4 ms·
First - I think just general manners, as well as established protocol, would have the security researcher let Apple know ahead of time what he would be doing.
by ghshephard 15y ago
First - I think just general manners, as well as established protocol, would have the security researcher let Apple know ahead of time what he would be doing. A simple email sent prior to uploading this code would have been sufficient to cover his bases - I'm surprised he didn't do that.
Second - Unless I'm mistaken - his proof of concept was more a violation of Apples TOU, it didn't really attempt to copy credit card numbers, or snoop on users calls - so, in that sense, it wasn't an exploit.
Net-Net - nobody comes out of this looking good, but Apple makes it clear that they are prepared to back up the language of their Developer TOU with actions.
- JoachimSchipper 15y agoPart of the security of the app store is the review process. "It's possible to download and execute code" is neat, "it's possible to download and execute code and the app store reviewers don't catch that" is much more impressive.
- ghshephard 15y agoNothing in the App Store review process will allow them to catch a zero-day exploit. Coming up with a zero-day exploit in IOS is very impressive - but, by definition, once you have it, the App Store review process isn't going to catch it.