4 ms·

I want one just to get a notification LED back. Thats up there with the headphone jack as something that shouldnt have been removed from basically all phones in

I want one just to get a notification LED back. Thats up there with the headphone jack as something that shouldnt have been removed from basically all phones in my book.

dont__panic 4y ago
Too bad the Nothing Phone doesn't have a headphone jack. I couldn't agree more. For anyone else who won't even consider a phone without a jack... I'm much more excited for the upcoming Asus Zenphone 9, which is roughly Pixel 5 sized and slightly smaller than the standard iPhone size, and features a headphone jack! It's the smallest (and headphone jackiest) flagship in quite some time, slightly smaller than its predecessor.
- bitwize 4y ago
  Does it run GrapheneOS?
  - dont__panic 4y ago
    I believe its predecessor, the 8, did. I can't say for certain that the 9 will but it seems like a (relatively) safe bet.
silisili 4y ago
I go back and forth on the headphone jack debate. But the notification LED I just don't get. They aren't large and intrusive like a jack - so it's not space saving. I like to leave my phone on my desk and only check it if I see an LED blinking. Not constantly wake it up to see if I missed something. I assume most people want that? I came to two possible conclusions - 1) it's about engagement, and for some reason companies want you opening your phone often, or 2) so many apps notify for everything anymore, the LED would just constantly blink. At least 2 could be solved by only allowing certain apps or classes of notification (like say, phone or text) notify the LED.
- hdjjhhvvhga 4y ago
  I believe it could be one of these mistaken A/B testings - do we have hard data that a significant portion of users actually use the notification LED? No? So let's ditch it and save a huge amount of money in total. I bet someone was very proud over the idea.
kayodelycaon 4y ago
If you have an iphone, you can use the camera flash for this: https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT210065 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT210065
- SkinTaco 4y ago
  One person at a ~30 person meeting I attend weekly has this turned on and every single attendee knows exactly who that person is.
  - kayodelycaon 4y ago
    Oh definitely. I prefer to use an Apple Watch since it's just a bit more subtle.
celsoazevedo 4y ago
Not sure if you need a physical LED when many phones these days have OLED displays that can mimic the LED without consuming too much power. Some Android brands have this built-in and there are also some 3rd party apps that do the same.
- bitwize 4y ago
  OLED displays are prone to permanent burn-in, so... not always the best choice.
  - celsoazevedo 4y ago
    Right, but it's what most flagships use anyway (iPhone, Google Pixel, Samsung, even this phone), so if you're an OEM that uses OLED and don't want to have a dedicated LED, it can be done with the display. Burn-in wouldn't be a problem for this fake LED because it can move around as it blinks.
srvmshr 4y ago
The original Google Nexus type color configurable notification would be such a welcome addition. Got mail? Red blink. Got a tweet reply? Blink blue. Even Nokia E72/73/75 had beautiful breathing lights.
fsflover 4y ago
Librem 5 has an RGB notification LED and a headphone jack.
kevincox 4y ago
Always-on displays have basically obsoleted the notification LED. I used to consider it a required feature when buying a phone as well and would carefully configure the colours of each app and their priority. But these days I am happy with the default Android always-on display and a row of icons for the notifications. I can imagine that some people miss the colour but the detail offered by the icons makes it much easier to know what notifications you have.
deleted 4y ago
[deleted]

I want one just to get a notification LED back. Thats up there with the headphone jack as something that shouldnt have been removed from basically all phones in my book.

dont__panic 4y ago

Too bad the Nothing Phone doesn't have a headphone jack. I couldn't agree more. For anyone else who won't even consider a phone without a jack... I'm much more excited for the upcoming Asus Zenphone 9, which is roughly Pixel 5 sized and slightly smaller than the standard iPhone size, and features a headphone jack! It's the smallest (and headphone jackiest) flagship in quite some time, slightly smaller than its predecessor.

bitwize 4y ago
Does it run GrapheneOS?
- dont__panic 4y ago
  I believe its predecessor, the 8, did. I can't say for certain that the 9 will but it seems like a (relatively) safe bet.

silisili 4y ago

I go back and forth on the headphone jack debate. But the notification LED I just don't get. They aren't large and intrusive like a jack - so it's not space saving. I like to leave my phone on my desk and only check it if I see an LED blinking. Not constantly wake it up to see if I missed something. I assume most people want that? I came to two possible conclusions - 1) it's about engagement, and for some reason companies want you opening your phone often, or 2) so many apps notify for everything anymore, the LED would just constantly blink. At least 2 could be solved by only allowing certain apps or classes of notification (like say, phone or text) notify the LED.

hdjjhhvvhga 4y ago
I believe it could be one of these mistaken A/B testings - do we have hard data that a significant portion of users actually use the notification LED? No? So let's ditch it and save a huge amount of money in total. I bet someone was very proud over the idea.

kayodelycaon 4y ago

If you have an iphone, you can use the camera flash for this: https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT210065 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT210065

SkinTaco 4y ago
One person at a ~30 person meeting I attend weekly has this turned on and every single attendee knows exactly who that person is.
- kayodelycaon 4y ago
  Oh definitely. I prefer to use an Apple Watch since it's just a bit more subtle.

celsoazevedo 4y ago

Not sure if you need a physical LED when many phones these days have OLED displays that can mimic the LED without consuming too much power. Some Android brands have this built-in and there are also some 3rd party apps that do the same.

bitwize 4y ago
OLED displays are prone to permanent burn-in, so... not always the best choice.
- celsoazevedo 4y ago
  Right, but it's what most flagships use anyway (iPhone, Google Pixel, Samsung, even this phone), so if you're an OEM that uses OLED and don't want to have a dedicated LED, it can be done with the display. Burn-in wouldn't be a problem for this fake LED because it can move around as it blinks.

srvmshr 4y ago

The original Google Nexus type color configurable notification would be such a welcome addition. Got mail? Red blink. Got a tweet reply? Blink blue. Even Nokia E72/73/75 had beautiful breathing lights.

fsflover 4y ago

Librem 5 has an RGB notification LED and a headphone jack.

kevincox 4y ago

Always-on displays have basically obsoleted the notification LED. I used to consider it a required feature when buying a phone as well and would carefully configure the colours of each app and their priority. But these days I am happy with the default Android always-on display and a row of icons for the notifications. I can imagine that some people miss the colour but the detail offered by the icons makes it much easier to know what notifications you have.

deleted 4y ago

[deleted]