3 ms·
My car was broken into with this technique :-(. You can buy (on the usual dodgy places) a briefcase with a multi-car unlocker which will unlock lots of differe
by londons_explore 4y ago
My car was broken into with this technique :-(.
You can buy (on the usual dodgy places) a briefcase with a multi-car unlocker which will unlock lots of different cars if turned on in a car park, allowing you to then empty out the contents of any car that does then unlock.
And since there is no smashed window, insurance won't pay out either.
- Axien 4y agoThe technique described is a replay vulnerability. The attacker must record you unlocking your vehicle. What you describe sounds different, but even more scary.
- eugenekolo 4y agoIsn't it potentially a replay attack the poster is describing? In a simple form it seems like this: The attack is you have a briefcase that contains specific RF transceiving components in it. You turn the brief case on in a hidden place, leave it, it records data, you come back to it later, and then press a button(s) that replays those RF signals. Perhaps, there's some very weak cars that don't even need a replay, but are vulnerable to a master key, or bruteforce, or something else.
- snarfy 4y agoWhat? Fuck insurance. I would smash my own window then.
- tasty_freeze 4y ago25 years ago, a (then) friend had a nice car, bought it new. IIRC it was a BMW. He was hypervigilent about its condition. One night some thieves broke into his car and did some damage. Replacing the window wasn't a worry -- that can be replaced good as new, but they had put some dings in the hood somehow. He was worried that insurance wouldn't replace the hood but would just pay someone to try to knock them back into shape, which was unacceptable to him. So he went and bashed up the hood himself with a bat. The insurance claims guy came out to inspect it and said: we'll replace the window and we'll have a shop hammer out out the damage in the hood. Served him right.
- jeroenhd 4y agoReplay attacks like these won't work for what happened to you, most likely the manufacturer of your car opted for an insecure unlocking protocol (i.e. a static key programmed into the remote) that's easily brute forceable. These were common for ages, and I don't understand why (especially technical) people trusted wireless unlocking technology. Modern systems have some form of protection against brute force and replay attacks but personally I don't trust them.
- wongarsu 4y agoIt's not like keys for pin tumbler locks are very secure either. I think the main drawback of wireless unlocking is that hacking it is less conspicuous. If you have a device that can unlock a car in 10 times the time it takes with the legitimate key that looks suspicious if you spend that time holding an object to a keyhole, it's completely unnoticeable if you stand a couple meters away on a parking lot doing it wirelessly. Even worse with a method that works on 10% of cars: with a physical keyhole you go from car to car, looking very suspicious, with a wireless device you just stand there and go to the first car that unlocks.
- jeroenhd 4y agoPicking a car lock without setting off a loud alarm is a huge hassle and with the right setup it'll probably leave marks of entry at least. I've seen enough LPL videos that I trust physical car locks as much as I do house locks. I agree with the inconspicuousness of wireless hacking, but I wouldn't even call it the main drawback: the main drawback is that many insurance companies won't pay a dime if there are no signs of entry at all. Break a window, steal an entertainment system, and the original owner probably gets some money for window repair and a new part. Do the same thing digitally and the insurance company will probably tell you to pound sand.
- wallaBBB 4y agoThat would be hard-coded on the vehicle side, but this looks more like a simply signal jammer that is described in this attack. They simple jam the RKE Lock command when you're leaving your car, you don't pay attention to the light signalization for the successful Lock and move on. They come and still anything valuable from the inside.
- 99_00 4y agoHow do you know that you didn't just leave the door unlocked?
- giobox 4y agoWhile it won't be true for all and can often be configured, many keyless entry systems nowadays lock the doors once key leaves vicinity of the car whether you remember to lock the doors or not.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Johnny555 4y agoAnd since there is no smashed window, insurance won't pay out either. If you have comprehensive insurance (which is what would cover a stolen car), they'll pay whether or not it was broken into, you left the keys in it, or even if you left the engine running while unattended. https://www.progressive.com/answers/car-theft-with-keys-in-car/ https://www.progressive.com/answers/car-theft-with-keys-in-c... As long as you have comprehensive coverage, you can file a claim if your car is stolen while left running. Comprehensive can still pay to replace your vehicle if it's stolen while your keys are inside it or if you left it running. Car insurance won't pay for any personal effects stolen from the car, that would be covered by homeowners insurance, but as long as you have a police report, they'll cover it. I had a bicycle stolen from my (unlocked) car while parked in a garage -- homeowners insurance just asked for the police report, then sent me a check for the bike. They d