7 ms·
They can fly an A380 on cooking oil, but can't phase out avgas? How does this make sense?
by kelseyfrog 4y ago
They can fly an A380 on cooking oil, but can't phase out avgas? How does this make sense?
- TheSpiceIsLife 4y agoVastly different fuels. Jet engines run on a Jet A1, kinda like diesel or kerosene, ignites under pressure with oxygen. Avgas is a high octane (100) petrol that requires a spark for ignition. Last time I was reading about unleaded avgas it seemed to be mostly a regulatory inertia problem, though I'm not well versed in aviation engine requirements.
- hef19898 4y agoIn the case of cooking oil, it is (I assume, didn't check) a trial and neither the engine nor the oil are certified for regular flight. Even if ao, it most likely would be the specific engine that would be recertified, not the cooking oil derived fuel. AvGas is different, there it is not individual engines that get re certified for using lead free fuel (faster for each engine but impossible due to the agevand obsolescense of these old engines), so the fuel has to certified for all engines at the same time.
- Merad 4y agoThe issues are totally unrelated. Jet turbines have always been capable of running on almost any fuel. I would hazard a guess that what Airbus did here was mostly certifying that the alternative fuel wouldn't cause any major problems, maybe also things like tweaking the engine management systems to ensure consistent power output and throttle responsiveness with the new fuel. The problem with avgas is that there are a huge number of aviation piston engines still in use that were built with 1930s-1960s era technology (in some cases the engines themselves are literally that old) that were designed to use leaded gasoline. Getting those engines to run on unleaded gas would at best require extensive modifications to the engine and at worst just isn't possible. In the cases where it's possible, someone has to foot the bill to figure out how to modify the engines and get the changes certified with the FAA, both incredibly expensive propositions. Once that's done all of the owners will have to drop the money to upgrade their engines. The death of avgas is inevitable but unfortunately it's probably going to take some sectors of general aviation with it. Those older planes are still flying in large part because newer planes have gotten so incredibly expensive. Also from what I've read the warbird community is working on the problem but many of them aren't very optimistic about being able to get those big WW2 era engines to run unleaded.
- jabl 4y agoThere is G100UL which seems to be promising as a 1:1 replacement for the current 100LL. Though regulatory inertia seems to be delaying a large scale rollout: https://www.avweb.com/insider/faa-continues-to-stall-on-g100ul/ https://www.avweb.com/insider/faa-continues-to-stall-on-g100... I'm not aware of any experiences of G100UL with warbird engines.
- krastanov 4y agoI am not a chemist so maybe I am naive here. My understanding is that lead additives were necessary to "fake" higher octane content (and the 0.1% lead additive is much cheaper than the 99% octane). Why can't we just go back to expensive high-octane fuels instead of adding lead (or just use the various alternative additives used in other high-performance engines)? Edit: an internet search tells me that avgas has an octane rating of 100... So why can't we just use actual pure octane in these engines?
- HPsquared 4y agoKnock resistance isn't the only factor in leaded vs. unleaded. From Wikipedia, valve wear is also a factor (the lead deposits apparently act as a kind of lubricant): "Meanwhile, Teledyne Continental Motors indicates (in document X30548R3 most recently revised in 2008) that leaded avgas is required in their engines: "Current aircraft engines feature valve gear components which are designed for compatibility with the leaded ASTM D910 fuels. In such fuels, the lead acts as a lubricant, coating the contact areas between the valve, guide, and seat. The use of unleaded auto fuels with engines designed for leaded fuels can result in excessive exhaust valve seat wear due to the lack of lead with cylinder performance deteriorating to unacceptable levels in under 10 hours."[8]" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Avgas#Properties https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Avgas#Properties
- bdefore 4y agoPresumably 'valve gear components' could be designed to function without reliance on a toxic lubricant. Ultimately this comes down to being cheap.
- kayodelycaon 4y agoGas turbines (which includes jet engines) can potentially use a lot of different fuel sources. For example, the M1 Abrams tank can run off a variety of different fuels. If it’s liquid and burns, it’ll probably work. Turbofan engines may need to be redesigned to accommodate a different fuel source, but there isn’t any reason you can’t use automotive gasoline to power a jet. It’s just not a good idea because it vaporizes more readily on the ground, has less power per volume, and freezes in the temperatures jet operate in. Piston engines aren’t as flexible. They don’t inject fuel in a constant stream, they compress and explode it.