19 ms·
Supply chain issues are killing synth companies
- Flatcircle 4y agoAfter reading this article went to Sweetwater to check out synths and nearly every single synth has a price drop icon above it. So it can't be too severe?
- kzrdude 4y agoPoint taken. Is it a USD strength effect though?
- Flatcircle 4y agooh interesting. I didn't think of that.
- Syonyk 4y agoSupply chain issues are killing everyone. You want to build a product? Great, here's the list of what you can't get this week. It's different from last week, next week will be different too. Good luck! Parts that used to cost $0.50 are now $5+ (various ADCs and DACs come to mind as one I've been dealing with). God help you if you want trailer axles. Etc. There's only so much you can do with flexibility and "Redesign every few weeks for what's available for this batch" before your design costs and parts cost increases chew up all the available profits, even if you've designed for flexibility. "We can use any uC in this entire line!" "That line is on 54 week lead time. Yes, all the variants." Such is life in the decline.
- camtarn 4y agoYep. We use smart PLCs (programmable logic controllers - basically an Intel Atom powered realtime platform with modular high-speed analogue/digital I/O) for a lot of our projects. For one project, we were planning on deploying a cheap PLC plus a thermocouple module and some SPI modules. Because of availability, that turned into buying thermocouple and SPI interface chips ourselves, and designing a custom PCB to interface those to a Raspberry Pi. And now of course Raspberry Pis are impossible to get, so while we managed to get hold of enough for the first run of deployments, we don't have any more of them - we even had to ship our tester Pi! It's a real scramble, and we've definitely lost a bunch of money on that project.
- rasz 4y agoDo you really need multicore linux computer with gigabyte of ram to send temperature over the network?
- vorpalhex 4y agoThat depends on how fast you're sending it, how you are sending it, how precise it is, and if edge calculations have to be run, and calibration workloads.
- rasz 4y agoAll valid points in 1985. Nowadays smallest cheapest microcontroller has more processing power than fastest desktop from 1995.
- vorpalhex 4y agoAnd in the last 30+ years do you think that maybe some of what we do with temperature data has changed? Or how we interact with a network? Or the data that sensors can produce? If you think you can answer parents problems without even knowing the problem space, you're behaving foolishly.
- camtarn 4y agoHey, it's alright - rasz just asked a question, and it was a fair one :)
- vorpalhex 4y agoThere's asking a question to learn and there's indicating that someone did something the wrong way without understanding the problem space. Understand the problem, then propose solutions. Anything else is ass backwards.
- rasz 4y ago
- shabble 4y agobonus fun if you're in a regulated industry and any BoM change is going to be, at the minimum, an external test-lab redoing all your certifications, and in the worst case, a brand new product you need to submit to your regulating authority. No wonder there are some $5 MCUs going for $500+ each (and apparently selling well at those prices, even)
- cyphertruck 4y agoThat’s not a bonus, that’s the entire point. Regulations hamstring companies and then deny them the ability to even comply with the regulations because other regulations have hamstrung the supply chain after regulations forced everyone onto vulnerable supply chains in the first place. So instead of people getting rich by innovating and making other people’s lives better, the people getting rich are the ones taking bribes (“campaign contributions” they get to keep forever) for reducing the impact of those regulations.
- amanaplanacanal 4y agoThe thing is, those regulations were put in place to solve a problem. They might not have been the best solution, but there is no way to know without going back and researching exactly what the problem was they were trying to solve. That’s on top of the fact that we are always dealing with incomplete information.
- zrobotics 4y agoUmm, I'm pretty OK with medical suppliers not being able to sub in no-name or grey-market substitutions that may have unknown silicon bugs. Regulation isn't always bad, and being in a regulated industry had some of these problems even before the component shortage. Sure, subbing a MCU for an unknown supplier in a kids toy isn't likely to cause any serious problems, but in anything that can hurt or kill people it's objectively a good thing that there are regulations in place to prevent safety issues. Ive heard the same complaints about food regulations, but it's objectively a good thing that a consumer can purchase anything (that isn't expired) from a grocery store with near certainty that it won't make them I'll. That same surety can't be had in countries with more lax food standards.
- jjoonathan 4y agoThe EEs are spinning alternative designs, the SWEs are writing cart sniping bots, the Supply Chain guys are trying to figure out if anyone with chips can be compensated for their consideration, ASML is desoldering chips from washing machines so they can make machines that make more chips, Influencers are using clout to beg for chips https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=chip+shortage+adafruit https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=chip+shortage+a... Et tu, ATMEGA328P? It's getting very real very fast out there.
- KptMarchewa 4y ago>ASML is desoldering chips from washing machines It's not what ASML does - ASML exec reported that some other company does this
- reaperducer 4y agoAnd according to the New York Times, this is the reason that Russian troops are looting major appliances from Ukraine, and trucking them back home. There must be some interesting chips in washing machines these days.
- honkler 4y agothey want a direct line to NSA
- nebula8804 4y agoWhy not just pull the circuit boards and truck those home? Do you really have to take the rest of the machine?
- tomxor 4y agoMaybe they are... alternatively maybe they aren't and it's simply easier and faster to tell troops to chuck washing machines onto trucks rather than spend time dismantling them and learning how to identify the relevant parts and remove them without damage, not to mention Russia has a lot of spare fuel now.
- floren 4y agoI designed a small circuit back in January. I ended up going with a PIC microcontroller because it was the only thing I could find that supported USB and was in-stock. I ordered enough parts to build four, from Digikey. Now, 6 months later, I want to build some more, and about half of the BOM is out of stock on Digikey. I was able to source most stuff on Mouser instead, but the switches I used weren't available anywhere and I had to go to a different manufacturer, driving the cost from $12 of switches per build to $18. Huge pain in the ass, but at least I was able to get it done. I feel for the people who designed around particular parts and are now starting at 2023 "in stock" dates.
- ok_dad 4y agoI used to work in medical device supplier quality and incoming inspection and I am so happy I don't work there right now, it must be an absolute shit show with different/new part numbers, probably tons of first article inspections, and spec changes galore.
- aconsult1 4y agoI'm a co-founder of a niche multi-effect pedalboard company and we're filing for bankruptcy in Germany this very week. It's not only the crazy price changes and random stocking issues. Small players have zero leverage with suppliers and are a much weaker link in this whole chaos. Good luck trying to find investors willing to put money to drive growth. Hardware startups is absolutely brutal. No surprise so many fail after a "successful" Kickstarter campaign. I'm actually surprised we're only going under nearly 30 months after the pandemic started. I would bet that millions of people will be unemployed because a gazillion of small companies will shut off in the next 18 months. I'll never start (or work for) a hardware company for the rest of my life. Software is so much a better business to invest that makes me cry just thinking how much money and years I lost of my life.
- webspaceadam 4y agodas tut mir wirklich leid. nur das beste für die zukunft. manchmal wird mut nicht belohnt :(
- rPlayer6554 4y agoI'm so sorry to hear about that, it seems really frustrating. I hope things work out for you.
- lnsru 4y agoI fell you! I am thinking about nice 3D sensor for robotic applications. I have hardware prototype and rudimentary software. However no parts are available for sale, so I am not able to advance to production ready version. Very frustrating! Happily I can fund my development from other sources and have long runway. I dodged a large caliber bullet not going all in with this single project 18 months ago.
- aconsult1 4y agoI don't want to deposit fear into your dreams. You should follow what your heart tells you. But not going all in was probably the smartest decision you've made. Good luck!
- 4y ago
- unionpivo 4y agoProblem is most of the world was in "just in time manufacturing" and having no inventory. Then there were supply issues, and everybody is not only trying to get their hand on the parts they need, but they also try to stockpile some components just in case. Essentially marked changed completely, and is throwing off all kinds of estimates and people are still trying to figure out what is what. Buyers are trying to stockpile as much as they can get, I know at least one company that bought run of 50k stm micros, not for any particular project, just in case they will need them. Hardware companies are claiming they are increasing capacity, but are doing it reluctantly, because they think it will be blown over, and they will have a lot of extra capacity, that they wont be able to sell.
- IAmPym 4y agoContext: I work at Sequential Running a business is not easy. Weathering a storm like this is not easy. Synth company or not, we're in difficult times. A lot of businesses will close but the people who are patient and can manage to wait it out, be flexible, and figure out new ways to innovate when the whiplash effect swings back in our direction will push forward the next generation of amazing instruments. Prices will go up, as they naturally do, and we'll have new winners and losers. No reason to get all doomsayer on it all at this point, kind of a few years late on that one.
- Pr0ject217 4y agoHow is the atmosphere at work? It's incredibly sad that Dave passed away.
- IAmPym 4y agoIt isn't easy carrying the torch of a legend but standing on the shoulders of giants is how we move things forward as a species. I'm confident I can speak for the company when I say we are doing our best to keep his legacy going.
- Pr0ject217 4y ago<3
- CoastalCoder 4y agoI'm curious about the technical expertise that goes into making a good synth. If economics force the synth-making hardware / software engineers into other industries, how long does it take to replace (or restore) their expertise once the economy recovers?
- IAmPym 4y agoThe difference is people in our industry are typically already taking a huge pay cut. People shuffle in and out but usually they end up back in the audio industry because... well... it's freaking awesome. How many other places can you work where you regularly get rockstars inviting you to hang out backstage because they love your work? Typically we have more people willing to leave a high paying job just to work in our industry than we have people leaving but, just like any industry, losing experience and contextual knowledge always hurts.
- CoastalCoder 4y agoWhat's the current prognosis for supply chains returning to stability? The last I heard, the main culprits were (a) COVID shutting down Chinese factories; (b) cargo-ship related shipping delays; (c) COVID-related demand for work-from-home electronics; and (d) follow-on problems caused by hoarding. My impression was that (a, b, c) are largely behind us now. Does that mean we just need to give things a little time? [Edited for clearer wording.]
- bobthepanda 4y agoI don’t think a or b have eased up much. Zero-covid means that ports in China can still lock up on a moment’s notice; Shanghai had a total lockdown for months, and is China’s largest port.
- bornfreddy 4y agoI would add e) - if the whole western economy depends on a single country as a supplier, and this country wants to become the world leader, then it is in the interest of the said country to make as much economic problems for west as possible, but not so much that the countries would again develop local supply or import from elsewhere. Excuses a), b), c) and d) are very handy for this and allow the said country to walk the fine line. It helps if the country is tightly run. Genius and scary to watch.
- KerrAvon 4y agoThere are enough western observers in Shenzhen etc that I find this attractive explanation somewhat wanting.
- bornfreddy 4y agoWhat do they observe, and how do you think this will help? Note that I don't blame the unnamed country, they would be stupid not to bank on the fact that they are the major / only producer. The trouble lies with our shortsighted greed where it is more important to save money on costs than to manage risks (IP theft, depending on a single entity). We'll see, hope (but doubt) I'm wrong.
- miketery 4y agoCan some one in semi conductor industry explain which chips there is a shortage of and what kind of industrial capacity needs to come online to create supply? I'm familiar with CPU / GPUs (i.e. very expensive equipment, facilities, etc.), but curious if most chips will do with using cheaper and older generation as sufficient. For example power MOSFETs, microcontrollers, etc.
- pjc50 4y ago"Wafers", i.e. the capacity of fabs to process silicon into chips. This capacity is more or less fixed at time of fab construction; if you want to expand, you need to buy more wafer processing machines from ASML. There is a queue for these as well. The nastier problem is that most of the microcontrollers are probably on older wafer processes (e.g. 65nm), and nobody wants to build a new old line. So it's up to the part suppliers to rework the design for e.g. 22nm if space becomes available on newer lines.
- kzrdude 4y agoHowever, scaling down a custom chip to 22 nm requires a complete rework of the design, yes? At least any analog parts if I understand correctly.
- zrobotics 4y agoDigital as well. Even if the overall design is similar, layout is dependent on the node size. Plus, the masks have to be remade at a not insubstantial cost.
- pjc50 4y agoAnalog subsystems will require rework from scratch; digital can usually keep the same HDL, and its associated test suite, but changing to much smaller standard cells completely changes the timing properties. So all the timing closure and layout work needs to be re-done. Budget about 50% of the original cost, approximately.
- varjag 4y ago
- rasz 4y agoYou are the problem if you wait two years for F7 instead of retooling. >We have open orders for thousands of microcontrollers from NXP and Microchip. The problem extends far beyond processors. Texas Instrument power switchers used throughout the industry are in very short supply; we use them for pulling down 15V supplies to 3.3V or to generate +/- and 48V phantom power rails. We also cannot get some ESD protection parts, power MOSFETs and a number of somewhat obscure analog switching ICs. We’re also paying 30-40% more for metal cases and packaging. Meanwhile less reputable Chinese branded replacements are plentiful and cheap.
- CamperBob2 4y agoRetool for what? How do you know whatever you choose will be available for production?
- rasz 4y agoDont go for fancy new parts, use what Chinese use at volume.
- krnlpnc 4y agoThats a good way to get a reputation for gear that dies on you. Instrument components need to be extra robust, they are put through a lot of abuse.
- zrobotics 4y agoPlus, pro audio gear needs to be on the same order of reliability as industrial equipment. For instance, an artist that has a piece of gear fry has potentially wrecked a contracted performance (which can affect revenue as well as reputation). This could also heppen during recording, which ruins very expensive studio time that may be pre-paid for. For most of the software devs here, having a computer fry would be at most a 1 day loss of productivity and a neglible effect on overall company earnings. Not so true when you have a booked venue and your amp or synth just blew up during sound check hours before the show opens. It's honestly not that dissimilar to how industrial equipment can cause huge revenue effects from a failure due to lost productivity.
- Qub3d 4y agoJason, the cofounder of Schiit Audio (its pronounced exactly as you think it is) regularly posts updates about the company to an audiophile forum, and his posts regarding the supply chain problems they've fought in the past 2 years are fascinating: * https://www.head-fi.org/threads/schiit-happened-the-story-of-the-worlds-most-improbable-start-up.701900/page-5824#post-16759741 https://www.head-fi.org/threads/schiit-happened-the-story-of... * https://www.head-fi.org/threads/schiit-happened-the-story-of-the-worlds-most-improbable-start-up.701900/page-5871#post-16797999 https://www.head-fi.org/threads/schiit-happened-the-story-of... * https://www.head-fi.org/threads/schiit-happened-the-story-of-the-worlds-most-improbable-start-up.701900/page-5951#post-16859594 https://www.head-fi.org/threads/schiit-happened-the-story-of...
- Dracophoenix 4y agoNow there's a name I haven't heard in a while. I enjoy the company's no-nonsense designs, but as Audio Science Review and NwAvGuy have proven, objectively higher quality audiophile equipment can be bought or built for much less money than Schitt is asking for.
- Qub3d 4y agoObjectivity and audiophile in the same sentence always makes me suspicious, especially when you are looking at the 100s to 1000s of extra dollars for 3-5% improvement on measurements (and good luck detecting that in an ABX test). I moved to a modi/magni stack from a Fiio portable and I don't know if I'll ever bother to upgrade again.
- MuffinFlavored 4y agoIronically, I'd be pretty hard pressed to believe you could tell the "quality" from a Fiio DAC compared to an iPhone
- bee_rider 4y agoIIRC the iPhone dac/amp is supposed to be fairly decent for driving, like, normal headphones. At least in the past (not sure in the post-dongle days).
- jl6 4y agoFeels like this is a golden opportunity, and possibly our last chance, to re-onshore supply chains to the west. Will anyone take it, or will we just wait around until China sorts itself out and resumes its steady ascendancy?
- _8j50 4y agoYou can distribute it to india,vietnam,south america but onshore isn't happening. Especially not in a pseudo-recession where you can't pass on cost to consumers like before (at least not more than what is already).
- Analemma_ 4y agoNo they won't, because fabs are long-term investments and anyone who onshores because of this crisis will be fucked over when things return to normal and their costs are suddenly many times higher than the ones of their competitors who stayed in China. Re-onshoring requires massive, permanent subsidies from the government to be a realistic proposition, and it is far from clear that we have the will to do that.
- beebmam 4y agoChina's plans are to maintain Zero-COVID until at least the mid 2020's. China will not sort itself out. It's a complete disaster
- coliveira 4y agoI think you're blindsided by American media. COVID lockdowns are not nearly as big a problem as they are presented in the West. First of all, any lockdown is for at most a few weeks. Second, China has dozens of huge cities, and they are all working extra when a couple of cities are locked out due to COVID. The Chinese are doing this in a planed way that will have a minimal impact on the economy in the long run. The fall down of Chinese economy due to lockdowns is just another fantasy of US media.
- markdown 4y ago> The fall down of Chinese economy due to lockdowns is just another fantasy of US media. I guess everyone else in this thread is just imagining the lack of supply from China.
- KennyBlanken 4y ago"“You’re looking at 1000pcs of the STM32H7 microcontroller. The beating heart of our beloved S2400,” they note. “I placed a panic order for these babies almost 2 years ago. Today, they finally arrived. It looks like we’re a go on the next batch of S2400s!”" ...and there's at least part of the problem. People panic-buying a year's worth of component supplies.
- mzs 4y agoYeah those seem like run of the mill parts easily replaceable with another board.
- runnerup 4y ago*another chip, not another board, usually. By the time you redesign your board for the other chip, it’s sold out too. We are dealing with this, it’s horrible. It’s not just chips either, it’ll be common passive components sometimes as well.
- varjag 4y ago1000pcs is a small order in normal times. Also buying a year's worth of supply is entirely normal. Time flies when you work with production of physical goods.
- lin83 4y agoIt's difficult to overstate how bad things have been for the past 1.5yrs. Automotive and Industrial microcontrollers and components in particular are impossible to source. I have a friend at one of the big US semiconductor companies. His team exhausted their main competitor's evaluation boards stocks on various sites to strip them for components to populate their own boards (which are hand delivered to selected customers). For non-critical applications they're using grey market Chinese components and even Chinese clones of some of their less complicated parts. Even then it's far from enough. ASML, who makes some of the most advanced products on earth for semiconductor manufacturing, have apparently purchased washing machines to harvest components. [1] [1] https://hothardware.com/news/asml-ceo-claims-chip-shortage-firms-harvesting-washing-machines-semiconductors https://hothardware.com/news/asml-ceo-claims-chip-shortage-f...
- varjag 4y ago1.5 years? The shortages started back in 2016 and are only getting worse. By 2018 it was already positively challenging with new designs.
- murkt 4y ago> ASML, who makes some of the most advanced products on earth for semiconductor manufacturing, have apparently purchased washing machines to harvest components. Your link doesn’t support this claim. It says that other companies are doing that, not ASML itself.
- tomc1985 4y agoI wonder, would this make analog synths more competitive? Like why do they even need DSP chips, might as well just run a VST softsynth with a MIDI keyboard
- SeanLuke 4y agoAnalog synths have tons of chips in them.
- bowsamic 4y agoNot really there’s a huge op amp shortage too
- dmicah 4y agoWhile not DSP chips, analog synths will typically also include microcontrollers, for scanning a keyboard or front panel controls, receiving MIDI messages, and generating control voltages.
- leviathant 4y ago>Like why do they even need DSP chips, might as well just run a VST softsynth with a MIDI keyboard When your analog synth has presets, it's because there's a DSP chip in there that's helping to record, store, and replay voltage values for the knobs and sliders and switches in the analog signal path. If your analog synthesizer has a sequencer, there's a pretty solid chance that's done on a chip. If your analog synthesizer has a modern modulation matrix, you need a DSP chip for that. If your analog synthesizer has a method for self-calibration, you need a DSP for that. The signal path stays analog in any of these situations, but the DSP helps you manufacture things that aren't feasible with simple components. There's a lot of cool stuff you can do with VSTs. There's a lot of weird-ass gain staging/overdrive stuff I can do with boxes on my desk that plug into each other, or even within a singular synthesizer, which cannot currently be replicated effectively with code. One day it'll catch up. Roland's ACB is a few years old now, but it's pretty good at mimicking 40 year old technology. It took a long time for a Windows machine to run an SNES emulator at a decent enough rate to play what was already at the time very old technology. I've got a mixing console from 1978 that I prefer to VSTs. The Poly Evolver Keyboard I have is as old as YouTube... nothing else sounds like it, there is no emulation of it, and I'm glad I don't need a 2005-era computer kicking around to keep it running. This is not to discount that there are amazing VSTs, and that physical controller options are amazing today (and amazingly inexpensive), but these are different options, not better options.
- tomg 4y agoEurorack got hit hard. Lots of module makers are tiny shops, some just one person selling a few pieces at a time.
- CarVac 4y agoThe custom gamecube controller project I'm on (https://github.com/PhobGCC https://github.com/PhobGCC) has clobbered the supply of Teensy 4 microcontroller boards. We already redesigned to switch away from Teensy 3.2, which had production suspended indefinitely due to parts shortages.
- rasz 4y ago600MHz 1MB microcontroller seems a little bit of an overkill for something $0.8 can easily handle https://lcsc.com/product-detail/ST-Microelectronics_STMicroelectronics-STM32G030F6P6TR_C529330.html https://lcsc.com/product-detail/ST-Microelectronics_STMicroe...
- zamadatix 4y ago512,000 cycles per poll is probably plenty but I think the SRAM might be a bit small for that code. Could something be made to fit in that and still do the same things? Probably but it likely wouldn't be as easy on either the software or hardware side. Sometimes a lunch is worth more than the extra hassle of optimizing.
- CarVac 4y agoThe Teensy 3.2 was fast enough; we're running matrix math for remapping the stick gates and a modified Kalman filter at 1000 Hz, and bitbanging the GameCube protocol meanwhile. Teensy 4 is overkill and we've been clocking them at 150 MHz to reduce power draw.
- bschwindHN 4y agoWhat did you switch to? I was going to recommend the RP2040 but you've probably already got things sorted out.
- CarVac 4y agoWe already switched from Teensy 3.2 to Teensy 4 because 3.2s are unobtainable. RP2040 is what we're looking at but it has ADC issues apparently. We're going to try though.
- fleddr 4y agoIt feels like we're at the end of an era. Most of us spent an entire lifetime in a particular model. The model being that supply is pretty much unlimited, given that you have money. And even money is a pretty fluid concept. Not only is everything unlimited, in recent years we've also made most of it instant. We've become completely detached from real world resources like commodities but also workers. Indoctrinated to the maximum into this consumer economy, ordering something and learning that you can't have it despite putting up the money, comes as a system shock. The very concept of "NO" is back from past times. What do you mean, no? I said I want it. Optimists would find it an excellent time to recalibrate society. Acknowledge critical dependencies and in-source them. Spent limited resources, such as workers, on areas considered vital instead of dispersing them across a million things less vital. Of course, none of this will actually happen. Just like during COVID where we had the "nature is healing" meme, we soon learned that it's same-old as soon as restrictions were lifted. We're unwilling to let go of a fragile and unsustainable global supply chain. We're afraid to make any hard choice at all. Unlike China. We're all aware their economy is more planned but one of their most fascinating moves is to slash the tech sector. And with "tech" I mean what the US considers tech. Which is the stuff coming out of SV. Most of it is entertainment, social network stuff, games, the like. According to China, this isn't tech. It's unimportant soft tech that in many ways is a net negative to society. Plus it's hard to censor. So they decimated the entire thing and re-calibrated "tech" to real-world tech. I'm in no way in favor of this type of intervention but I do find it a fascinating example of making actual hard choices. In the West, we don't seem to prioritize anything at all, we'd rather continue with the limitless illusion in a world that isn't.
- garbanz0 4y agoThis is well written but also very alarmist. There are supply chain issues, but in the west they're limited to certain industries. Amazon orders still arrive in two days. My grocery store is still stocked full. Inflation sucks, and so does the stock market, but we're in the middle of a European war and just out of a global pandemic. Demand has already risen to pre-pandemic levels, so supply will eventually reorient to meet it. All things considered, the economy is still doing pretty great!
- TaupeRanger 4y agoWith the advent of modern software emulations and MIDI controllers, I'm surprised many of these companies are still in business. There have been so many blind tests where audio experts can't tell the difference between pure analog and pure digital modeling. I know some people like the knobs and buttons as a catalyst for exploration, but anything you might do with an analog synth knob you can ultimately do in a software model. And when good synths cost $3,000 and up, the value just isn't there unless you're just trying to impress people that walk into your studio.
- 3565366 4y agoIt isn't about the quality of the audio, although in some cases it is. For most, navigating a physical device is still a much easier workflow than navigating software synths. There are so many advantages to software synths, but also working within the limitations of hardware forces you into a creative head space you might not get with software. I always felt uninspired by software at least until I discovered VCV Rack, but even then sometimes clicking around and zooming in and out feels tedious. Midi controllers are great, but setting them up can be a negative experience. The other big issue with software synths honestly is DRM. Some have DRM that is just as bad as video game DRM. I got locked out permanently from a VST I was using to generate melody data, and when I reached out to support they told me nothing could be done and I would have to re-buy the VST again. What happened was I had to keep inputting my license because occasionally, the license info would become disassociated with my VST. What I didn't know was this counted towards the max number of installs my license was capable of. The other big issue with VST is you end up in a situation where you cannot update your operating system because over time, VST's become unsupported and will not run correctly when you update your OS, DAW software, or audio drivers. This is an absolute disaster in terms of security. I would rather work within the limitations of synth hardware than deal with all the pain that comes with software. I still use VST software though. Aside from VCV Rack Serum is outstanding and will do almost anything you could possibly need a synth to do, and it does not have crazy licensing issues. I think most artists use a hybrid hardware/software workflow, but there are definitely disadvantages no matter what path you choose.
- thrtythreeforty 4y ago
- recursive 4y agoPersonal anecdote: I ordered a synth from Sweetwater on 4/1. It's shipping now. (Yamaha Reface DX)
- zrobotics 4y agoYamaha isn't facing nearly the same issues as the boutique makes, since they have the scale to be able to do volume buys and negotiate with vendors directly. I doubt the folks at places like Teenage Engineering are buying in quantities large enough to get any consideration from the vendors, they are likely just purchasing from digikey & mouser. So 4/1 is already a pretty poor lead time, but it's even worse for the specialty suppliers.
- Fargoan 4y agoThe wait times for the SP404 MK2 have been crazy. I ordered one last month and I wouldn't be surprised if I have to wait until next year before I get it
- s1mon 4y agoEven without Covid etc., the synth business is very challenging from a supply chain standpoint. The quantities and margins are not great. The highest selling synth of all time was the DX7. It sold ~200k units. Most stuff sells much fewer units. It's part of why you will see several models that use similar parts so that they can leverage some scale. Even if a company manages to combine the BOMs from several models to improve buying power, unless you are Yamaha, Roland, or Korg, it's unlikely that you have enough overall volumes to get allocations from component suppliers. The consumer electronics and automotive are going to be way ahead of any synth company.
- synicalx 4y agoWhen we say "supply chain issues", what specifically does that mean? I keep seeing this being used as the new catch-all explanation for everything, but I never see it clearly defined anywhere and I'm very curious.
- pipeline_peak 4y agoHow much of this is supply chain issues and not the aging fact that physical synthesizers are long on their way out?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ioseph 4y agoIs part of the issue non musical electronic devices all moving digital? I imagine there's a lot of analog IC's that were previously used across a wide range of industries are now moving far less units.
- elihu 4y agoThere's still a lot of analog music happening, especially in the modular synthesis world. They're a tiny part of the whole market for electronic components, though.
- tomxor 4y agoFinally my Raspberry pi hoard will be useful for something! I knew buying them and almost immediately putting them in a draw would make sense eventually.
- elihu 4y agoI kind of wonder what this means for our prospects of being able to make complicated products in the future. Presumably this will all settle out and we'll eventually settle back into a working supply chain that's maybe a little less centralized and with more redundancy. But that's not guaranteed. In order to deal with climate change and maintain a decent quality of living, we need to replace a lot of ICE vehicles with electric replacements over the next decade or two. What happens if major manufacturers just can't make cars because the parts aren't available, and we're basically just stuck with the cars we already have for as long as we can keep them running? This has already happened to some extent thanks to Covid-19 and poor logistics planning, but it could be a lot longer and a lot worse if, say, China were to attempt to invade Taiwan or there's some new, unexpected catastrophe (natural or artificial).
- rightbyte 4y agoCars are needlessly complex electronics wise today. If they had to throw out most of the fluff too be able to build cars I would see it as an improvement. The computer systems are used for spying and DRM subscription buttheaters anyway.
- jrochkind1 4y ago> In 2018, the Trump administration imposed an import tax on Chinese electronics components, and this has stayed in place under Biden... The administration also banned sale of some components to China, which created a disincentive for US companies to manufacturer these parts. Oh, well of course it would. Is this actually an industrial policy with rational goals, or just random flailing?
- kohlerm 4y agoThank you Trump, you idi..
- brainwipe 4y agoSimilar issues can be found with drones too - STM32 flight controllers and gyroscopes are both in short supply. The prices have lept up and supply has dwindled.
- _def 4y agoTime for virtual synth to rise and shine again? So far I feel like softsynths sound amazing, but the hapric of a real device with knobs makes a huge difference in using it. Now, I wonder if it's time someone comes up with a fundamental different interface approach for a soft synth that lowers this creative barrier.
- boffinAudio 4y agoThese are some pretty great soft-synths worth checking out: Monome Norns: https://monome.org/docs/norns/ https://monome.org/docs/norns/ Zynthian: https://zynthian.org/ https://zynthian.org/
- pelasaco 4y ago... And the amount of ads on this page was just killing the user experience there.. I like to keep the ads enabled to help to support small sites, but no way in that case.
- substation13 4y agoWhy can't synths be fully emulated in software?
- ris 4y agoThey more or less can, but people like the physical gear for the "feels" (see also: vintage guitars and valve amps). It's increasingly absurd given that more and more synth modules are almost entirely digital and microcontroller-based. I find it hard to have a lot of sympathy here.
- odiroot 4y agoThey can, they are and in most cases it's enough. But it's more about the user experience. Hardware is more immediate.
- substation13 4y agoWhat about a physical interface that can control any software synth?
- odiroot 4y agoWell, there's a lot of MIDI controllers that can approximate that. I use AKAI MPK Mini for example. There's even some dedicated MIDI controllers that look a bit like miniature hardware synth, but they're not worth it, in my opinion. Usually costing around a price of a real synth.
- AtomicOrbital 4y agogood side of current supply chain issues is this encourages hardware manufacturers to make the transition away from using domain specific computer chips and to instead rewrite that logic purely in software to get executed in today's super fast super efficient CPU/GPU ... decades ago it made sense to design hardware to do the compute yet today that strategy is more costly and risky ... and yes software is eating the world and where it isn't it will be so make this jump now