7 ms·
Survivorship bias seems to play a huge role in VC too. A handful of individuals and firms got mega-rich with Facebook and then later with Uber, and now they ar
by paulpauper 4y ago
Survivorship bias seems to play a huge role in VC too. A handful of individuals and firms got mega-rich with Facebook and then later with Uber, and now they are held up as these huge geniuses. However, this is more luck than skill, because all oof their later investments have done much worse, so excluding Facebook and Uber, they are not so skilled. Now these same geniuses are hyping crypto , which has been a total disaster for half of 2021 and all 2022. Same for Softbank, which had a big winner with Ali Baba, but pretty much failed massively with later bets. Successes have many mothers, failure is an orphan, as it's said.
- jollybean 4y agoI believe the logic of VC investing is misplaced here. That their subsequent investments did worse than FB is not evidence of anything at all really. In particular, almost all VC fund returns are weighted towards a few big winners, some ok winners, a bunch of zombies and a lot of failures. There is a 'FB' in every successful VC fund. Most VC just didn't just magically appear as VCs and then magically/luckily invest in FB. It was a long path for most of those funds and individuals. There is luck involved, surely, which is why funds have a lot of companies in their portfolio.
- yomkippur 4y agoBut why is it that some VC are clearly better at this dice rolling? ex. Sequoia Again and again they seem to be able to discover these home runs or is it that they are able to use their vast network of influence to manufacture success? It all reminds me of poker. High stacks dictate/influence/restricts other participants with less stacks.
- azemetre 4y agoIt could be evidence that the idea of VCs may not be a reliable way of investing. Nassim Taleb stated that in 2009, within an 18 month window, banking industry lost all the profits it ever made since the beginning of banking as an industry. Such a catastrophic event isn't out of the question for VC either.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jdsully 4y ago> Such a catastrophic event isn't out of the question for VC either. It is out of the question with the current legal system. Because of limited liability for this to be true they would have to have invested more than the total profits. The individual investments could lose a lot of money but the VC loss is capped at their original investment.
- pessimizer 4y ago> There is a 'FB' in every successful VC fund. Tautologically. There isn't a facebook in any failing VC fund. So it's really unnecessary to talk about VC strategies at all if you're going to define a successful strategy as having once invested in some whale early and ignore all of the other failures, it's sufficient to just ask for a list of the investors in things that did well and declare them shrewd.
- jollybean 4y agoNot rally, if you take the reality of it a big further i.e. 'there is an FB in every vintage' or more like 'there are a 'few big hits' in every vintage' - you'll find that the pattern is repeated over and over by good VC's who can demonstrate their consistency.
- dandelany 4y agoThis. I always get annoyed when entrepreneurs eg. on Shark Tank say things like “I quit my job, took out two mortgages on my home, maxed out my credit cards and spent my kids’ college fund on the business. And look at us now, we’re making millions of dollars a year! Don’t give up when failure looks inevitable!” Probably most of the people who follow this advice to the letter end up financially ruined, they just don’t get a public platform to talk about it…
- gerdesj 4y agoQuite. I think Shark Tank is what we call Dragon's Den in the UK (bunch of civilians pitch to zillionares for cash and mentoring in return for a stake in the business - all on TV). You see some absolute horrors that inevitably will lead to bankruptcy. However you also see some clever folk getting a well deserved leg up. But I think we agree that for everyone that seems to effortlessly do the American Dream thing, there are 1000s or 100,000s that don't. Then there's the likes of me that have run a rather boring small business for 22 years turning over around £1.2M pa but not exactly setting the world on fire! I can sleep at night and have nearly no debt, so that's nice.
- hvs 4y agoMaybe it's just me getting older, but running a successful small business that pays the bills and supports my family into retirement is what I would consider the paradigm of success for my life. Congrats on your business.
- nostromo 4y agoI just want to point out that you’re living the American Dream. I think you may misunderstand the term as it’s generally used. The phrase isn’t about becoming a billionaire. It’s rooted in the American frontier period, inspired by Protestant values, and is much more aligned with living a happy upper-middle-class life: owning land, a home, enough resources to have a family, and having meaningful or productive work.
- ROTMetro 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- abraxas 4y agoMoreover, just with the sheer count of VCs, stock investors and other sorts that play with their (or more often other people's) money to try and earn outsized profits, it is inevitable that a small sliver of them will be wildly successful. It's a statistical certainty. It's like having a million people toss coins all day and then hail as geniuses those who got twenty heads in a row. There is an excellent book by Nassim Taleb that expands on this theme titled "Fooled By Randomness".
- WalterBright 4y agoThe ones who don't toss coins all day have zero chance of getting lucky.
- z3t4 4y agoBut there is an opportunity cost to tossing coins all day.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 4y agoCan't win the lottery if you don't play either, but that doesn't mean playing the lottery is a good idea.
- WalterBright 4y agoSuccessful people toss coins in games where the odds are in their favor. Saying if they win it's just luck is pedantically true, but if you keep playing those kind of games you'll win. Keep playing the lottery, and you will lose. Successful people I know don't buy lottery tickets.
- ekianjo 4y ago> Successful people I know don't buy lottery tickets. Are we talking about typical "work hard, relatively successful people in middle class" or "extremely rich people" here? Because the latter, I can guarantee, is typically due to pure luck, despite all what we want to believe.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- throwoutway 4y ago100% spot on. It's like Jim Cramer and Mad Money. His stock picks are terrible compared to the index/average, yet he somehow has a following (and a show) https://www.ifa.com/articles/cramer_chasing_mad_money/ https://www.ifa.com/articles/cramer_chasing_mad_money/
- ilrwbwrkhv 4y agocough Peter Thiel cough The fact that there is a whole cottage industry around his thinking makes me laugh.