6 ms·
Commander Keen in Keen Dreams
- viksit 4y agoAliens ate my babysitter.
- bee_rider 4y agoThe graphical improvements from Invasion of the Vorticons to Goodby Galaxy (and apparently Keen Dreams, although I didn't play this one) were really remarkable. Wonder if there are any fun numbers hidden in this source code. Although, I guess that would mostly be for 3d...
- hackcasual 4y agoJust got a Retroid Pocket 2+. There's good support for Dosbox with the RetroArch dosbox-pure core, and having a trip down memory lane playing the commander keen games
- chrismorgan 4y agoBack in 2014 when the source code was released: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8326883 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8326883
- elktea 4y agoThere are a few forks with lots of activity since the original release, this one in particular seems quite active https://github.com/ReflectionHLE/ReflectionHLE/releases https://github.com/ReflectionHLE/ReflectionHLE/releases
- Linda703 4y ago[dead]
- dehrmann 4y agoI wonder if there's enough interest in the franchise to reboot it or see it in a new medium in a way that isn't just a cash grab. My worry there's only a 5-year window of PC gamers who would care, but I'd still love to see it.
- smcl 4y agoThey made an attempt, but it was apparently a "free-to-play" pvp card game which caused a bit of a stir and got cancelled prior to release: https://www.gamereactor.eu/commander-keen-reboot-seems-to-have-been-cancelled/ https://www.gamereactor.eu/commander-keen-reboot-seems-to-ha...
- albertzeyer 4y agoWhile I loved the original games, I did not like this new comic style at all - it is a very different type of humor. Also, the impressions of the new game by these trailers were very unsatisfying and not really like a game I would enjoy playing and not at all like the original games. So I wondered, how should a modern reboot of the game actually look like? The graphic style is sth very subjective. I think just keeping the old pixel graphics would not be appropriate. But then what style? Should it be some comic style? Or more realistic? Or maybe sth in between, like GTA? Maybe like Halo? There is a similar discussion around Monkey Island now. I assume it should be a proper 3D game. What type of game? I think this should follow the old style. Ie. some small puzzle elements (but not too hard), some maze-style levels, levels where you do not just go from left-to-right but in any directions, where you collect key cards or whatever, activate some mechanisms etc. Maybe it's a bit like Tomb Raider. The main character should be the same. The setting should be similar, the same, or maybe extended, of course different worlds. I think there should be more and new and different opponents, aliens, etc. I think the kind of humor should be similar. But this is maybe hard to get right because I'm not sure how it fits together with modern graphics. Should it be violent? Should there be blood? Maybe that fits the humor. I don't know.
- smcl 4y agoYeah I think you're right that they maybe missed the mark with this. I know I'm certainly not the target market (my only experience of Keen was killing him in Doom II) but it looked a bit odd to me. Resurrecting a franchise has to be done with a great deal of care - there has been success with id software games before (Doom and Wolfenstein are good examples) but I guess you're walking a pretty fine line when you try it and there will always be a vocal (minority?) crowd telling you that you're fucking it up. I don't know if the Keen games was popular or interesting enough to warrant a reboot, but I certainly wouldn't envy the team tasked with the purpose of developing it for exactly the reasons you stated.
- teekert 4y agoWhat is cool is that the "Standard Galactic Alphabet" ("Too bad you can't read the standard galactic alphabet, human!" [0]) is also used in other games, like MineCraft [1]. I could actually read it later on, because in Keen 3 I believe I found the translation on some pyramid level (iirc). [0]: https://64.media.tumblr.com/20adefd053fe320e3aabc7f7b1deb39c/14a4171232fcc2c0-09/s540x810/06a75e60647dea8f3036a28cafa909364d5ffdad.pnj https://64.media.tumblr.com/20adefd053fe320e3aabc7f7b1deb39c... [1]: https://vivu.tv/what-is-the-galactic-alphabet-in-minecraft/ https://vivu.tv/what-is-the-galactic-alphabet-in-minecraft/
- DrSiemer 4y agoAt the time I had already translated it thanks to the "EXIT" signs in Keen 1 or 2. It was such a cool optional in-game side puzzle.
- teekert 4y agoDon't forget the letters U and D (for Up and Down) at the series of switches that would open doors.
- adamrezich 4y ago[1] claims that Quake 4 uses the same alphabet for the Strogg, is that really true?
- jerf 4y ago[1] appears to be one of the web sites generated by either GPT-3 or something like it. Don't trust anything it says. Doing a web search specifically for "standard galactic alphabet quake 4" doesn't appear to produce any interesting results, so I think it's false. Get a good read on [1]. Learning how to identify those web sites is rapidly becoming an important skill. Today you're just learning something a bit wrong about Quake 4 because the transformer model thought that sounded plausible, tomorrow it could be something much more dangerously wrong.
- 4y ago
- makapuf 4y agoThe readme says it should be compiled with borland c++. Do you know why wasn't turbo c/c++ used for these ?
- lionkor 4y agoOr why not any compiler from the last 15 years
- FartyMcFarter 4y agoIf it ain't broken, don't fix it. What's the point of updating an old game's source tree to compile with the latest and greatest compilers? Even if one wanted to do that, it would probably be best done as a fork.
- unixhero 4y agoWell because GCC
- mysterydip 4y agoSometimes the code was written specifically for nuances of a given compiler, and compiling the same code on a different one would produce side effects.
- bluedino 4y agoFor one, the inline assembly syntax wasn't exactly the same. When I was a kid I had a DOS game programming book, the worst thing about it was that it came with the Microsoft C compiler. EVERYONE used Borland back then. So most of the sample code and shit you would find on the AOL forums or BBS's wouldn't work. Sure, if you knew assembly and your compiler it was probably trivial to get it working. Same goes for functions to call interrupts and things like that.
- petercooper 4y agoIf you had two compilers for the same language from different companies back in the 80s or 90s, the chances of them both successfully compiling the same codebase without any changes was slim to none. A bit like sharing SQL between Postgres, SQLite, SQL Server and Oracle nowadays.
- emmanueloga_ 4y agoI did not know the sources of keen game/(s?) were available. I remember reading in "Masters of Doom" about the scrolling technique [0], and how ID tried to use it to create a port of Mario for the PC. Now I can read the code, too :-). [1] 0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adaptive_tile_refresh https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adaptive_tile_refresh 1: https://github.com/keendreams/keen/blob/4348b4719be87a0b873f5f4f77b4de82ddf7050c/id_rf.c#L1057-L1069 https://github.com/keendreams/keen/blob/4348b4719be87a0b873f...
- tombert 4y agoIt always surprised me that Keen never really had a console presence, outside of the Gameboy Color (and ports of the original DOS games). According to Masters of Doom, the games were quite popular, and I'm surprised that there wasn't any interested in making a SNES version or something.
- zelphirkalt 4y agoI used to play "Goodbye Galaxy" and "Invasion of the Vorticons" as a kid. I knew almost every secret way in "Goodbye Galaxy" back then and still remember many levels and secrets. I remember there was a secret way, where you could get 2 "1UP"s, but in the process you die, because you cannot get out of the secret location. Played many hours of that level to get a highscore "record" and thought of myself as so clever ... Oh and who knows about the trick to get 1 extra "gun" at the beginning of "Goodbye Galaxy", entering the spaceship map? ;) "Invasion of the Vorticons" was a quite difficult game as a child, because the controls were not as responsive as with "Goodbye Galaxy", but I actually liked some of the monsters more and the energy blast of the weapon more than in "Goodbye Galaxy". Overall however, "Goodbye Galaxy" was the clear winner between the two though. I played "Keen Dreams" years later, but I really disliked the stone throwing in an arc and enemies waking up after some time again. Level design also felt better in "Goodbye Galaxy". I never finished "Keen Dreams", but I often finished "Goodbye Galaxy". At the time I knew no English (pre-primary school and early primary school time), so the texts made little sense to me, and I interpreted them in my own ways, trying to find words that look similar in my language.
- M4tze 4y ago"Goodbye Galaxy" was perfect. I still remember the place where Commander Keen showed his butt.
- aliqot 4y agoi knew none of these :( never made it past the ice level or the big pyramid shaped one.
- wedn3sday 4y agoI also played the heck out of Goodbye Galaxy as a kid (as well as all the other commander keen games), and much to my chagrin was never able to figure out the secret of the pyramid levels. Such a fantastically designed game at every level, from the writing to the graphics to the game mechanics. I'll always have fond memories of sneaking into my dads study with my brothers at night when we weren't supposed to be playing on the computer and exploring the world of Commander Keen.
- boringg 4y agoGlory days of computer games - simple, funny and not serious. Such a goofy fun time those keen games.
- KptMarchewa 4y agoProgrammers back then really loved their fancy visual separators. Nowadays I would be really surprised if I saw something like that, yet it's extremely common in code from back in the day.
- pluijzer 4y agoI still use it for projects where I am the main author. I also prefer a handful of files containing visual separators to tens of thousands little files containing a few lines of class definitions. Guess the preference depends a lot on which editor or IDE you use.
- vkaku 4y agoOh. I love that you can build this stuff in BORLANDC even today. :)