3 ms·
Chromebook pros: - Digital experiences can offer different learning formats which might work better for a subset of kids. Cons: - Having computers in the cla
by metadat 4y ago
Chromebook pros:
- Digital experiences can offer different learning formats which might work better for a subset of kids.
Cons:
- Having computers in the classroom is a huge distraction, and not a valuable use of time for teachers to have to manage on top of everything else; kids constantly abuse the privilege and goof off instead of paying attention to the lesson. Teachers can either fail at their job and ignore it, or must constantly monitor and police all the screens while they are teaching. As if it's not already hard enough to manage the class?
- Chromebooks are expensive for school districts, they pay large ongoing sums of money to Google for the G-Suite SaaS contracts, too. They're not getting a great deal, districts often don't even have the expertise to evaluate if it's cost effective or not.
- Chromebooks get filthy and gross, with kid sludge and boogers and whatever else. Who should be tasked with cleaning them?
- Chromebooks result in excessive, unnecessary e-waste. Google offers updates for only a few years before deprecating them. They only run a web browser, but somehow they must be EOLd after only 5 years? Ok..
How about bringing back the books and chalkboards? Ill-informed parents would probably freak out and have a meltdown, thinking their kid is getting a second rate education without the stupid Chromebook during school time.
We are stuck in the minima of a very local function. So dumb.
This isn't the biggest problem though, it's the US public education system that created and enables all this, constantly making changes to curriculae and requirements in a non data-driven way.
- josephcsible 4y ago> somehow they must be EOLd after only 5 years? I have a Chromebook that was released in 2019 and will get updates until 2027, so there's definitely not a rule that they can only get updates for 5 years.
- metadat 4y agoSounds like you got a nice one! How much money and resources do you think goog is spending on an ongoing basis to ensure they sell fewer Chromebooks to schools (and in general) in the future? It's much easier (and more profitable / less expensive) from a program management perspective to instead deprecate the bulk of these cheap machines after five years to ensure "consistent user experience". I hope I'm wrong! My experience with capitalism tells me I'm probably not. Less e-waste isn't profitable in the short to medium term. :(
- Brian_K_White 4y agoThey don't make money on the hardware and have no incentive to make the subscription look like a bad deal because of short hardware life cycle. The hardware manufacturer is a different story. They love nothing better than to collect a laptop price tag on a laptop replacement schedule while only having to deliver a chromebook performance and absolutely zero os/software related customer support or windows license.
- er4din 4y agoYeah aren’t the machines themselves made by Lenovo? Google just makes the chromeOs?
- Brian_K_White 4y agoSeveral different manufacturers make chromebooks.
- fuzzythinker 4y agoOne more con. The screen is very bad. My kid's came new, but it looked worst than the 90s non-active matrix laptop I had. I wouldn't stand more than a few minutes on it. I guess kids have good enough eyes to not affect them too much. But maybe it speeds up their eyes' wear and tear. Hope kids won't be using it more than an hour or so a day.
- sliken 4y agoChromebooks are expensive? Do you have numbers? Unlike Windows or OSX where you need an IT guy for a school district, the chrome OS doesn't really require a full time staff. Generally if it dies, you hand the student a new one. Most of the work is tracking inventory. No testing, no production, no app installs, no backups, no training (at least for students), no managing licenses, no maintaining a custom collection of apps, etc. Would macbooks or windows boxes be plausibly cheaper in any way? Seems like most highschools give freshman a new chromebook, and then offer to sell it to the student for $25-$75 when they graduate. Said laptops often live on supporting the student or the student's family. My kid just graduated and is quite fond of her chromebook. It's pretty low power (some arm variant), 4gb ram, pretty durable case, and I expect it to live on for a few more years. Sure chromebooks can get gross, but that's really only a issue if you plan to give them to multiple people. The laptop we got came with a get to know your laptop card that showed you how to recover from pouring a soda on your keyboard, generally open, shake, and don't close the lid for a few hours. Teachers can still use books and chalkboards, up to them. But using google apps is a useful skill and using them to turn in homework seems to work really well. The use of chromebooks during class was limited for my kid, but depended on heavily for homework, research, etc.
- er4din 4y agoI went to a school where we used chrome books. We paid a 500 euro deposit I believe upfront and signed a contract that obliged us to use the machine appropriately and that any damage resulting from failing to do so is our fault yada yada. By the end of the curriculum the computer moves into being our own property and the school wipes it from the network so to speak and it’s factory reset. The reality is that at this point it’s a piece of old junk that no one wants since it’s been in constant use for like 4 years, and yes I went to a privileged school which hopped onto the idea as soon as it was publicly available. I talked to our it department and they confirm the fact that chrombooks make the back end work of the it department so so so much easier, as does the rest of the google interface. They no longer deal with individual account backups, data storage and network access, being able to focus on what is accessible from the school network and solving hardware problems with the machines themselves, as well as some additional maintenances on PC systems that were present I. Every classroom dedicated to each teacher which we’re not chrome books but ran windows 7 instead, up until a year or 2 ago I believe. Chrome books have an arguably larger upfront cost bit a reduced maintenance cost which may make them more economical depending on the scale you work on and you budget. As I said I went to a privileged school with around 1k kids as of last year I believe so it may have been a good choice there, the school is not in Denmark btw. I personally am more interested in knowing what are the alternative options to the chrome books that denmarkian schools can switch to now that chrome books are out of the picture, because let’s face it, we’re not going to back to pen and paper days because of this. I found some HP made notepads that run windows 10 and are visually resembling chrome books in addition to being in the same price range of 400 euro. Does anyone have any better guesses as to what the switch could be made to?