9 ms·
The Tyranny of Meritocracy
- protomyth 15y ago"In fact, if the last generation is any guide, your child growing up in the top two-fifths today will have a 60 percent chance of being in the top two fifths as an adult. That's the impact of picking the right parents -- increasing the chances of ending up middle- to upper-middle class by a factor of three or four." Let me get this straight. A kid starting in a bracket that includes 40% of the population has a 60% chance of remaining in that bracket as opposed to the 40% if it was totally random. I would actually have expected a higher %.
- sounds 15y agoThe article has other flaws as well, but the one I disagree most strongly with is: "But in the new aristocracy, it is rarely enough to just get born to the right parents; you also have to work very hard. (Higher earning men are now more likely to work more than 50 hours a week than are men in lower earnings quintiles.) Whatever the systemic injustices, it's also quite clear to everyone ... even parasitic leeches of investment bankers ... that their salaries only come as the result of frantic effort." Here's what I think is missing from that paragraph. I've tried to label each logical fallacy, but I could be fallacious (hah!) in my labelling. Argue to the point, I'm not interested in getting the fallacy names just perfect. (Here's a source if you want one: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fallacy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fallacy ) 1. How can she attack hard work and intelligence? She doesn't state what metric she is using, but I assume it's what she starts the next paragraph with: "one's parents to confer such enduring advantages is obviously unfair." If hard-working well-educated parents teach their children to be hard-working and well-educated, that does not prove hard-working poorly-educated parents cannot. "Hasty generalization" fallacy? 2. What justification does she have to write off "systemic injustices" with a summary "whatever"? Should that not have been the focus of the article? "Straw man" fallacy? 3. Why are investment bankers singled out? "Ad hominem" fallacy?
- scott_s 15y agoPerhaps I can summarize what I think are her real points: The old system was an aristocracy, where people were born into positions at the top of society, and this was obvious unfair. However, this system was not stable. The new system is (supposedly) a meritocracy, where people have to work towards high positions in society. This system is not obviously unfair. But it is stable, because parents tend to instill the qualities required to succeed in their children. Her point was that what these two systems have in common is that who your parents were is a good predictor of where you will end up.
- protomyth 15y agoYeah, I'm with you on point 1, particulary since I know a lot of parents that got a grade school education, but taught their children to value education. It is kind of the standard immigrant story. Her arguments seem really lazy and not well justified.
- pg 15y agoThe root of the problem (or at least the fixable part of the problem) is probably schools. Rich people arrange for their kids to go to good schools, and poor kids end up stuck in bad schools. So maybe the best way to narrow the gap is to make the worst schools better. That would be a good thing to do regardless. Startups may be able to help: http://imaginek12.com http://imaginek12.com
- klbarry 15y agoThe KIPP program seems to work very well. I believe it's because it creates a cult-like environment, and I mean this in the best and most impressed way. It keeps poor opportunity kids (chosen by lottery) in school from very early to very late as many days as it can, loads them with homework, promotes group cohesiveness, and generally drills in the schools messages. Since the home neighborhood environment is often toxic, a complete environmental change seems to do the trick.
- Alex3917 15y ago"Since the home neighborhood environment is often toxic, a complete environmental change seems to do the trick." ...As measured by standardized testing, on a good day, and when you analyze the data the right way. And who knows what sorts of longterm problems KIPP could be causing in these kids and within their communities. The fact that the 'best' idea in educational reform is basically just taking kids away from their parents for virtually all of their waking hours shows that America is on its last legs. We no longer have the cognitive infrastructure necessary to transmit learning from parents to children, so I think KIPP is really just a hail mary attempt to try to buy some time before the whole system collapses.
- klbarry 15y agoThank you for this reply. I am very interested in seeing data against the KIPP model - what sources would you recommend? EDIT: just read http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Knowledge_Is_Power_Program#Criticism_and_commentary http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Knowledge_Is_Power_Program#Crit..., which is certainly interesting.
- jisaacstone 15y agoI wonder if free education would help? At any rate I am still more concerned with inequality than with relative mobility within quintiles. There is always going to be a larger number who stay than those who move, and the numbers here are not as bad as the author makes them seem
- marquis 15y agoFree education generally means that there are fewer placements. In countries where university used to be free you had to excel to be accepted, so many students left school with only the opportunity to enter the trades or an apprenticeship. Once universities charged fees, they could open up to a broader range of students. This may leave us where we are now - with people with degrees and heavy loan payments but maybe it's just a transition period we have to go through, where students start to become directed more into areas that actually suit them rather than the default bachelor degree. I'm not convinced on either method and would like to see a balance in between, and better funding for apprenticeships.
- einhverfr 15y agoApprenticeships rock. Actually as I am looking at expanding my business, I am actually looking to an apprenticeship/guild model for scalability rather than a traditional corporate model.
- jka 15y agoWhile I agree that improving access to education and opportunities for all is a big part of the remedy, I do have to take a disagreement with the author's initial statement that wealth ratios aren't worth considering. Expensive education may be one part of the gap that appears to be widening, but as wealth disparity grows, so does power disparity. Money can't buy you happiness, or even 'true' friends perhaps, but it can buy you influence and it can keep people following you. This can let the wealthy 'open' job and experience opportunities where others might not be so fortunate.
- phaedon 15y agoRight. Wealth has both absolute and relative terms. The poor in American today have it better in many ways than even nobility in millennia past. But there is also a relative component to wealth too. If Bill Gates and his class can pay for their children to receive personal instruction from the best tutors and at the best schools, that does price/crowd out the less wealthy. But that's because the tutors and schools will naturally seek to get more money rather than less money. I think most people would. So it's hard to know how to solve this problem short of forcing these tutors to do what others want at the point of a gun, or cloning them, etc. None of these seem very satisfying. I pump this from time to time, but MIT's OpenCourseWare does a great job of making a fantastic education widely available. Perhaps this is a model others could adopt more widely.
- jfager 15y agoIt's hard for me to think of another reasonable person I disagree with more frequently than Megan McArdle. Other than pure envy, it's hard to see how I could somehow be made worse off if Bill Gates' income suddenly doubled, but everything else remained the same. Nobody reasonable begrudges anyone who is wealthy for creating commensurate value. The issue is with wealth that accumulates to those who don't, like CEOs who run their companies into the ground or bankers who crash the entire economy. If you're creating value, the wealth society has given you is probably a bargain for society; if you're not, it's an inefficient allocation of resources, a symptom of a systemic fault that hurts everyone else. It's actually rather more worrying if what they're giving their children is a strong education and an absolutely ferocious work ethic. An aristocracy that simply bequeaths money and social position to its children will eventually fall. And aristocracy that bequeaths the actual skills required to earn more money than everyone else is self perpetuating. Strong education + ferocious work ethic + skills to earn money seems like a weird definition of meritocracy to me, especially given that later in the article we acknowledge that this combo doesn't actually seem to be getting good results. A strong education does not necessarily imply you know how to apply it, and there's certainly a long history of people without that advantage succeeding. The dirty secret of working long hours is that much of it is either for show or spent doing shit work. And the 'actual skills' in question are still very frequently having the right connections. Don't tell me it got hostage to the wrong ideology--tell me why all those professors we paid millions of dollars to study economics couldn't provide a convincing rebuttal to that ideology in advance of the crash. Don't tell me that regulators were stupid or bankers got greedy until you first explain to me why tens of thousands of very well educated people, most of them graduates of colleges and professional schools that had aggressively winnowed them based on intelligence, barely outperformed a bunch of upstart micks, third-generation coupon-clipping WASP dimwits, and central bankers who still worshipped the barbarous relic of the gold standard? I... what?
- anigbrowl 15y agoYeah, that last paragraph didn't make sense to me either. I think her point is that for all the systemization and professionalization of knowledge over the last several decades, the boom(s) leading up to the financial crisis were just as irrational and ultimately ephemeral as the false wealth of the roaring 20s, when the financial sector was a comparative free-for-all.
- jheriko 15y ago"Other than pure envy, it's hard to see how I could somehow be made worse off if Bill Gates' income suddenly doubled, but everything else remained the same." This statement is enormously naive. Bill's money has to come from somewhere so the "everything else remained the same" is just not possible... Unfortunately if people are getting much richer than other people it is necessarily at other people's expense - a reasonable approximation is to think of money like energy, which can never be created or destroyed (its not quite true) - Bill doesn't make his pile of money out of nothing leaving everything unchanged, the money he makes comes from other people's piles of money - these need not be poorer people, in fact I bet most of them are big businesses, but then they don't get their money from nothing either, and their budget decisions on how much to spend on MS software will be balanced alongside salaries etc... at any rate, that money moves around and naively, if you made too much you would quite literally be making everyone else poor. I don't have access to huge amounts of data needed to workout how this scales in reality and if Bill is anywhere near the point where he is almost certainly making everyone poorer, but it is a trivial consequence of the nature of money. This is the nature of capitalism - if every one does what is in their best interest, some talented/lucky/greedy people will end up much better off with zero incentive to improve the situation for anyone else. Thankfully capitalism is merely an ideal and nobody follows it that blindly - Bill at least tries to give some of his money away to good causes lately...
- adamjernst 15y agoThis statement is enormously naive. Bill's money has to come from somewhere so the "everything else remained the same" is just not possible... Only if you see money as a fixed quantity of dollars. We're really talking about purchasing power here. Bill Gates invented a way to make anyone who used his products more efficient. (You can do a lot more with Windows than older OSes.) Since everyone is more efficient, your $1 can buy more. Of course, you will probably choose to give some of your money to Bill Gates, but since the rest is worth more it's a fair trade. (Also, no one can force you to give money to Bill. If you think it's not a fair trade, don't buy Windows; ignoring monopoly power here.) In formal terms, the economy is not a zero-sum game. Your assertion that "money is like energy, which can never be created or destroyed" is incorrect, if we're talking about the purchasing power of money and not its numerical face value.
- fleitz 15y ago"In fact, if the last generation is any guide, your child growing up in the top two-fifths today will have a 60 percent chance of being in the top two fifths as an adult." Great that means that 40% of the top two-fifths will be from people who earned their way up, instead of being born into it. Tyranny of meritocracy indeed, I mean what kind of uppity lower class kids are we raising who think they can earn wealth instead of inheriting it!
- michaelochurch 15y agoAny discussion of so-called "meritocracy" requires that we specify a timeframe. Short-frame meritocracy means that resources are allocated to people who will do the most with them now. Long-frame means that resources are given to people who will produce the most with them in the future (i.e. we invest in people whose short-term performance may be mediocre). Short-frame meritocracy is pragmatic and efficient in the context of a static time-frame, but doesn't produce growth or social justice in the long run. Resources (VC funding, jobs, educational opportunities) are allocated to those who don't need them. Long-frame meritocracy is fairer and more productive in the long run but much harder to implement because it requires a certain foresight. Most business decisions are made in the context of short-frame meritocracy. People aren't hired based on what they might become in 5 years, but based on what they're likely to be doing in 3 months. Schools are supposed to take more of a long-term outlook, but they have no real incentive to do so, and plenty of incentives (alumni and parental contributions) to kowtow to society at large and rubber-stamp the preselected winners. The truth is that iterated short-frame meritocracy is not much better than oligarchy. It's oligarchy with a tiny Brownian motion term thrown in, and the annealing rate is always calibrated so as not to threaten the overall shape of society. For a historic analogue, one might consider that it was very easy for the peasants of medieval Europe to believe that the nobility were of superior "merit". Merit at the time was physical might (and this wasn't unreasonable, since it also conferred the ability to protect others). First, the nobles were better nourished and much larger. Second, they knew how to use weapons, because they were trained. Third, they could ride horses. Feudal Europe was, fundamentally, a meritocracy (of the short-frame variety) for some definition of "merit".
- absconditus 15y ago"I don't care about income inequality. I care about the absolute condition of the poor--whether they are hungry, cold, and sick. But I do not care about the gap between their incomes, and those of Warren Buffet and Bill Gates." The entire article seems to be about income inequality.
- PotatoEngineer 15y agoI'm unclear on just how bad meritocracy is; the author blames meritocracy for the recent economic mess, sure. And our meritocracy isn't "perfect"; it doesn't guarantee that "good" workers end up well-off, and that "bad" workers end up destitute. Everyone has a leg up (or not) from their starting circumstances, which unbalances their supposed merit. But it's really hard to see what the comparison is. Was there more upward-mobility in the old aristocratic system? Were the leaders too stupid to make gargantuan mistakes? The article certainly doesn't have any good comparison to make, and there were certainly problems in the Good Old Days (like, say, the Great Depression), too. The whole article looks like it's trying to pin blame somewhere, and it has enough facts to get a decent start, but it has too many holes to be convincing.
- DanielBMarkham 15y agoPerhaps what really matters for accumulating wealth is not being transmitted in colleges? Call me crazy, but if your assumption is that opening the doors to the unwashed masses and funding lots of education for poor people raises them up, and it doesn't? Perhaps you should verify your assumptions. Perhaps what really matters for accumulating wealth is the modeling of attitudes and virtues from an existing wealthy set of parents. Much the same way that watching a movie of a famous piano player won't help you play the piano, but working day-to-day with one might, perhaps all this structural, fact-based education actually misses the point of how wealth really accumulates? Perhaps wealth generation is actually more of a learned art, not an applied science. EDIT: I see pg says this could also be the quality of the schools, and I think this dovetails in with what I'm saying. It's better to be around folks who model and demonstrate the best wealth-generating lifestyles in order to generate wealth yourself. When we look at the word "education," we are measuring the wrong thing. Don't know. Just putting it out there. I found this essay thought-provoking. Much better than the usual fare on this topic.
- lesterbuck 15y agoThis is one of the most chilling short audio essays I've ever listened to on NPR. de Botton blasts a huge hole in the idea of pure meritrocracy. Commentator Alain de Botton explores the darker side of a western ideal: meritocracy. http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=3200029 http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=3200029 I wish there was a transcript of this. I think he covers the basic topic in some of his books.
- edderly 15y agoInteresting listen. The topic is pretty challenging, especially so for the left leaning where quite often the political policy related by affluent lefties is "to give people the same opportunity as me" to compete in a meritocracy.
- skurry 15y agoNot everyone is cut out for a high-paying white collar job. Some people are passionate about doing construction work, driving a truck across the country, or even waiting tables. Or maybe one of these profession is most in line with their physical and intellectual abilities. These people believe (and rightly so I think) that if you put in your 40-50 hours of hard work per week in a blue-collar job, you should earn enough to afford a decent place to live, food, health care, child care, to send your kids to college and to retire once you're 65. The problem is today that this is less and less the case. This is what people are complaining about. They're not envious of the "Top 1%" making a lot more money than they do, instead, they are noticing that the "ruling class" is actively pushing blue collar wages down, either directly or indirectly by outsourcing, dismantling entitlement programs, slashing union rights and so on, with the help of politicians they bought. Of course, the money saved goes back into the pockets of the upper class, for example in the form of tax cuts, bonuses, or dividends, and at the same time they claim that these are hard times and everyone has to tighten their belts. It's not a tyranny of the meritocracy, it's a tyranny of the power elite.
- grandalf 15y agoYour argument is a nostalgic argument... one might as well argue that an honest and hard working blacksmith deserves to be able to earn a living wage to support a family... This ignores the changing economy -- these days people use bicycles, public transit, and cars for transport rather than horses. Other areas of the economy are changing too. Most technological innovations exist b/c they do something cheaper or faster than the human labor alternative. No matter how much a person may enjoy menial labor, someone else is working hard to make that work unnecessary. To fight against this trend is a doomed effort and frankly longs for the dark ages.
- skurry 15y agoBelieve it or not, there are still working blacksmiths and horse carriage drivers. But that's beside my point. My point was that the author of the article assumes that with enough work and educational opportunity, anyone can join the meritocracy. But I believe that getting a college degree requires a certain set of talents, which I believe a sizable chunk of the population simply does not possess (I admit that I may be wrong here, and that some people might see this as offensive elitism). It's unfair that those who don't win the talent lottery should be doomed to a life in poverty. Therefore, there should be a bottom in labor compensation, and that this bottom should guarantee a certain standard of living, and that this standard of living should depend on the wealth of a society as a whole. The US has a minimum wage, but that is way to low to guarantee any sort of comfort in many parts of the country.
- twoodfin 15y agoLong ago, I think I actually read the study on Sweden vs. U.S. mobility. Alas, only the first page is available now without the requisite JSTOR tolls: http://www.jstor.org/pss/2951338 http://www.jstor.org/pss/2951338 My recollection is that the authors looked at the predictive power of a father's earnings on his son's earnings, but rather than measure changes in absolute (or inflation-adjusted) earnings, they measured earnings relative to the society (Sweden or the U.S.) as a whole. In other words, if my father was in the 50th percentile for earnings, I could use their "mobility" estimate to determine my odds of making it to the 75th percentile (or down to the 25th percentile). That doesn't seem like a useful statistic on which to make qualitative comparisons when you're talking about societies with two very differently shaped income distributions (as the authors acknowledge is very much the case with Sweden and the U.S. on the freebie first page). Suppose the middle 60% of Swedish males earn between $25,000 and $35,000 annually. A jump from the 20th to the 80th percentile (or vice versa) in absolute terms isn't that impressive. If the income curve gets narrow enough, any impact your parents have will get lost in the noise and you'll have a "perfectly mobile" society in which everyone makes almost exactly the same amount of money. But how is that mobility? In contrast, if the earnings difference between the 20th percentile and the 80th percentile is, as in the U.S., a factor of four+, then moving from the 20th to the 80th percentile represents dramatically more "mobility" than in the Swedish case. AFAIR, the 1997 study would treat those movements equivalently.
- einhverfr 15y agoI think this is a bit of a misnomer. The problem is not meritocracy. The problem is concentration of control within a fake meritocracy. This is the same problem that doomed the Soviet Union, and it exists to a lesser, but still serious extent, here in the United States. As Hilaire Belloc wrote, control over the production of wealth is the control of life itself. When we give the rich control over the production of wealth because they are rich and can afford to fund capital, we disempower the majority. The answer is not socialism or communism, which try to solve the problems associated with such concentration through further concentrating that control. The answer is to back off and recognize that the division between capital and labor which has developed is an unhealthy one, that laborers should own their own means of production not collectively but individually and that the role for big capital should be as restrained as possible. As Chesterton said, "Too much capitalism does not mean too many capitalists, but too few." And as I say "In these economic woes, jobs are the problem, not the solution." One reason Open Source rocks is that it gives economic ownership to the means of production to every willing programmer and user. This is a value that cannot be measured economically. And open source works often according to a real meritocracy, where those who contribute the most and the best rise to the top, absent corporate control and marketing. So it is my hope that we recognize it is not meritocracy that is the problem but rather the level of concentration of resources and control that has been achieved that is the problem. These are good reasons to support small businesses, bank with credit unions, become self-employed, and encourage others to do the same.
- pmorici 15y ago"tell me why all those professors we paid millions of dollars to study economics couldn't provide a convincing rebuttal to that ideology in advance of the crash." Because many business and economics professors, esp. the prominent ones, make the majority of their income from consulting fees and by serving on boards of large corporations. For example Frederic Mishkin a professor at Columbia Business School and a former member of the Federal Reserve Board of Governors authored a paper titled "Financial Stability In Iceland" shortly before the countries economy imploded from a credit bubble. As it turns out he was paid $124,000 to write it by the Icelandic chamber of commerce. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frederic_Mishkin http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frederic_Mishkin This and many similar examples are detailed in the documentary "Inside Job", though, it isn't something you hear about in the news much if at all. In other words the study of business and economics has been corrupted by corporate money.
- jerf 15y agoI don't think you're actually disagreeing, because I think the entire point of the piece was to highlight the discrepancy between the putatively educated meritocracy and the fact that they have in fact not produced all that much merit. I think the "Meritocracy" in the title is intended to be subtly ironic. I think you're supposed to read this and then kvetch about how the meritocracy isn't. I could copy and paste this as a reply to a number of other people complaining about how misinformed this piece is, then going on to argue in the comment about how the meritocracy isn't. This piece is a fine bit of judo, getting a whole bunch of people who probably would otherwise be defending the dominant educational culture to condemn it, by its own standards.
- anamax 15y ago"But I think that rather misses the point: shouldn't the educational meritocracy, which really is very different from the combination of WASP elites and up-from-nowhere untutored operators, have done better?" It's unclear what definition of "meritocracy" Mz. McArdle is using. "Don't tell me that regulators were stupid or bankers got greedy until you first explain to me why tens of thousands of very well educated people, most of them graduates of colleges and professional schools that had aggressively winnowed them based on intelligence, barely outperformed a bunch of upstart micks, third-generation coupon-clipping WASP dimwits, and central bankers who still worshipped the barbarous relic of the gold standard?" As I suspected, she's confusing credentialed with educated and thinks that schools winnow only on intelligence.
- leoh 15y agoAnother very good essay, quite cognate. "Lost in the Meritocracy," http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2005/01/lost-in-the-meritocracy/3672/ http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2005/01/lost-in-..., by Walter Kirn a few years back.