3 ms·
Disclaimer: Former Red Hat employee My info might be slightly outdated cause last I looked into it was a few months ago, but I would guess it's not terribly d
by freedomben 4y ago
Disclaimer: Former Red Hat employee
My info might be slightly outdated cause last I looked into it was a few months ago, but I would guess it's not terribly different. Yes both are essentially the same product. Main differences from user perspective are reliability of package servers and speed of updates, plus community experience if you get involved there (friendly tip: I suggest you stay the hell away from the cess pool that is Reddit. That whole site probably needs to die in a fire)
*Alma Linux:*
- Works closer with upstream (actually sends patches and participates with dev on CentOS)
- Backed by a for-profit company (which I consider a good thing for longevity and reliability, but of course there's a risk of profit and community incentives misalignment)
- Fastest on updates when upstream releases
- Friendly and appreciative (generally speaking) toward Red Hat (without which none of their business would be possible)
*Rocky Linux*
- "Community" owned, but backed by some corporate money
- Very volunteer-run. Have some paid employees working on but many volunteers
- Hostile (and sometimes hateful) toward Red Hat
I mostly use CentOS Stream though and that has been rock solid. I use Alma on my router and on a prod database server that will be nearly impossible to rebuild that I migrated to Alma from Cent, but CentOS feels better to me now than it did before changing to Stream.
- rubyist5eva 4y agoWhat are you going to do when support for CentOS Stream 8 ends in 2024? Alma Linux 8 is supported until 2029 at least - for me it's a no brainer to use Alma for something like a database server.
- dralley 4y agoThe same thing all the Debian and Ubuntu LTS and OpenSUSE Leap users would do, upgrade to a newer release. 10 years of unpaid support has always been an anomaly that no other LTS distro provided.
- rubyist5eva 4y agoDebian, Ubuntu and OpenSUSE Leap all support in-place upgrades between major versions. RedHat/CentOS do not.
- mroche 4y agoRed Hat does support in-place upgrades for RHEL via Leapp, and the process around this has been improving. Granted I know in the past this process was... sub-optimal and restrictive. It is true that CentOS has not supported this. I am hoping we can achieve a "dnf system-upgrade" process on RHEL, but we'll see how that goes. RHEL 7 -> RHEL 8: https://access.redhat.com/documentation/en-us/red_hat_enterprise_linux/8/html/upgrading_from_rhel_7_to_rhel_8/index https://access.redhat.com/documentation/en-us/red_hat_enterp... RHEL 8 -> RHEL 9: https://access.redhat.com/documentation/en-us/red_hat_enterprise_linux/9/html/upgrading_from_rhel_8_to_rhel_9/index https://access.redhat.com/documentation/en-us/red_hat_enterp... We still recommend having strong backup, rebuild, and automation strategies regardless. I personally would rather spin up a side system, ensure everything works, and nuke the original. That would apply to either test a in-place upgrade or a from-scratch build.
- rubyist5eva 4y agoI’ve only ever heard negative things about Leapp and it always seemed like an unloved side thing, which is why I didn’t mention it.
- worthless-trash 4y agoI have dealt with many, many customers who update between major versions on RHEL while working in RH support.
- rubyist5eva 4y agoI’ve never heard good things about the experience of using leapp and it always seems like an unloved project. Upgrading major versions of RHEL is akin to jumping 5+ versions of Fedora at once and I don’t think it could ever really work well without waaaaay too much work that probably isn’t worth it. The Alma Linux “elevate” project seems to be attempting that using leapp as a framework but also allowing migration between RHEL derivatives so we’ll see how that pans out I guess.
- freedomben 4y agoSorry for the late reply. based on your username I suspect we are kindred spirits :-D by 2024, for things still in service I will most likely upgrade it to CentOS Stream 9. by about that time I'm usually running in to annoying things about the older OS and I want updated tools and such, which is enough incentive to get the rebuild done. The box that will be extremely hard to rebuild I already moved to Alma, where it will stay hopefully until EOL. There is one box I moved to Stream that I may just move to Alma to squeeze a few more years out of it in anticipation of it retiring. Overall though I really hate being on extended support (past the initial period). The farther in it gets the more headaches pop up. I got hosed by deprecations of SSL and old boxes that suddenly stopped working (because they were using protocols deemed too old/insecure by modern browsers). That was an absolute nightmare because it was instant prod outage and we had no time to plan.