4 ms·
It seems like the main values of Tesla's cylindrical cells are that cylinders pack fairly tight, but also they make for pretty cool looking assembly lines becau
by hinkley 4y ago
It seems like the main values of Tesla's cylindrical cells are that cylinders pack fairly tight, but also they make for pretty cool looking assembly lines because you can roll them around. Neither of these are particularly useful qualities in a production vehicle.
I'm curious if a prismatic cell solution - especially if they take 'prismatic' literally instead of meaning "rectangular", can be better optimized for heat dissipation. It's easier to tune surface area to internal area when you can make more sophisticated shapes, like truncated cuboids to provide rectangular cooling channels, or concave surfaces to make cylindrical ones.
- ggm 4y agobatteries are round because the process to make them was a flow process, and its natural to roll things up from ribbons and sheets. Folding introduces more complexities: how do you make the fold the right length? what does it do to the barrier between things? folding and layers don't mix as well as rolling and layers. swiss rolls, sushi rolls, battery cells are basically the same thing with chemistry differences. capacitors come in cans for much the same reason. you take sheets of "stuff" and cover them with semi liquid other "stuff" and you roll them up and then cut the long rolls into short segments, put them in cans, attach electrodes and you have a capacitor. Sorry battery. Sorry Swiss roll. Sorry, sashimi. No: we got that order wrong.
- hinkley 4y agoPrismatic cells are still rolled as far as I’m aware, and from the few videos I’ve seen. They just don’t start with round core, they start with a different shape, such as a flat one for rectangular cells like in cell phones or Apple laptops. Apple hit a trifecta when they started making their own batteries. The MacBook where they introduced them got twice the battery life. The new OSX version had better battery management. The prismatic, unpackaged cells occupied 30% more volume within the case, because they dropped the packaging, the round cells, and used a tiny motherboard. And finally the chemistry of the new cells increased the watt hours per cubic centimeter by 30%. But the difference between a laptop and a car is that the laptop batteries were maybe 3/8” thick. Plenty of top and bottom surface area to dissipate heat. Or so they thought (lots of swelling batteries in those models). If you wrapped the battery around a thin trapezoid, or a very thin parallelogram, I think you get that truncated cuboid shape once you have laid up a half dozen layers or so, because of the way the radius of the corners builds up with each wrap.
- Neil44 4y agoPleating is a pretty solved problem too, many filters produced by the million are pleated and can be safety critical too.
- ggm 4y agoPleating is interesting mechanically because its very strong in the right 'direction' considering the pleats. Its what makes corrugated cardboard work. I suspect pleating would work well with "flow" production methods which start with sheets, and do some kind of printing/overlay process in a shallow bath, and then you have 100m of thing, which you pleat before canning/containerising and its both robust and a BIT flexible in some plain in the 3D space, so you can shape it around things.
- gruturo 4y agoCylindrical cells also leave space for cooling (and heating!) channels when you assemble them together. Some companies tried to pack them more efficiently and then realized you NEED the cooling channels to avoid thermal runaways, fires, premature degradation, limp mode and extremely slow charging....
- dzhiurgis 4y agoDunno if true but it’s much simpler - pouches are still under patent, while cylinders expired.