3 ms·
> Why should I believe someone like Herodotus could possibly report accurately about things in 50 to 100years before he was born in places he couldn't have poss
by rsynnott 4y ago
> Why should I believe someone like Herodotus could possibly report accurately about things in 50 to 100years before he was born in places he couldn't have possibly been and with no actual proof, just decades of "telephone"
Modern historians _don't_ take ancient historians at their word, in general. No-one _actually_ thinks that Caligula made his horse a consul or a priest, say. There's very limited contemporary information on a lot of ancient history, and they have to work with what they have, but they're generally skeptical.