3 ms·
This feels dubious to me (edit: and I was right, the headline is a lie, pretending a warning about a potential future problem has already happened) Does smart
by ZeroGravitas 4y ago
This feels dubious to me (edit: and I was right, the headline is a lie, pretending a warning about a potential future problem has already happened)
Does smart mean internet connected? I guess I'm impressed if they have 40% market penetration. But the behaviour of having a default time to turn on describes pretty much every timer based thermostat. One of the big sales pitches of 'smart' thermostats was that thermostats with timers were too hard for normal people to set up and so their potential gains went unused. So if people are literally reducing their energy usage during the night as a result of 'smart' thermostats then that's a good thing.
Ah, you don't have to read beyond the abstract to see how it's been misrepresented:
> We find that despite lowering overall energy consumption
Lets just pause a moment and take in the full impact of that opener....
> smart thermostat control algorithms can severely increase the winter peak heating demand through load synchronization during the early morning hours, when solar energy is unavailable.
Note the use of the word can and peak here. And that it says elsewhere that wind is available at this time.
And the solution they propose, is to make the thermostats 'smarter' with regard to carbon intensity and predicted supply/demand which is the whole reason for having a smart thermostat connected to the internet in the first place.
Vague negative lies about anything that stops fossil fuels getting burnt is a real weird feature of our current society. It's like you've offended someone's god or something by suggesting burning less of an expensive poison is a good thing.
This is their open source code btw: https://github.com/zlee406/smart-heat https://github.com/zlee406/smart-heat
- _aavaa_ 4y ago> And the solution they propose, is to make the thermostats 'smarter' with regard to carbon intensity and predicted supply/demand which is the whole reason for having a smart thermostat connected to the internet in the first place. My current "smart" thermostat does not take into account other people's energy usage. It's known when I'm not home and doesn't heat/cool as much then. They address this directly in the paper: > Fig. 2 shows that on average, smart thermostats tend to use setbacks at night and during the workday, likely in an attempt to save energy. [...] From a thermodynamics perspective, setbacks can only reduce energy consumption to the extent that they can reduce the average indoor temperature, and thus the building’s heat loss, assuming the heat pump efficiency remains constant. While setbacks can certainly reduce the instantaneous energy consumption in the short term, recovering to original indoor temperature requires an almost equivalent amount of additional energy consumption, with the only total energy savings being from the reduced heat loss from the temporary reduction in indoor temperature.
- ZeroGravitas 4y ago> From a thermodynamics perspective, setbacks can only reduce energy consumption to the extent that they can reduce the average indoor temperature, and thus the building’s heat loss, assuming the heat pump efficiency remains constant. While setbacks can certainly reduce the instantaneous energy consumption in the short term, recovering to original indoor temperature requires an almost equivalent amount of additional energy consumption, with the only total energy savings being from the reduced heat loss from the temporary reduction in indoor temperature. That is some very fancy bullshit. They're saying that lowering your thermostat only helps because less heat is lost to the environment. Yes, that is why it helps, it's not a perpetual motion machine or a magic trick, it's a slight efficiency improvement that can pay for itself in a year or so because you burn less fossil fuels as a result and then leaves you with a remote control thermostat that can talk to the grid for further benefits.
- _aavaa_ 4y ago> it's a slight efficiency improvement that can pay for itself in a year or so because you burn less fossil fuels as a result and then leaves you with a remote control thermostat that can talk to the grid for further benefits. Except they currently don't talk to the grid. And the question to ask is does that efficiency improvement outweigh the current increase in emissions by people's houses all heating/cooling themselves in the same time period resulting in increases in peak demand.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoI would be surprised if you could find one name brand smart thermostat that doesn't have deals with local grid providers to modulate loads during peaks. At its most basic it's just looking up the local Time of Use rates. They still have benefits (both eco and cash saving) if your local provider is stuck in the stone age, but this is one of the prime motivations for them existing in the first place. Here's the related page for the specific devices the paper's data source uses: https://www.ecobee.com/en-us/utilities/ https://www.ecobee.com/en-us/utilities/
- mindslight 4y agoAlso, what are the specific loads being synchronized that's the problem? Bulk heating in the northeast is generally oil/gas. Are there enough heat pumps in New York to be significant? Or do boiler/furnace pump/blower motors have enough of a draw to cause a problem? Or are they just speculating that when there are lots of heat pumps this will become a problem? As someone that tends towards a later schedule and generally bumps up against a lot of "early worms" thinking everyone is fully awake at 9AM, I'd cackle with glee if not needing to pay more for peak before-dawn electricity was something that worked out in my favor for once.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoGiven the title of the paper: > Unintended consequences of smart thermostats in the transition to electrified heating I'm assuming they're predicting this will be a potential problem in future, once everyone uses heat pumps, if none of the obvious solutions that everyone knows about aren't put in place by then. But phrasing it as if it's already happening for greater clickbait. It's the home heating equivalent of "if every person in the world had an EV and they all rapid charged them at the exact same second, it would use <silly amount>Watts and the grid would melt". Yes, that's probably true, but it's not going to happen is it. In reality, EVs and heat pumps that talk to the grid make it easier and cheaper to integrate renewables and burn less fossil fuels on top of just being more efficient.
- atwood22 4y ago> So if people are literally reducing their energy usage during the night as a result of 'smart' thermostats then that's a good thing. That is a good thing, but the power grid needs enough capacity to meet peak demand, so if these thermostats are making peak demand higher than they might actually be making things worse.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoBut in reality the do the exact opposite and reduce peaks today, and will do in this proposed future scenario in exactly the same way: https://drawdown.org/solutions/smart-thermostats https://drawdown.org/solutions/smart-thermostats
- atwood22 4y agoYea I agree. What’s likely happening is that the demand curve is shifting due to smart thermostats. Some adjustments need to be made on the production side to account for the shift, but overall total and peak usage should be lower.