4 ms·
But isn't discrimination only bad when it's based on membership of protected classes? And preferred method of payment definitely isn't a protected class.
by josephcsible 4y ago
But isn't discrimination only bad when it's based on membership of protected classes? And preferred method of payment definitely isn't a protected class.
- thr0wawayf00 4y agoIt's well established that lower income cohorts have less access to digital finance and credit. Cashless systems instantly become a proxy to exclude those cohorts.
- josephcsible 4y agoBut income isn't a protected class either (and it can't be made one, or nothing would be allowed to be expensive).
- dredmorbius 4y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32091797 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32091797 1. If the net effect is to discriminate against a protected class, legal liability may still exist. 2. Discrimination as a general concept is not identicial to discrimination against a protected class. It may be legal in a strict sense, and still morally, socially, and politically reprehensible and/or disruptive.
- dredmorbius 4y agoDiscriminations harms extend well beyond those which are recognised legally. The law itself is very often a tool for further oppression, and should be considered on that basis. There are two elements to that question: the legal and the moral. Legally the premise is shaky as it's a short walk from "use a specific payment method" (a financial instrument, a device, a service, a company) to what are protected classes: age, race, national origin, religious beliefs, gender, disability, pregnancy, and veteran status in the United States.[1] As such, strictly as a business decision there's a considerable risk involved that such practices would be found to be de facto discimination against one or more protected classes. (Keep in mind that there are religions which consider interest on money to be against their beliefs, which would then transfer to use of revolving credit instruments. I've no idea whether this has been tested in US courts.) On a moral basis, even that which is not strictly illegal may be against principles of greater justice, and gatekeeping access to goods or services can easily work against those with limited means (unable to buy the latest mobile smartphone or desktop/laptop computer), unabile to maintain broadband comms access, owning a working but end-of-lifed device (for Android as little as 2--3 years, somewhat better for Apple), living in regions without high-speed broadband (most of the US), excluded from access to credit by low credit scores, or forced by circumstances to accept massive invasions of privacy or exposure to manipulation (propaganda, advertising, targeted manipulation) simply to participate minimally in the everyday business of life. Note that remote-commerce can be a force for inclusion and against oppression. The Sears Roebuck Catalogue was the subject of recent commentary on that point, see for example: "How Sears Catalog Fought White Supremacists" https://www.voanews.com/a/usa_all-about-america_how-sears-catalog-fought-white-supremacists/6176981.html https://www.voanews.com/a/usa_all-about-america_how-sears-ca... The major operative factor to me seems to be whether a technology constrains or expands opportunities. Reducing payment options quite clearly constrains them. ________________________________ Notes: 1. https://www.legalmatch.com/law-library/article/protected-classes-under-anti-discrimination-laws.html https://www.legalmatch.com/law-library/article/protected-cla...
- josephcsible 4y ago> owning a working but end-of-lifed device Aren't such devices major security risks, and isn't accepting them connecting to anything of your own a major liability?
- dredmorbius 4y agoIt really shouldn't require much reading-between-the-lines or interpretation to see that for someone who cannot afford to replace such a device, a multi-hundred-dollar expense every few years is a significant hurdle. The choice isn't between "old unsupported device" and "new, supported device", but between "old" and "none". Most especially when the underlying hardware itself may well function for a decade or more. Your volume and line of questioning are suggesting a lack of consideration and awareness of circumstances. You might want to think a bit more and ask a bit less.