3 ms·
I was about to submit this article, but PaulHole already did: I hope it will not be a problem if I compose here the abridgement I would have composed for mine.
by mdp2021 4y ago
I was about to submit this article, but PaulHole already did: I hope it will not be a problem if I compose here the abridgement I would have composed for mine.
Subtitle: If every driver has a horror story about charging, adoption is going to stall
> In many regards, electric vehicles are clearly better than the internal combustion engine-powered relatives they will eventually replace. They're quieter, they rattle and vibrate less, they accelerate faster, and they're much more efficient because they can recover energy under braking. And their batteries should last for the life of the car. // [But] even the biggest EV enthusiasts can't ignore the fact that it takes a lot longer to recharge a battery [...] Stopping to charge every 150..250 miles becomes an impediment to... freedom
> Finding a charger isn't actually the problem [in the USA], though, even if it adds another 50 miles to your road trip [...] No, the problem is whether or not any of the chargers will be working when you arrive
> Man plans, universe laughs: A few weeks ago, The Wall Street Journal published a piece...: "I Rented an Electric Car for a Four-Day Road Trip. I Spent More Time Charging It Than I Did Sleeping" [...] A few weeks later, [...] despite plenty of planning, I still spent almost as much time stationary, arguing with charging machinery, as I did actually pulling electrons... throughout the 600-mile journey. // At each charging stop, in Virginia, Pennsylvania, and New York, I ran into problems. A five-minute wait to see if the car and charger would establish communications was invariably the case[; w]aiting 10 minutes was not uncommon. Even then, there was no time to relax; more than once, an error somewhere in the loop shut everything down after just a few kWh. // Only one of six charging stops was painless [...] // Then there was the problem of whether or not all of the chargers at a given location were even functional [and review ratings will not help]
> I think a lot of these communication errors come from the plug weighing down and one or more pins losing their connection [and it seems the issue is not restricted to the vehicle model]
> 97% is the uptime requirement for chargers that will be built as part of the federal government's Interstate charging network
The article may include other useful information (names software applications for road trip planning), together with many links to further explore the matter.
--
Incidentally, as a free comment: the article further specifies the statistics about the average trip in the USA to be less than 30 miles per day (less than 50km/d). But it should be clear that the problems lie in the exceptions, not in the norm. Hence, the need for the preservation of options. And will that lossfully compressed number hide uncontiguous realities and potential clusters - with different needs - such as city dwellers vs commuters vs rural dwellers (more telling clusters could be found)?
By the way: think of emergency ops vehicles depending on "careful planning"... From the very car of a doctor to specialized vehicles...
- PaulHoule 4y agoIt's a common problem that organizations will put some money in to start something up but not spend the money and do the work to keep it going. It's even worse if there are a number of different organizations involved: there might be a group that runs 100 chargers (one of a large number of groups) and then some business that has the charger at one location. I think of how I'm hesitant to order food online for pickup at a small restaurant in my area unless I know their web site really works. There are sites that take orders for restaurants that have nothing to do with the restaurant, and then other restaurants who have their own site but between technology and process you can't trust it. If I pull into some place I've never been it's a leap of faith that facilities like electric car chargers are what they are claimed to be and it takes work to build a brand such that people know the organization behind it really delivers what it promises.
- mdp2021 4y ago> order food online Just one of the reasons I only order in place. More on topic: it takes a certain profile to build baroque systems. Even more: process solidity is a value, and simplicity is both a value and something that also derives from the former. > between technology and process you can't trust it If I could tell you the relevant shock I received only a handful of hours ago, dealing with a service provider... I'll respectfully "fix" yours: "between technology, and process, and human processors you can't trust it". The situation is worsening because the attempt which some called "anglosaxon school of management", of depreciating the human participation in enterprises as a mere "biological workflow executor", "define it as if a fool should follow it", is - as one could guess and as some can see - a blow to the awareness and presence of common sense. Which does not promise quality for forthcoming service provision. Concern which should be part of the planning (minimization of damage potential, especially if outside the windows the clouds are heavy).
- PaulHoule 4y agoMore specifically I'd say that restaurants are a microcosm of manufacturing processes. There is a sub shop downtown in Ithaca that spins like a top, it is so well run you'd think they'd write a business school case study about it. That is, they make great subs and never screw your order up. Well, at least they never screwed your order up when you submitted in person. I think the online ordering is OK today but the first time I ordered something online they made my sub 30 minutes early and then stuffed it in some out-of-the-way place where they couldn't find it! A place that handles in person orders very well can fall down completely when it comes to online orders or vice versa.