7 ms·
EU lawmakers slam “radical proposal“ to let ISPs demand new fees from websites
- pteraspidomorph 4y agoSo, literally an attempt to discard net neutrality altogether (again).
- IfOnlyYouKnew 4y agoNo, not altogether, at least not literally. Yet.
- ShaneMcGowan 4y ago"statements to the press indicate that a new provision would require payments from online service providers to broadband providers—ostensibly to fund the rollout of 5G and fiber to the home” One could argue that the broadband provider should be the one paying for the infrastructure to …provide broadband
- mrwizrd 4y agoThe practice of public companies appealing every single court ruling out of duty to their shareholders seems to have been taken to another level. Now they actively try to avoid paying to invest in their own infrastructure. ISP's as common carriers and infrastructure providers willingly put themselves in a position that demands a level of altruism beyond your average private corporation - and that's really not asking for much. For many their primary goal is to enrich themselves to the detriment of building the best network for end users. This sort of wailing and thrashing from broadband providers really needs regulation, but competition and financials mean that it's always going to be in the interests of less scrupulous companies to make every attempt possible to enrich themselves or push costs elsewhere, even if that screws up what is quite a delicate balance of legislature, technology and public and private interests. "So you're saying, governments want fast internet access for a productive, modern economy, but our anticompetitive practices and lack of investment have come back to bite us? Can't let shareholder dividends be affected by that, it's clearly Netflix/YouTube/whoever's fault for providing content consumers want!" Make that statement enough times in front of enough uninformed/bought legislatures and sooner or later you'll start pushing slowly towards your goal. Not to mention that this conveniently ignoring the fact that Netflix/YouTube and the likes provide caches colocated inside of ISP data centres as well as upstream [1] in an attempt to avoid the costs of peering. But nothing will ever be enough. [1]: https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2013/07/why-youtube-buffers-the-secret-deals-that-make-and-break-online-video/4/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2013/07/why-y...
- gsatic 4y agoYou sound uninformed about how much a 5G rollout costs.
- lillecarl 4y agoWhat's so incredibly expensive about the 5G rollout that wasn't the case for "3G/4G"? You replace/mount more radios, make sure you have backhaul to carry the traffic. I have no idea what the radios cost, but one thing that's for sure is that networking gear isn't that expensive. I know a guy that runs a teeny IX where everyone gets a 100GB port, because it's not that expensive. Once you start doing stateful packet introspection, that's when price goes through the roof.
- tennis_80 4y ago5G masts cover a significantly smaller area than 4G, so you need a lot more to provide the same coverage.
- BenjiWiebe 4y agoNot exactly. 5G also can use the same frequencies as 4G with a slightly better range. You only need lots of towers if you want blazing fast speeds everywhere. Out in the country they won't be putting up towers every mile.
- lillecarl 4y agoOnce the 3G network is dead we can reuse that low-freq bands for 5G with similar range. You only use the high-freq high-bandwidth radios in populated areas. https://youtu.be/0faCad2kKeg https://youtu.be/0faCad2kKeg this is Wendover Productions explanation of cell service, there's an error regarding ultra high-freq when he means ultra low-freq, other than that it's a good explanation of how RF works. An important bit here is that 3G is 16 combinations and 5G is 1000+, this is why it's important to deprecate old tech, we need to reuse frequencies.
- armada651 4y ago
- bogantech 4y agoNo network allows 100% utilization from all nodes at once, each peering arrangement only has a finite amount of bandwidth and Net Neutrality activists don't even want them to be able to do QoS. If some peer is causing massive contention issues for your network and refuses to pay anything to help cover the costs you can * Just have a shitty network until your customers leave you * Go bankrupt by constantly buying millions of dollars worth of hardware to subsidise their business * Increase prices Consolidation will continue, and people will continue to whine that they have little or no choice in broadband provider after all the smaller providers go bust or get bought out for peanuts. At least Netflix colocate their CDN in ISP networks but I bet most of the others do not.
- cowtools 4y agoJust charge customers by the gigabyte like a mobile network or a satellite network. It is misleading in the first place to advertise certain speeds on an underutilized network. This is like running an all-you-can-eat buffet and complaining when a fat guy shows up and eats you out of business. It's a flaw in the business model they CHOSE to implement.
- mrwizrd 4y agoHearing every criticism of any proposal whatsoever being described as "x slams y" is getting tiring. Is it time to pick a different verb yet? I wonder if there are any projects tracking the proliferation and trends of those patterns in articles?
- IfOnlyYouKnew 4y agoI believe it’s called „Google Proliferation“.
- powerhour 4y agoWhen I look for past conflicts between organizations I typically use the verb "slammed" in my searches.
- curiousgal 4y agoHN commenter slams news article
- the8472 4y agohttps://xkcd.com/2584/ https://xkcd.com/2584/
- ajsnigrutin 4y agoWhy is it every time I see "EU" anywhere in the title here on HN, it's them doing something really bad.. again. So, what's next? Demanding mcdonalds to pay the highway operator money, because people use a highway to drive to a mcdonalds?
- sgift 4y ago> Why is it every time I see "EU" anywhere in the title here on HN, it's them doing something really bad.. again. Because outrage motivates people. First, it motivates writers to write articles, so you even get to have an insight into law making without being motivated to research it yourself. Next, people who read something they don't like are motivated to post it here. For most topics at least one of these two steps is missing. Either no one writes about it (or only very niche websites without much reach) or people read it and "yeah, okay, nice" and go on with their day.
- pornel 4y agoIt's a proposal, in a very early stage. There are lots of steps before any proposal can become a law. It's already strongly opposed, so it's very unlikely to go anywhere. It looks like the system is working fine. This proposal is pretty tame compared to proposals coming from the QAnon branch of the US government.
- richrichardsson 4y agoHow exactly is this article painting the EU in a bad light? The Commission has proposed something that MEPs have pushed back against. Is that not democracy working? This is probably not the first stupid thing the Commission has proposed that MEPs have rejected. If anything the worst thing about the EU is that EU citizens generally can't be bothered to engage with that level of politics; this is how UKIP managed to appear like a real political party because they required relatively little support to get elected to the EU Parliament.
- ajsnigrutin 4y agoBecause they can try many times, and it takes only one time for them to push it through.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- fredgrott 4y agoreminds me of the bad business habit of USA telecoms spending profits not to re-invest in new infrastructure but to increase salaries of board members and stock buy backs.
- RHSeeger 4y agoAs I understand it, it's not even just profits. The government specifically gave them money to expand their networks, and they... just didn't. They kept the money, but didn't bother to spend it on what it was supposed to be for. And not a hand got slapped.
- AinderS 4y ago> Vestager reportedly said at a news conference that "there are players who generate a lot of traffic that then enables their business but who have not been contributing actually to enable that traffic." Oh, they get bandwidth for free? And consumers who connect to them also get bandwidth for free? Sign me up!
- runeks 4y ago> The letter cited a May 2 Reuters article that said, "Tech giants such as Google, Meta, and Netflix may have to bear some of the cost of Europe's telecoms network”, Europe's digital chief Margrethe Vestager said on Monday, following EU telecoms operators' complaints. Google and Facebook both own over 50,000 miles of submarine cables [1], thus comprising a major part of the backbone of the internet. Then there are ISPs, who specialize in providing the infrastructure that connects this backbone to the end consumer, and ISPs want Google and Facebook to pay for this, too? [1] https://broadbandnow.com/report/google-content-providers-submarine-cable-ownership/ https://broadbandnow.com/report/google-content-providers-sub...
- _23sd 4y agoTelecoms trying to use their political clout to get cash from third parties is quite bold even for them. Of course Brendan Carr is involved. Is there any sort of precedent for this? I don’t remember electric utilities getting to shake down air conditioner manufacturers when their products created a need for infrastructure upgrades.