4 ms·
Clayton Christensen had a much more interesting take on solar power at the Business of Software conference: it won't compete with fossil fuels in the US anytime
by patio11 15y ago
Clayton Christensen had a much more interesting take on solar power at the Business of Software conference: it won't compete with fossil fuels in the US anytime soon (except as a recipient of huge amounts of government largess), because for the most part our energy infrastructure works really, really well. It's ubiquitous, cheap, and mostly doesn't kill you. In much of the world, energy is 0 for 3! This makes e.g. small solar cells just good enough to run a cell phone charging station into revolutionary, disruptive devices in parts of Africa, because they're not competing against a well-developed multi-billion dollar infrastructure, they're competing against "no electricity at all." If they're expensive and fail to work in poor weather and available only spottily and... who cares, some electricity still beats no electricity.
His thesis was that if solar ever becomes a big thing in the US it will be because it grew like wildfire on the global periphery until the tech gets mature enough to start peeling off bits around the edges of US consumption (and then implied it might go further than that, using the same disruption mechanic).
- roc 15y agoI'm not sure how solar can become cheap/effective enough for the developing world without commodification due western subsidies and demand.
- tptacek 15y agoIt can't be cheap/effective enough to provide power at western service levels, but it can within developing world budgets be cheap/effective enough to provide useful levels of power. The key point here is just a restatement of Christiansen's "Innovator's Dillemma": a new product incapable of meeting the needs of most users of an incumbent product, but capable of meeting the needs of some other related market.
- roc 15y agoI suspect we're having a difference of definition. When Christiansen is paraphrased as saying solar won't become a big deal in the US, I took that to mean "not a big deal, in total", whereas everyone else seems to be reading it as "in comparison to fossil fuels".
- tptacek 15y agoThe "Innovator's Dilemma" describes the common scenario where the successor to an incumbent product is, when it's introduce, inferior to the incumbent on important axes; for instance, it could have inadequate storage, or be too slow, or not be secure. But the new product has attributes that make it way more attractive to some new market; for instance, maybe it's game-changingly cheap, or portable. As a result, the new product won't be adopted by the core market for the incumbent product. It's used by a different market, or at the margins. The "dilemma" here is, over the long term, the new product improves as it captures more and more market share. The new product has room to evolve and isn't locked into a core market with fixed expectations. Eventually, the benefits of the new product exceed those of the incumbent product, even for the incumbent's core market, and the incumbent product loses. This all plays out in slow motion, so that even if the incumbent sees this happening, they can't do much, because they're dependent on the revenue from their core market. Put fossil fuel in the "incumbent" box, "solar" in the "new product" box, "the industrialized west" in the "core market" box, and "the developing world" in "the new market" box.
- roc 15y agoI'm clear on all that. My point was simply this: PV is not efficient/cheap-enough to catch on in the developing world, yet. As the developing world cannot subsidize/commodify something it cannot afford, by definition, the only way PV becomes more efficient and more inexpensive, is by chasing western demand/subsidies. Which then means that for PV to ever be big in the developing world, there is a precondition of substantial generating and production capacity for PV in the developed world. Given that such installations must exist for PV to even make progress toward the developing-world-changing tipping-point, it seemed strange to me to say that Solar will never be "a big deal" in the developed world. One could likely do the math and determine approximately how much installed generating capacity and how much production capacity the industry would need to have created, to drive price-per-watt down to rates that are attractive to the developing world. And I'm thinking the numbers you'd come up with amount to "a big deal" by any reasonable objective measure. (Though I do concede that such a substantial number may still pale in comparison to fossil fuel usage in the developed world.)
- pkulak 15y agoI think that's over thinking it. If solar panels get cheap enough, companies will find a way to make it reliable. It's not terribly difficult (or expensive, comparatively) to store energy when size and weight are not a concern. You can use huge tanks of molten salt, for example. But in the short term, you could just hook a bunch of panels up alongside a normal natural gas plant. Just spin the gas up when it's cloudy or at night. The nice thing is that in a lot of places where it's hot and sunny often, electricity use tracks sunlight due to air conditioning. Natural gas already supplements coal plants all over the country. It would be no different.
- anamax 15y ago> It's not terribly difficult (or expensive, comparatively) to store energy when size and weight are not a concern. You can use huge tanks of molten salt, for example. Yet, PG&E pumps water uphill at night so it can get more hydro during the day. Maybe they made a big mistake, but I'd like to see some actual numbers. PG&E isn't perfect, but they're not obviously incompetent either, so .... To put it another way, if you're correct, you're ignoring gobs of money. > The nice thing is that in a lot of places where it's hot and sunny often, electricity use tracks sunlight due to air conditioning. Most places don't have air conditioning.
- bh42222 15y agoWhy would the US electricity infrastructure care if the electrons come from coal heat or sun light? And if renewable power becomes cheap enough you can synthesis gasoline from air. Renewable power does not have to become incredibly cheap for this work. If the price of oil rises high enough that alone could make synthesizing fuel using solar power profitable.... in theory.
- DennisP 15y agoThat's true as long as there's no price no carbon. It's hard to compete with someone who can externalize massive costs. (Coal emissions, btw, are estimated to kill at least 13,000 Americans per year, and many more Chinese.)