6 ms·
Knock resistance isn't the only factor in leaded vs. unleaded. From Wikipedia, valve wear is also a factor (the lead deposits apparently act as a kind of lubric
by HPsquared 4y ago
Knock resistance isn't the only factor in leaded vs. unleaded. From Wikipedia, valve wear is also a factor (the lead deposits apparently act as a kind of lubricant):
"Meanwhile, Teledyne Continental Motors indicates (in document X30548R3 most recently revised in 2008) that leaded avgas is required in their engines: "Current aircraft engines feature valve gear components which are designed for compatibility with the leaded ASTM D910 fuels. In such fuels, the lead acts as a lubricant, coating the contact areas between the valve, guide, and seat. The use of unleaded auto fuels with engines designed for leaded fuels can result in excessive exhaust valve seat wear due to the lack of lead with cylinder performance deteriorating to unacceptable levels in under 10 hours."[8]"
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Avgas#Properties https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Avgas#Properties
- bdefore 4y agoPresumably 'valve gear components' could be designed to function without reliance on a toxic lubricant. Ultimately this comes down to being cheap.
- tonyarkles 4y agoAbsolutely for new equipment that would be the case. Safely retrofitting existing equipment is quite a bit more challenging, and my suspicion (without having actual numbers) is that the vast majority of the fleet that would require those retrofits is quite old. Some of the manufacturers don’t exist anymore, so having them sign off on “this retrofit kit will safely transport you in the air for thousands of hours” wouldn’t be possible. It’s not an unsolvable problem, but it’s thorny for sure both from a safety perspective and a cost perspective. You call it “being cheap” but my gut feeling is that retrofitting existing 40-year-old kit to handle unleaded Avgas safely would be capital-E Expensive.
- bdefore 4y agoGeneral aviation is expensive certainly and for a select few very wealthy individuals. I call it cheap because there is a way to solve it, but owners of small planes are choosing not to do so (and they're not compelled to do so despite the known externalities of their outdated machinery). Maintaining a beautiful car from the days of the Cold War is also not cheap, but it can be retrofitted to pass emissions tests. If you don't, you can't legally drive it. I don't see why the same doesn't apply to aircraft.
- missedthecue 4y agoI mean, there's being cheap and then there's getting a new aviation engine FAA certified. Those aren't exactly the same thing and Bob the dentist who likes to take his Cessna 172 up on weekends can't simply approve a new engine. This is why buying a new spec Cessna 172 from the factory floor today will still come with the good old Lycoming O-360 engine, introduced in 1955. Cessna sells ~250 172s per year, nowhere near enough to justify new engine approval.
- bdefore 4y agoI'm no expert, but I'll express a wish: that modern supply constraints mean Lycoming O-360 engines may be noncompetitive to an engine design conceived today. Perhaps these old engines are suppressing the investment into an invention that turns a 250 person market into a 25,000 one?
- tonyarkles 4y agoThe trick is that there’s two tiers of expensive for GA: - People buying, say, a new SR22 for $779,000 - People buying, say, a 1976 Cessna 172 for $72,000 and splitting it with 3 friends Having Cirrus work on, say, regular Mogas by contracting Continental to develop a new engine would be expensive but the buyers aren’t particularly price sensitive and amortized across the typical lifetime of an aviation engine design (the IO-550 in the SR22 was first delivered in 1983) likely wouldn’t hurt much. Trying to come up with an engine swap for the O-320 in that ‘76 172 is a whole other can of worms. Who’s going to even sign off on it? The whole aircraft is 50 years old and designed and certificated for that specific engine. There’s no financial incentive for Cessna to do it, and even if they did, the cost to do the swap would likely significantly exceed the financial capacity of many owners. I absolutely would love to see a financially viable way to get past this! The use of LL fuel in 2022 is tragic. On the other hand, killing off a big chunk of the GA industry and leaving it solely in the purview of the Wealthy and not just dedicated hobbyists… that sucks. For context, my family has an old Piper J3 sitting in a hangar on a farm. It definitely needs an overhaul, but to get it back in the air would likely be a low 5-figure bill; retrofitting a Mogas engine onto it in such a way that it doesn’t need to be categorized as “experimental” would be… prohibitive.
- yardie 4y agoThis seems like such a cop-out excuse. We'd rather harm potentially millions of people with toxic materials rather than inconvenience a few dozen aviation enthusiasts. Progress moves forward, if these old engines can't function in this new world they should be scrapped and replaced with something that can do the job. And BTW, general aviation has been asking for leaded avgas to be dropped for decades now. The holdup is not the pilots or plane owners but the goddamn FAA [0]. [0] https://www.avweb.com/insider/faa-continues-to-stall-on-g100ul/ https://www.avweb.com/insider/faa-continues-to-stall-on-g100...
- bdefore 4y agoDo you know of any research focused on lead-related health issues from areas of popular general aviation? Or around the supply chain for leaded fuel?
- yardie 4y agoThere are a few studies done. Here is one carried out by the NIH around NC. [0] In summary they are noticeably elevated but not as high as, an example, Flint Michigan. Lead blood levels do fall off precipitously after ~2km. [0] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3230438/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3230438/
- bdefore 4y agoThis is really good thank you. Worthy of a follow-up submission on HN of its own since we're pretty deep into comments here. Note that this study is specifically focused on North Carolina. I'm curious if similar research has been done in the Western US. California in particular is very popular for GA. Here's the top 10: https://generalaviationnews.com/2020/02/03/top-10-busiest-general-aviation-airports/ https://generalaviationnews.com/2020/02/03/top-10-busiest-ge... edit: Another link: Santa Clara, CA recently banned sale of leaded fuel https://grist.org/transportation/california-county-bans-toxic-aviation-fuel-at-its-airports/ https://grist.org/transportation/california-county-bans-toxi...
- belval 4y ago