3 ms·
Who sells in a marketplace where someone else sets your price for you automatically without your approval? Amazon isn't a distributor in this case any more tha
by ck2 15y ago
Who sells in a marketplace where someone else sets your price for you automatically without your approval?
Amazon isn't a distributor in this case any more than the person who owns the tent at a fleamarket allows people to sell underneath it.
In any case, Amazon's automatic algorithm to save themselves money from having to pay humans to do it nipped them this time and they owe the author. Do the right thing and settle Amazon. Take it out of the programmer's pay if necessary - better yet their manager who was supposed to review the code before it executed.
- illumen 15y ago'Who sells in a marketplace where someone else sets your price for you automatically without your approval?' Most people who sell products do. You sell at your wholesale price, and the retailer sets the retail price.
- _delirium 15y agoTrue, but the tricky part here is that Amazon got to set the wholesale price, too. Larger publishers have negotiated fixed wholesale prices (against Amazon's attempt to push back), but self-published eBook authors get a percentage of the retail price, so when Amazon varies the retail price, the wholesale price varies accordingly.
- feralchimp 15y ago(To split a maybe-relevant hair) in a purely royalty-based resale model, with no pre-negotiated minimums, there is no wholesale price. There is only the retail price, and revenue flow per the royalty calculation. Amazon clearly believes: - the cost/benefit for this guy to sue doesn't work out in his favor - no (or an insignificant number of) other authors will pull their content in an attempt to negotiate a change in the contract terms Sucks.
- rapind 15y agoTaking it out of the programmer's or manager's pay is ridiculous and probably illegal. You've never written code with a bug or two in it? If you want someone to right bug-free code or take financial responsibility for the code they've written, be ready to pay a lot more than you already do for that extra insurance. It's a cost of doing business. I do think Amazon should reimburse the guy if only to save on negative publicity over a very small amount.
- nicwest 15y agoAmazon isn't a distributor in this case any more than the person who owns the tent at a fleamarket allows people to sell underneath it. I don't feel this is quite true. in the ebook-fleamarket example Amazon are also the person that handles any transactions under the tent, helps the customer find what they are looking for, designed the structure of the flea market, and is not insignificantly responsible for way in which a fair few people take their products home.