide specific property, you can make the case that specific performance cannot be justified because Twitter can be made whole by a damage award, to wit, via compensatory damages equal to the difference between the amount of money Musk offered and the value of 100% of Twitter stock at the time damages are assessed.
> If Twitter is making a claim about how many actual human users it has (which it is doing by providing the number of users and saying 5% or less are bots), and that claim is materially false, that’s the ballgame.
That’s rather imprecisely worded (aside from also drastically factually misrepresenting the content of Twitter’s bot-related claims), and resolving that sloppiness in a way that is tolerably approximately true (aside, again, from the misrepresentation of what Twitter has actually claimed), “materially” is doing a lot of work in that sentence.
- roughly 4y agoAlso, to be clear, Twitter is not making a claim about how many actual human users it has - it is making a claim about how many actual human mDAU, or monetizable daily active users, it has. 90% of Twitter's users can be bots, as long as no more than half a percent or so of those are counted as mDAU.
- tveita 4y ago> Twitter can be made whole by a damage award, to wit, via compensatory damages equal to the difference between the amount of money Musk offered and the value of 100% of Twitter stock at the time damages are assessed. This sounds difficult to assess - the possibility of damages being awarded should itself be affecting the stock price. E.g. if you were 100% assured of a payout of $52.40 - stock price, the stock should trade for $52.40... but then the damages would be $0.
- dragonwriter 4y agoCourts routinely assess damages things for things like what profits the harmed party would have been made but for the wrongdoing which require projections of counterfactuals. By comparison, “$44 billion less however much the sum of all Twitter stock was worth at some designated time” is...not particularly difficult.
- torstenvl 4y agoI specifically noted that the constitutional arguments against specific performance most likely have no application here. Please don't truncate a quote so you can strawman someone.