3 ms·
Retool for what? How do you know whatever you choose will be available for production?
by CamperBob2 4y ago
Retool for what? How do you know whatever you choose will be available for production?
- rasz 4y agoDont go for fancy new parts, use what Chinese use at volume.
- krnlpnc 4y agoThats a good way to get a reputation for gear that dies on you. Instrument components need to be extra robust, they are put through a lot of abuse.
- zrobotics 4y agoPlus, pro audio gear needs to be on the same order of reliability as industrial equipment. For instance, an artist that has a piece of gear fry has potentially wrecked a contracted performance (which can affect revenue as well as reputation). This could also heppen during recording, which ruins very expensive studio time that may be pre-paid for. For most of the software devs here, having a computer fry would be at most a 1 day loss of productivity and a neglible effect on overall company earnings. Not so true when you have a booked venue and your amp or synth just blew up during sound check hours before the show opens. It's honestly not that dissimilar to how industrial equipment can cause huge revenue effects from a failure due to lost productivity.
- seizethegdgap 4y agoAnd what happens when your Chinese parts are stuck in China for weeks due to their zero-COVID policy?
- lnsru 4y agoWe buy what’s available in stock, design with these parts small runs(500-2000 units). And then the run in 3 months is being made with completely different parts that were available. It’s emergency solution. But it’s better than being out of business.
- samatman 4y agoI'm out of my depth here, but I'm under the impression that synthesizers just don't work that way. My source is a housemate of an old friend, whose profession was restoring a certain sort of mixer popular with house DJs, for whatever that's worth. Analog synths, at least, just won't sound right if components get swapped. The TR-808 was discontinued, and replaced with the 909, because a critical component went out of production, and it wasn't possible to deliver the sound without it. It's the difference between a wood shortage for a cabinetmaker and for a luthier. A cabinetmaker can use mahogany where he would use ebony, a luthier is out of business if she can't get certain woods until she can again. This could be totally inapplicable to modern synths? I wouldn't bet on it though.
- mzs 4y agoThe two parts mentioned were an ARM board and DSP. Those are easily retooled for and not like an opamp or something very particular.
- munificent 4y ago> Analog synths, at least, just won't sound right if components get swapped. I think this is true in some cases for particular analog synths. But my impression is that most synths aren't using unobtainium chips like this. I think you generally can redesign the circuit using alternate components and get to a fairly close sound. But that redesign process is iterative and time-consuming. By analogy, imagine there a shortage in "compiler invocations". You have a giant program written in one language, but you can't run a compiler on it. Could you port it to another language without a shortage? Sure, but it's a ton of work, and if you end up in another language that has its own compiler invocation shortage, you're no better off.
- jdkee 4y agoBoth Curtis and SSM chips used in synthesizers like the Sequential Circuits Prophet-5 in the 1970s have being cloned and are in production. See https://electricdruid.net/analog-renaissance/ https://electricdruid.net/analog-renaissance/