3 ms·
You can't read just any grey-on-white text.
by dredmorbius 4y ago
You can't read just any grey-on-white text.
- chrispine 4y agoFor real. Also, why are some of the links struck-out?
- kroltan 4y agoBecause they are broken, apparently. The CSS class for those is `broken_link`, and I tried on the "Primary and secondary compounds", sure enough it leads to an "access denied" response 403.
- jacobr1 4y agoThat bothered me too. Trying a few though, it looks like they are 404s. Which is an interesting way to preserve a historical, but no longer valid link. If you are going to the trouble, it might be better to rewrite the links to point to Archive.org or something.
- dredmorbius 4y agoLinking an archived copy (and proactively making an archive submission when initially linking, which seems to be an increasingly common practice), would be preferable.
- smeagull 4y agoUgh. Links are meant to live forever.
- dredmorbius 4y agoIs/ought fallacy. They clearly don't, despite 30+ years of whinging. (I've whinged plenty myself.) Preemptive defence is justified, necessary, and strongly advised. The Web is not an archival platform, it's a publishing one. Each request is served in the moment it's requested, and absent specific measures for persistance can and will vanish at any time without notice.
- dang 4y ago"Please don't complain about tangential annoyances—things like article or website formats, name collisions, or back-button breakage. They're too common to be interesting." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- dredmorbius 4y agoI'm aware. This site takes it to the next level, and is honestly illegible. I'd hope that at some point extraordinary badness is remarkable. Something's got to give, and I'd suggest here it's the HN guidelines.
- pvg 4y agoSomething's got to give, and I'd suggest here it's the HN guidelines. What's going to be better about HN if it becomes more accepting of everyone's personal web peeve?
- dredmorbius 4y agoSlippery slope. There are peeves worth noting, and there is site breakage which crosses boundaries. I think this case crosses a line, or at least gets damnedably close. In the case of paywalls (or other forms of content-gating, such as GDPR-attributed geoblocking), for example, HN has adopted the position that those which can be reasonably bypassed are acceptable. This has become increasingly harder over the years, though there's been an ongoing arms-race with various alternative-access mechanisms, ranging from Google Cache, cookie clearing, and at least in the past couple of years, Archive.Today which often (though not always) works. Noting that a site has a hard and insurmountable paywall is a legitimate gripe. Many of my own comments are links which provide access, and I'll often include such comments with my own submissions. The article here is literally impossible for me to read on either a full-colour tablet or my preferred driver these days, a monochrome E-Ink tablet / ebook reader. The site itself further discourages feedback. In the longer term, my view is that if there's no push-back against such practices, the Web will ultimately become if not comletely unusable, then generally unreliable. It's well on its way there. Similar issues affect other realms of information and communication infrastructure and systems. Robocalls, scams, and other forms of telephone abuse. The general death of broadcast television and radio into increasingly irrelevant and bottom-fishing advertising churn. Postal mail with its junk and bulk mail and scams. Newspapers devoid of news. Ultimately people will simply desert these. And I'm not sure what replaces them, if anything, or whether or not an effective attempt can be made to keep the cycle from repeating. I'm ... getting more than a little tired of it. I also remember what the Web was promised to deliver, and helped at least in part to make it do that. I'm feeling some aspects of a life wasted in that regard.