5 ms·
I mean, TBH this seems like a pretty dumb scam, and you have to be pretty gullible to fall for it. Send my bank account information over to a company before I'v
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
I mean, TBH this seems like a pretty dumb scam, and you have to be pretty gullible to fall for it. Send my bank account information over to a company before I've actually had face-to-face conversation with anyone there? And who would expect to get an offer letter before you've even had an actual interview (as opposed to just some questionnaire you had to fill out)?
- yieldcrv 4y agoI mean if I said it was for Direct Deposit this would match many candidates and employees experience.
- aynyc 4y agoPeople are gullible. I can probably build a website with reasonably fake job listings, and ask job applicants to fill out I-9. I'm pretty sure I can get a lot of personal data from that.
- vlunkr 4y agoThere are lots of dumb scams. It's a numbers game, you reach out to thousands of people and if only a few bite, you're probably still making a profit.
- V-2 4y agoPlus the "offer" (and all email communication) is run from a Gmail account, they didn't even bother to spoof or semi-spoof a credible looking address. Of course they're not targeting the best and brightest, but this is by design - such folks wouldn't jump at a random job opportunity to begin with
- elcomet 4y agoI'm not sure it help to shame people who fall for those scams. People do fall for it, scammed are exploiting human's trust that most people are nice. Most scams seem dumb once you know about them. And once some scam becomes well known, scammers will just change tactics. The important thing is to educate people (for example do not give your bank information over the phone ever, except if you are the one who called maybe) and have good insurances in case something like this happens. And I believe it could happen to any of us, even people who think they're not gullible.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoSorry, I didn't mean to shame folks, I just meant to highlight that there is very little in this scam that seems new or clever, so it doesn't seem particularly noteworthy. I probably get a couple of similar scams directed to me every week (we joke in our company how we all get texts from our "CEO" asking to respond to an urgent need...) Every now and then I'll read about an online phishing/spear-phishing scam and think "Wow, that is really good. I definitely may have fallen for that!" (e.g. the "delayed disconnect" phone scam - TBH I didn't even realize some landlines worked like that.) This is not one of those times.
- nerdponx 4y agoTIL about delayed disconnect. Scary!
- slig 4y agoThere's a reason why there are a lot of typos, broken English, fake emails from gmail, etc, they do not want to waste time on non-gullible people.
- ghaff 4y ago>And who would expect to get an offer letter before you've even had an actual interview (as opposed to just some questionnaire you had to fill out)? Many years ago now but I did get a job offer out of grad school on the basis of a mass mailed job application cover letter/resume. (And this was with a major aerospace company.) Only did a site visit/interview after I asked for it.
- omoikane 4y agoDue to the rising trend of people working remotely, some people might have never had any physical contact with the people they work with, all the way from interview up to signing the contract. It might be difficult for these people to verify that a startup is legit.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoI work in a remote company, and have hired a ton of people remotely. How many folks do you know who are hired remotely without ever having even a phone call, not to mention a video/zoom call?
- omoikane 4y agoSince a lot of interviewers conducted interviews from their homes during the pandemic, I am not sure just being able to see a person would provide enough assurance.
- oplav 4y agoI was on a Zoom interview panel where it was clear that the interviewee had someone else on an earpiece and was being fed answers. When we conversed about non-technical things, the interviewee spoke clearly and fluently. But when we'd ask a targeted technical follow-up to something on their resume, they would always repeat the question slowly, and then robotically with several pauses say their answer back. Another interviewer said they could hear the voice in the earpiece talking in between their pauses. I'm not sure what their end goal was with getting hired, but we ended up cutting the panel short.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoDon't disagree, but that didn't happen in this case.
- dahart 4y agoYounglings may have no idea what’s normal, right? I don’t know anyone who’s been hired without a call or interview, but that isn’t necessarily relevant; it doesn’t mean that scam is obvious to someone who’s never been hired anywhere before, or is too excited about the prospect of a decent job to question the process. Lots of scams are somewhat based on people’s general reluctance to challenge someone else, especially when there’s a prize or benefit on the line, this is a human trait.
- _jal 4y agoCompanies are increasingly intrusive when hiring, like everyone else. Running background, credit, etc. checks for low-level employees was considered absurd not too long ago, now it is routine. Especially young folks, excited by their great new gig, are likely to be unclear on where, exactly, the line is, or not think through the implications of things happening in the wrong order. (At my current gig, one of the first things HR did after we signed was ask me for direct deposit info.)
- formerkrogemp 4y agoI applied for a job couple of years ago that wanted a cognitive assessment and what they billed as an IQ test. I applied to several other jobs that had such absurd hoops that, as you say, it became routine for low level work. It's not that we're naive youngsters who don't know any better. We just often don't have a choice. There's no chance to save money or to live off savings when young unless living with relatives while working, and that becomes burdensome quite quickly.
- _jal 4y ago> It's not that we're naive youngsters who don't know any better. Sorry if it came out that way, that wasn't my intent. Fake jobs were not a thing that I encountered when entering the market, but I almost certainly would have fallen for anything that wasn't utterly incompetent. > We just often don't have a choice. This isn't new. I grew up very poor, and it wasn't until my mid-30's that I had things paid off and could start thinking about what economic security might feel like someday. What's new is that middle-class young people are starting to have that experience, too.
- bornfreddy 4y agoI don't understand this part, is this US-specific? (Genuinly curious... I'm from EU) If I send my banking details to some company here they can deposit funds (as in, pay) to it. No way can they withdraw anything without my authorization. So how does this scam even work? Or am I missing something?
- jenthoven 4y ago[This is Julia, the OC] It’s not exactly clear what the end scam will be. Scammers ask for bank info, a photo of your ID, and credit info. Sounds like some sort of identity theft or bank withdrawal situation.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoWelcome to the byzantine world of ACH transfers in the US. Short of it is that, no, they do not need your specific authorization to initiate a withdrawal. Here's how ACH works: 1. One banking institution is the ODFI - originating depository financial institution, that makes the request. The other is the RDFI - receiving depository financial institution. In order to make a withdrawal, the ODFI sends the RDFI an ACH request that says "For this routing number (which determines the RDFI), for this account number and account holder name, debit $XXX amount and send it to me, the ODFI." No other authorization is necessary from the account holder. 2. The RDFI will send the ODFI (basically, the ACH process is more complicated) the money, BUT the RDFI has 90 days I believe (maybe longer) to pull the money back (search for "R10 ACH response code). If they do, the ODFI is left "holding the bag" and must return the funds. Thus, it's up to the ODFI to ensure that the user who initiated the withdrawal in the first place is authorized to do so. Thus, a common ACH scam is: 1. Bad guy opens account at some financial institution with a stolen identity. 2. Many fintechs and online banks use Plaid to link to an account at an external institution to transfer funds. If the bad guy somehow has stolen credentials, then they link Plaid to that external account. 3. Bad guy initiates the ACH. Most ODFIs will then hold the funds for 2-5 days (depends on how long the account has been open, there are banking rules about how long they can hold it) specifically because of this return possibility. 4. Bad guy then tries to withdraw the money as soon as they can. If the original account holder doesn't notice the money missing from their account for, say, 2 weeks, the bad buy will have gotten the money and the ODFI is the one that has to make good on the stolen funds. Google "ACH Fraud". It's a common problem with startups that don't realize all the intricacies and problems of the NACHA rules.