4 ms·
The wrong assumption they are making is that the pace of science is constant, so that Nobel prizes (which are given out at a constant rate) are a rough approxim
by jessriedel 15y ago
The wrong assumption they are making is that the pace of science is constant, so that Nobel prizes (which are given out at a constant rate) are a rough approximation of progress. In physics, at least, this is very wrong.
In fact, fundamental theoretical physics has been more-or-less stagnant since the late 60's when the Standard Model was finished. But they have to keep handing out Nobel prizes. So the outcome is predictable: you see prizes being awarded to people who are fleshing out ideas which have been known for a half century; the low-hanging fruit has already been picked, so you have to work for years in the nitty-gritty to push the bounds. Hence, the prize winners are old.
But this doesn't tell us anything about physicists and when they are capable of genius (and how could it? does anyone really think that human nature has changed?), it tells us about the stagnation of the field.
The really interesting question is this: is the stagnation of physics more attributable to (a) some combination of fundamental technological/intellectual limitations or (b) institutional/social pathologies in Academia. Most people say '(a)', but I (as a young physicist) worry that '(b)' plays a substantial role.
- zzleeper 15y agoWould you mind elaborating about (b) more? Thanks!
- nostrademons 15y agoor c.) random chance. Kuhn would say that science consists of long periods of "normal science", in which people flesh out basic theories that have been known for decades, and short periods of "paradigm shifts", where previously ignored evidence is suddenly incorporated into brand-new, world-shifting theories that completely upend the old order. Just because you happen to be in one of those long doldrums of normal science doesn't mean that something is wrong with science, or that the field has stagnated. It just means you're not in a revolutionary paradigm-shifting phase.
- jessriedel 15y agoWe have had more physicists working in the past few decades than in the rest of human history put together. Statistically, there are dozens of Einsteins and Feynmans and Newtons walking around. But no breakthroughs. You can't attribute this to chance. Again, mere time is a bad metric for baseline progress.
- mrpsbrk 15y agoAnother way to say the same thing the article says is that «science has been rewarding creativity less and less». In that case, both (a) and (b) start to seem subtly related. Because once your hero ceases being a random wacko who was curious about weird stuff and comes to be a laborious researcher that climbed a lot of ladders, then the amount of effort you give to weird ideas decreases. Another way to put it is that big science is replacing science, and i think it is. (Feyerabend's perspectives, albeit very different from that, seem to point out many of the problems...)
- zerostar07 15y agoThe article doesn't make the assumption of linear change in science, on the contrary, studying nobelists means you have only those who made the big leaps forward. There were big leaps in medicine and chemistry, and the pattern seems to be valid: to my knowledge in life sciences you have few young geniuses and many awards are given to collaborative work. Seems like a natural consequence of the fact that science has become increasingly complex and computational.
- PaulHoule 15y ago(a) is primary. Problems in physics are much harder to solve than they were. For instance, the thing that corresponds to general relativity today is quantum gravity. Other paths exist, but the two that are most traveled are string theory and loop quantum gravity. The math involved in either one is considerably heavier than Einstein's relatively theory, and neither one is in a place where you can calculate real observable things. There's plenty of (b) to go around, but it's hard to believe we'd know what dark matter is, discover supersymmetry, or have an established "theory of everything" if we cleared away the cobwebs.
- jessriedel 15y agoThis is indeed the story that is usually told, but I find it pretty lacking.