9 ms·
The most eye-opening thing I've learned about relativity in the past few years is that the notion that space has no preferential direction is an axiom in the th
by shadowgovt 4y ago
The most eye-opening thing I've learned about relativity in the past few years is that the notion that space has no preferential direction is an axiom in the theory.
There's nothing about the way we measure the speed of light that would disambiguate if light traveled instantaneously in one direction and at half the measured speed of light in the other. We just don't have a way to know, because time measurements require information to re-converge at the original site of the experiment's beginning.
It's a pretty good axiom, because we also have no reason to believe there's a preferred direction in space... But it's an axiom.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- qsdf38100 4y agoVeritasium has a nice video about it on YouTube. We can only measure the average back and forth speed of light.
- gnramires 4y agoI'm not sure that claim is true. Take this experiment, where A sends B a message following two paths: /-->--B (/ and \ are mirrors) | | | | \--<--A with speeds: (assume lengths are all 1m) /--cr--B | | cu cu | | \--cl--A The time it takes for path 1 (left,up,right) is cl+cu+cr. The time it takes for path 2 is cu. B can measure the difference cl+cu+cr-cu = cl+cr. A can compare cl+cr to cu: if cl+cr != 2cu the velocity is not isotropic. To see that's always possible, A and B can simply bounce back path 2, so B receives pulses every 2cu (and hence can measure and compare to other time intervals). Directional speed of light would be very weird, I think it'd show up everywhere in experiments if it weren't true. --- Also, I think there's a notable distinction in physics: they are usually called postulates to distinguish from axioms. A postulate is an assumption about a physical theory (usually something simple and "beautiful" -- mathematically neat and satisfying Occam's razor); if a theory doesn't match reality, one of its postulates is incorrect. An axiom in mathematics of course can't be proven wrong. Because axioms are the basis for your mathematical theory describing reality, they can't be incorrect (as long as they form a mathematically consistent theory); the most could happen is they're insufficient to describe reality (you need other axioms and another mathematical theory), but they're not (somewhat) falsifiable in the sense of physical postulates.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kortilla 4y agoYour experiment doesn’t verify that cr = cl nor does it verify cu = cd.
- qsdf38100 4y agoI think you assume one can measure the time between two events at different locations. I believe Einstein proved you can’t because there’s no way to truly synchronize clocks at different locations. Another way to say it is that there’s no instantaneous "now" that all observers can agree on. In special relativity, "now" is meaningless. Or rather, "now" depends on the observer’s inertial frame of reference. There’s a nice diagram one can plot, with 1 dimension of space and 1 dimension of time, that shows lines of simultaneous events based on the velocity of a moving observer in another frame of reference.
- db48x 4y agoCorrect, cl+cr = 2cu is the best you can measure. But it doesn’t follow that cl = cr! Assume a linear transformation like αcl+βcr = 2cu, where α and β tell you how the speed of light varies in between left and right. We simply assume that α = β = 1.0, but what if α=½ and β=³⁄₂? Or α=2 and β=0? A long as α + β = 2.0, then everything will look exactly the same.
- x3n0ph3n3 4y agoThat video was pretty bad, though. It completely ignores everything we know about the CMB. If it were true that the speed of light was different in different directions, the CMB would look very different.
- raattgift 4y agoNo disagreement on what you write, but the CMB spectrum is about as useless as radiocarbon dating for deciding which of two Hydrogen maser clocks on opposite sides of a university laboratory is wrong when they differ by ten nanoseconds. However, we can generalize your point and say that real configurations of matter let us make those decisions reasonably and with good accuracy. (The BIPM UTC Circular-T contributors seem to manage fine, as do the various GNSS operators). If the video had taken care to set their experiment in vacuum flat spacetime (perturbed only by the experiment), as the shown Einstein 1905 work <https://www.fourmilab.ch/etexts/einstein/specrel/ https://www.fourmilab.ch/etexts/einstein/specrel/> (top of p. 3) did, it would be better. That's because that setting offers no convenient-to-agree way to slice spacetime into space and time. The CMB does, but we suffer from practical limits on measuring the CMB's blackbody temperature.
- kergonath 4y ago> Veritasium has a nice video about it on YouTube. He is often wrong in subtle and not—subtle ways, though. In this case, regardless of the issue of one-way measurements of c, his sources do not really support an anisotropy in the speed of light. His video was mentioned already 5 or 6 times here. Isn’t here anything better at all?
- qubex 4y agoThat’s not an axiom, it’s an assumption. Anyway, it’s the assumption of isotropy.
- naasking 4y agoAn axiom is an assumption: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Axiom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Axiom
- qubex 4y agoIt’s a matter of scope. Axioms are assumptions that undergird the formal edifice (those or mathematics or arithmetic) whereas assumptions are local to the theory. ‘Assumptions’ is a synonym of ‘postulates’. Axioms are foundational, such as m×n=m×n (which is true for scalars, but not true in general for matrices).
- codethief 4y ago> But it's an axiom. I don't agree. If light traveled instantaneously in one direction, then if we looked in the opposite direction (where such light originates from) we would be seeing stars and galaxies at much more recent time (now). Also, their light would have traveled a much longer distance (due to the ongoing expansion of space) and so would be redshifted much more. All in all what we see on the sky would look very differently in terms of redshifts, matter distribution and so on – unless of course there's no isotropy, i.e. unless there's some cosmos-sized conspiration that fine-tuned matter distribution, distances etc. in such a way that the universe looked isotropic to us even though it is not.
- codethief 4y ago> Also, their light would have traveled a much longer distance (due to the ongoing expansion of space) and so would be redshifted much more. I need to correct myself: If light traveled instantaneously, the expansion of space wouldn't matter because in the very instant in which light would be traveling space wouldn't be expanding. -> No redshift at all.
- tasty_freeze 4y agoI get what you are saying, it suggests there is no preferred direction, but it is just an inference. The point is one cannot create an experiment to measure the speed of light other than a round trip average speed.
- CamperBob2 4y agoWasn't that the whole idea behind Michelson-Morley ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michelson%E2%80%93Morley_experiment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michelson%E2%80%93Morley_exper...)?
- db48x 4y agoYes, that is an example of a measurement of the two-way speed of light. What is impossible, however, is a measurement of the one-way speed of light.
- alex_smart 4y agoCould you not, at least theoretically, create two synchronized clocks and physically transport one of them to another location and then throw a beam of light from the location of the first clock and measure the time of arrival at the second clock? Am I missing something? Edit: What I was missing was time dilation. Physically transporting the clocks would mean that they are no longer synchronized.
- bee_rider 4y agoLike 75% of my intro to modern physics class was "Couldn't you just <thing that results in further relativistic weirdness>." Not sure it lead to the most well-founded understanding of relativity, but I was an engineering major -- if engineers have to correct for relativity, probably the device is operating very out of spec (ignoring very specific, well understood cases).
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoBut can't you still do it? It just takes a long time to set up. That is: I synchronize two clocks at a particular point. I then move one clock to the other end of the apparatus (which could be multiple kilometers away). Now, there are three "time dilations" that I have to worry about: 1. Gravitational red shift. I can avoid this by having both ends of the experiment, and the path the clock takes to move from one to the other, all be at the same gravitational potential. 2. Special relativity time dilation. I can minimize (not totally avoid) this one by moving the clock slowly with respect to the stationary one. 3. General relativity time dilation. I can minimize (again, not totally avoid) this one by accelerating the moving clock slowly. By taking enough time to set up the experiment, can't I minimize all three of those far enough that I can tell that the speed of light is the same in both directions (to some error margin, still, but better than "I can't tell if it's instantaneous in one direction")?
- raattgift 4y agoThe problem is probably insoluble in Special Relativity alone*, because of the available clock-synchronization schemes in a universe populated only by the self-contained experimental apparatus (sender + local clock, receiver + local clock), experimental pulse of light, and flashing-light morse code or whatever to compare timestamps. If we are allowed to add more matter of our choosing, we can probably measure the one-way delay with good precision. The absence of gravitational sources is an aspect of the flat spacetime of Special Relativity, but if we are cheating by adding in (and declaring gravitationally negligible) the experimental apparatus, why can't we cheat by adding in a non-gravitationally evolving bit of matter which can serve as a clock? A low-mass, sparse, spherical, uniform cloud of of hot dust expanding adiabatically can serve as a clock by measuring its and temperature if the one-way-transmitter and one-way-receiver are freely falling within it and moving slowly compared to light. This is essentially a demotion of the sparse cosmic microwave background gas/dust of massless photons -> sparse gas/dust of neutral low-mass molecules. The CMB expands and cools, while we're within it. Our non-relativistic molecular gas expands and cools, while our one-way test equipment is within it. Of course, what is too much of a cheat in Special Relativity and what is not is debatable. In all the cases above we are ignoring the Raychaudhuri equation with the only justifications being that the timescales are too long to tell if we're focusing, and we aren't obviously engaging post-Newtonian (PN) corrections. (What gets us into trouble with PN formalisms in GR can get us into trouble in gravitation-free SR though: ultraboost one side of the experiment, rather than "... moving the clock slowly with respect to the stationary one". You guessed correctly that boosts and accelerations could be a problem in (2)&(3). However, contra your (3) acceleration is perfectly permissible in "pure" SR and the result is only equivalent to being in a uniform gravitational field (rather than with a potential gradient), and only somewhat briefly (you can rest your clock on an enormous rocky planet for much longer than you can accelerate your clock at ~ 10 g). The time dilation in (3) is Minkowski / Born / von Laue / Einstein 1905-1911 Special Relativistic and not post-1915 General Relativitistic. Your (1) is done for you for free in "pure" SR, since there is no gravitation there.) General relativity is hardly a panacea: if we have a strongly expanding vacuum our one way pulse might never reach the detector. In a dynamical curved spacetime we can break the symmetry between legs of a reflection 2-way test in any number of ways. It's really the breaking of the vacuum condition that lets us set up a "global" or at least wide-enough-area clock. When we're allowed to introduce half-life decays or thinning background matter or radiation, or distant millisecond pulsars, we are more likely to be able to use a synchronization scheme sufficiently different from Einstein's method and successfully compare timestamps at the sender and receiver of a one-way flash. - -- * If we assume Special Relativity then we already have global Poincaré invariance, so we have already have symmetrical legs of a reflection test. If we have a setting which is maybe Minkowski spacetime, or maybe something other than Minkowski space that breaks the symmetry of the legs in a reflection test, then we probably can't do it with a one-way test along the lines you're thinking.
- nine_k 4y agoIf there is an experiment that could detect the discrepancy, it's no longer an axiom, and can be falsified. If there's no such experiment, it just means that for all intents and purposes, light travels at the "same speed" in any direction for an observer inside our Universe, because the speed of light is how we measure time in the first place. If an outside observer could notice that our spacetime is non-uniform, it's a fun thing to contemplate, but it does not change anything for us inside.
- sytelus 4y agoIt's a great axiom until it isn't. One thing I still cannot visualize is exapanding universe. If there is an expanstion then there must be a shape and then there must be a center and then must be one direction that is not exactly same as another because expansion rates are different. I read that universe expands same everywhere and there is no "center" which is very hard to visualize but it is a requirement for this axiom to be true. If you think in these terms, this axiom seems very problematic.
- pdonis 4y ago> If there is an expanstion then there must be a shape and then there must be a center However intuitively plausible this seems to you, it's still false. The fact that our intuitive visualization capabilities cannot directly visualize the mathematical entities involved does not change that.
- adelarsq 4y agoAt same time that a center does not exists it exists. Take a line between the two sides from the theoretical border, divide in the middle and will be a center. But isn't a center.
- pdonis 4y ago> Take a line between the two sides from the theoretical border There is no "border" to our universe. The fact that you have trouble visualizing such models does not mean they don't exist.
- tick_tock_tick 4y agoThere is an "effective" border because of speed of light limits. Technically we are "at the center" of our intractable universe.
- pdonis 4y ago> Technically we are "at the center" of our intractable universe. We are at the center of our observable universe, yes, but that fact does not support any of the claims I have been responding to in this thread.
- pdonis 4y ago> The most eye-opening thing I've learned about relativity in the past few years is that the notion that space has no preferential direction is an axiom in the theory. No, it's not. It's a geometric property of particular solutions in the theory. Those solutions include the ones we use to describe the universe as a whole. But there are plenty of other solutions that don't have this property. (For example, the family of solutions that describe black holes.) > There's nothing about the way we measure the speed of light that would disambiguate if light traveled instantaneously in one direction and at half the measured speed of light in the other. You're confusing two different concepts here. The concept of spatial isotropy, which is what "space has no preferential direction" refers to, is different from the concept that the one-way speed of light could vary by direction. The first concept, spatial isotropy, is an invariant concept: it's a geometric property that either is or is not possessed by particular solutions of the Einstein Field Equation. The second concept, anisotropy of the one-way speed of light, is not an invariant concept or a geometric property: it's an artifact of your choice of coordinates. You can take a spacetime that is spatially isotropic, and choose coordinates on it that make it seem like the one-way speed of light varies by direction. Or you can take a spacetime that is not spatially isotropic, and choose coordinates on it that make it seem like the one-way speed of light does not vary by direction. So the one-way speed of light is simply the wrong thing to think about.
- codethief 4y agoThe distincion you're making between isotropy of space and isotropy of the speed of light is important but I don't think the following is true: > The second concept, anisotropy of the one-way speed of light, is not an invariant concept or a geometric property: it's an artifact of your choice of coordinates. You can take a spacetime that is spatially isotropic, and choose coordinates on it that make it seem like the one-way speed of light varies by direction. We are not talking about coordinate speed here, we are talking about the light cone looking different, depending on which direction you go. This is (or would be) a geometric / invariant property.
- pdonis 4y ago> We are not talking about coordinate speed here, we are talking about the light cone looking different, depending on which direction you go. Before you could even test for this, you would need to come up with a consistent mathematical model of it and show how it's different from the mathematical models in standard GR. Otherwise you won't even know what to test for. Note that in standard GR, models that do not have isotropy of space also do not necessarily have the "isotropy of light cones" that you describe, at least not once you go beyond a single local patch of spacetime that is small enough for curvature to be ignored. I'm not aware of any such mathematical model that is different from standard GR.
- 323 4y agoWhy is it a requirement for the experiment information to get back to the originating point right away? We do all the time experiments where the information is re-converged much later, even months later like at the LHC. We tested many times the speed of light on earth, and we know that so far no directional speed difference was detected over earthly distances, which you say it's an impossible statement to make.
- snarfy 4y agoWe've never actually measured the speed of light in one direction. It's impossible. Vertasium video on the subject - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pTn6Ewhb27k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pTn6Ewhb27k
- x3n0ph3n3 4y agoIf it were true that the speed of light is different in different directions, the CMB would look completely different than it does. This was a major oversight in Veritasium's video.
- oldandtired 4y agoNot at all. You are applying an assumption for which you cannot actually determine is true or false. That assumption is that we could measure the differences because we would see a "linear" flow (using the word linear is the sense that it is anything that is not radially determined). What it boils down to is that it is not a measurable quantity (the one way speed of light).
- codethief 4y agoI'm not following and, so far, strongly agree with the parent here (the fact that Veritasium didn't mention the CMB a single time really surprised me when I watched the video for the first time). Why wouldn't we be able to measure the differences in the CMB, depending on the direction? What do you mean by "linear flow"?
- lamontcg 4y agoI know that classical rotational symmetry leads to conservation of angular momentum by Noether's theorem. I suspect if you break the rotational symmetry of the speed of light that you wind up breaking something like conservation of quantum spin angular momentum and the universe rapidly becomes nonsensical.
- tagrun 4y agoPhysicist here. It's not an axiom, historically, it follows from Michelson-Morley experiments, which precede special relativity, and whose purpose was to detect such an isotropy. They repeated the experiment during different times of the day and different seasons, since the velocity of the Earth (and the lab) relative to the hypothetical aether would be different. The working assumption was that Galilean relativity was correct, and the Maxwell equations (which also define the speed of light) were only valid in the special reference frame of the aether. Special relativity assumes Maxwell equations are always correct in all reference frames and orientations, which was already an experimentally observed fact (albeit puzzling, back then), rather than an axiom, which implied that it is Galilean relativity that is broken and needs to be refined.
- blueplanet200 4y agoEx-physicist here. This is not true. See https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pTn6Ewhb27k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pTn6Ewhb27k for an explanation. You can have a spatially asymmetric speed of light and be perfectly in line with every experiment to date. The speed of light appearing constant in every inertial reference frame is experimentally verified and measured. But it's an axiom that the speed of light has no spatial preference. Each measurement of the speed of light sneaks in this axiom in subtle ways. I think you misinterpreted the parent's point. They weren't saying c being a constant in all reference frames is an axiom. Rather, they were saying that it's convention that c doesn't have a spatial, directional, preference. It's a different claim.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tagrun 4y agoWhat is not true? You can't have reference frame independent (which is a term that also includes orientations) Maxwell equations and anisotropic speed of light at the same time. If Maxwell equations are correct (which was already well-tested by then), speed is already the same for forward and backward propagating electromagnetic waves (=light), and there is no other spatial anisotropy either. Differing one-way speed of light is an amusing "loophole" in the experiments measuring the speed of light (which requires one particular magical angular distribution of c to slip through a Michelson-Morley interferometer) but never existed in the theory that directly predicted it to begin with, so if you insist on it, one needs to ask how would that even work with the rest of physics? c doesn't have a spatial/direction preference in electrodynamics or quantum electrodynamics, vacuum permeability and permittivity (\mu_0 and \epsilon_0) don't have any observed spatial dependence. (Such a thing happens in condensed matter systems, effective mass, vacuum permittivity, g-factor, etc etc are in general anistroptic due to the medium, and is easily detectable, and their spatial derivatives do show up and need to be taken into account to match the observations as in the case of the kinetic term -\hbar^2(d/dx)(1/2m(x))(d/dx). Coulomb force doesn't get stronger or weaker when you rotate the table you perform your experiments on, current carrying wires don't produce stronger magnetic fields as you change their orientation (at least not within any observed precision). Similar goes for any field theory in the standard model. I should add that in terms of experimental precision, quantum electrodynamics is the most accurate theory that we have, and can put very strong limits on possible anisotropic deviations if any.
- kergonath 4y ago> the notion that space has no preferential direction is an axiom in the theory. This was the case in special relativity, with a flat space-time. In general relativity, space-time is curved and there are locally special directions. The laws of Physics still do not define special directions a priori. It is quite fundamental actually, and so far everything behaves as expected, at least in this respect. It is not as much an axiom as a consequence of Maxwell’s equations, from which we can deduce that light has a well-defined velocity in vacuum, irrespective of location or direction. > There's nothing about the way we measure the speed of light that would disambiguate if light traveled instantaneously in one direction and at half the measured speed of light in the other. There is something I don’t get here. If we shine a light on a detector, we can measure the time the light takes to reach the detector. Are you saying that the light hits the detector instantly, and then goes back to the source, or that the detector is the source and the light comes back to it after hitting the source instantly? In practice, the speed of light does not depend on direction, as far as we can measure.
- oldandtired 4y agoIf you shine a light on a detector, you measure the time it takes to travel both legs. What is being said is that all we can know is the average time from when it leaves us to when it gets back to us (i.e. the sensor results). It could well be the same magnitude each direction or it could be instantaneous one way and 1/2 c back the other or any other combination of values as long as the average of the two way measurement is c. Final note: the value that we put as c is only true in a very specific environment. It depends on the characteristics of the medium through which light is traveling as to what we will measure as the average two way speed. This is a consequence of the permeability and the permittivity of the medium through which the light is traveling. This is standard electrical engineering fare.
- raattgift 4y ago>> If we shine a light on a detector, we can measure the time the light takes to reach the detector. Are you saying that the light hits the detector instantly, and then goes back to the source, or that the detector is the source and the light comes back to it after hitting the source instantly? > If you shine a light on a detector, you measure the time it takes to travel both legs. reflector, surely, rather than detector? Your director can record a timestamp locally while you and your flashlight are across the room. You don't need two legs. The main objection upthread is that while your flashlight's "on" switch can also record a timestamp within the flashlight, synchronizing the flashlight's time to the detector's time so that one can compare the timestamps after the experiment is done (or days later, or weeks later, again and again) is not feasible within the framework of Special Relativity. Therefore if one has confidence in one's local timestamps, one can compare them when measuring the round trip of the flashlight beam reflected off a mirror across the room back onto a detector mounted right beside the flashlight's bulb, inside the flashlight. However, nature provides several gravitationally-driven systems which can provide a "preferred foliation", or a naturally-produced easily-compared timestamp. Examples include fancy sundials (including observations of millisecond pulsars), lunisolar tides, and the cosmological scale factor. These can be recovered independently in a (probably pretty large) flashlight and the detector looking for the light from the flashlight. Timestamps can then be compared with greater precision than available via Special Relativity synchronization methods. Indeed, this is something that has been worked on in lunar-ranging experiments over the past decades. Can we use detailed knowledge of the solar system to predict a signal aimed Earthward by a 21st century space probe on or very near the moon as well as a signal launched from Earth to a reflector on the moon that is picked up by a detector on Earth? It turns out we can, to good precision! > Final note "c" is the free parameter of the Lorentz group, which is the fundamental isometry group of Special Relativity (and quantum electrodynamics and the Standard Model of particle physics). "c" is also a constant in the Einstein Field Equations of General Relativity, and there is a mathematical connection between that and Special Relativity. In both theories, unless interfered with by interaction with matter, massless objects are constrained to move, obligatorily, from one spacetime point to another point from a restricted set of neighbours. These points are on the surface of a null cone. Light is experimentally massless, so null curves are often called lightlike curves, null cones are usually called light cones, and so on. However, electromagnetic radiation is not the only massless species in the cosmos. > very specific environment An excellent approximation of vacuum (very long mean free paths for electromagnetic radiation at all frequencies) dominates the observable universe, so the permeability and permittivity of free space is a good choice except in very specific environments (planet-bound electrical engineering laboratories and copper wires are out-volumed by intergalactic, or even interplanetary, space by a lot). In those matter-rich environments, the mean free path of light is low. The constant c remains the same in such matter-rich environments, but electromagnetic radiation passing through them does not propagate at c. > the value that we put as c is exactly 1. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geometrized_unit_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geometrized_unit_system>