3 ms·
The central exchange idea might make sense, but exchanges themselves are a business. Creating a central one is tantamount to mandating a monopoly, which doesn'
by pclmulqdq 4y ago
The central exchange idea might make sense, but exchanges themselves are a business. Creating a central one is tantamount to mandating a monopoly, which doesn't often result in good things. If I were the SEC, I would do the following:
* Remove reg NMS as it applies to brokers and broker-dealers, allowing them to trade anywhere they want. Keep the requirement that brokers must give a price to customers at or better than the NBBO (but let them trade how they want on the exchanges). This should make brokerage fees cheaper and reduce spreads.
* Require brokers to provide execution quality reports to the public the way that brokerage fees are reported to the public. Brokers would then have to say: "$0 commissions, 0.1% average spreads" or something along those lines. The market for high-fee high-quality brokers would likely develop around that: "$5 commissions, 0.01% spreads" is compelling to people who trade large blocks. Hedge funds and big money traders already test brokers like this.
* Allow and/or require crossing auctions for retail market orders that get to an exchange. Privileging retail orders on exchange and having brokerages advertise their slippage should give "high-commission, low-spread" brokerages the incentive to send most customer orders to an exchange, and a mechanism to get the best possible price from the broader market.
Also, a tiny Tobin tax does currently exist - it funds the SEC. However, adding higher transaction taxes has been tried in Europe, and turned some exchanges into wastelands.