5 ms·
No, they spent several times $50.4M on TV ads to promote their brand to try to increase food sales. $50.4M of that happened to be on ads that featured a $100k d
by tzs 4y ago
No, they spent several times $50.4M on TV ads to promote their brand to try to increase food sales. $50.4M of that happened to be on ads that featured a $100k donation.
That part of the cost of their $50+M ad campaign was a $100k donation is no more interesting or relevant than how much they spent on animation to make their Noid ads or how much they spent to pay actors in their ads.
- enumjorge 4y agoThe point still stands that spending $50M of your ad budget to highlight a $100k donation is a bit ridiculous.
- eloff 4y agoNot really, because they would have spent the ad budget anyway, just without calling attention to the donation.
- arcticfox 4y agoI'm surprised people aren't getting this. The $100k is from their advertising budget (or could be). They chose the proportion 500:1. It's comical. If you want to be seen as a good actor, don't take your dollar and then split a penny in 5 pieces and give one to charity. They could have made 10x more of a donation and hardly touched the budget they had for their ads. Or 100x more and only slightly reduced the ads. All while increasing the advertising power of the donation they were showcasing in the ads themselves, so it's not like they'd simply be losing the money to charity.
- dwild 4y ago> They could have made 10x more of a donation and hardly touched the budget they had for their ads. Or 100x more and only slightly reduced the ads. All while increasing the advertising power of the donation they were showcasing in the ads themselves, so it's not like they'd simply be losing the money to charity. That $50m is the amount decided to reach their audience. Increasing the donation won't increase the reach... I remember recently a pizza chain in my province decided to stop all their ad campaign for a month and give the amount they would have spend otherwise to people. Hey if it works for Mr. Beast, it could work for them right? I saw it on Tiktok so a good platform to allow organic sharing, well a week later I started to see ads about it on Facebook... they didn't reach their audience. So yeah that spending is for their ads, they are going to spend it, it's there for a reason. Believe me, if they could lower it in some way, they would... that's called business. Is there really anyone in the world happy to pay ads and that doesn't do anything to try to lower that cost? At best they could avoid the bad press from r/antiwork (does it really matters? how many views did that get versus that $50m ads?), but I got a feeling that they would still complains about the fact that they spend more in ads than in the actual donation.
- eloff 4y agoYeah, I agree. What the parent said is akin to saying they could have donated an extra $10 million by taking it out of their R&D budget. If they thought they could cut an extra $10 million in costs somewhere, they would. That's business. Whether they would donate that or not is a separate matter.
- kube-system 4y agoIf 100 people in suits walk past a homeless man, and one of them hands the homeless man a $100 bill, do you berate him for only giving 500:1 his disposable income? What about the 99 who gave nothing?
- arcticfox 4y agoIf the person in a suit subsequently spends $49900 on positive news stories about the $100 giveaway... Yeah, I'd berate the person
- kleene_op 4y ago> (or could be) So which is it? Because this is what makes the difference. You seem to have opted for the first option in the rest of your post but never mention why.
- arcticfox 4y agoIt's because it was 100% their choice. It doesn't matter if they drew funds from the ad budget or the CEO's couch cushions, they could have spent the ad dollars on it even if they didn't. They spent $50.5M on an ad campaign about charity, of which $0.1M was the charity itself. It's embarrassing. 50/50 might be an appropriate ratio. Even 90/10 might be defensible. 99.8/0.2 is "are you joking" territory.
- tzs 4y agoThey are completely different categories of spending. The $100k is part of the costs to make the ad. Almost all of the rest of the $50.4M is the cost of run the ad. It's not sensible to compare them.
- elmomle 4y agoWhat you say is correct from al the perspective of advertising and corporate budgeting. From the perspective of charitable work, which they invited by loudly proclaiming "look at our charity", it is appalling.
- dusted 4y agoI agree, it'd be much better if they hadn't donated at all.
- bragr 4y agoIMHO most charity work is kind of scam anyways. Sure you've got some proportion really out there doing good and helping desperate people, but most of them seem like ego trips and tax scams for rich people. In most cases, at least in democratic nations, I think it would be in our interest to take all that money and give it local and national governments to fully fund education, social services, environment causes, animal control, healthcare, etc. By letting charities handle large chunks of those, we essentially allow rich people to dictate public policy.
- 3pt14159 4y agoThe problem is that corruption is widespread throughout most of the world, and especially places in poverty. A stable, just society is able to bootstrap into relative wealthy pretty quickly, so most of the countries that have the largest need of aid, also tend to have the greatest issues with government trustworthiness. As an aside, some charities are scams, but many are not. There are tools you can use to determine which ones are trustworthy, but some basic common sense goes a long way too.
- b112 4y agoSome say that giving money to marketing companies, and the people they employ, is a bit of charity, for what other function could those people possibly serve in society?
- kube-system 4y agoIronically enough, the most effective charities often have significant marketing budgets. You can't do any work if you don't have any money to do it with. Also, nobody is under any impression that Dominos is a charity and not a pizza joint.
- bachmeier 4y agoI can't tell if this comment is real or parody. If it's real, and you really don't understand the point, ask yourself why a $100k donation would be useful addition to a TV commercial.
- dwild 4y agoThe $50m is there whether the donation happens or not... it's their advertising budget, they are going to spend it, they advertise their brands... Why a $100k donation is useful? Well obviously because it's good that they gave $100k... You prefer $50m of ads with 0 donation? You do you, but I prefer the former...
- KronisLV 4y ago> You prefer $50m of ads with 0 donation? You do you, but I prefer the former... How about $49m in ads with $1m in donation? Perhaps $45m in ads with $5m in donation? Or maybe $40m in ads with $10m in donation? You might as well do $5m in ads with $45m in donations, build a community center (or a dozen) and name it after your brand or something. Obviously there are reasons for them choosing the split that they did, but we don't need to pretend that $100k is some upper end that cannot be surpassed.
- lotsofpulp 4y ago> Obviously there are reasons for them choosing the split that they did, but we don't need to pretend that $100k is some upper end that cannot be surpassed But it was their right to choose for to split it. The conversation is about not castigating someone for charity, no matter how small. The flip side is also not touting it. Ironically, maybe Dominos would have been better off keeping their heads down and spending $0 on charity.
- dwild 4y agoThat's the thing you fail to understands, your math is wrong. Here's the correction > How about $50m in ads with $1m in donation? > Perhaps $50m in ads with $5m in donation? > Or maybe $50m in ads with $10m in donation? The $50m is how many they are going to spend in ads, it's fixed. They want to reach theses eye balls, and increasing the amount donated won't increase the amount of eye balls. They are going to spend $50m in ads. They want theses minutes of airtime... donating more won't pay for more airtime (unless it become news worthy but that's a whole other level).