3 ms·
Their new design was just yet another example of how the currently in vogue "minimalism everywhere" design aesthetic sucks. The Tropicana case study is such a g
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
Their new design was just yet another example of how the currently in vogue "minimalism everywhere" design aesthetic sucks. The Tropicana case study is such a great example because the effects were so drastic, but only really because there were easily substituted goods - consumers basically thought the carton was just "generic store brand OJ".
My guess is that other recent brand redesigns to this boring, same, sans-serif minimalist aesthetic (recent HN article, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32040506 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32040506) are just as bad, but with "stickier" products (people aren't likely to leave Google or Facebook just because the typography is shittier) the downside is less noticeable.
- ad404b8a372f2b9 4y agoOn that subject, https://www.underconsideration.com/brandnew/ https://www.underconsideration.com/brandnew/ tracks the desecration of all these once colorful, beautiful, expressive logos into this new bland style that's in vogue.
- mrcartmeneses 4y agoSaying that this guy's designs were terrible therefore all modern design is terrible is like saying all children's TV presenters are pedophiles (apologies I know that's an extreme analogy). The truth is that the guy behind this design agency is not a good designer at all and his career seems to have been driven by confidence, greed and the incompetence of his clients. It's a sample of one. He's the Jimmy Saville of bad design
- thisOtterBeGood 4y agoThinking the same. They've made some fatal mistakes there. Heck of a lesson for the agency there :D
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoWhich is why I linked the related recent HN post about tons of different brands, across tech and fashion, that wiped out any trace of their individuality for bold, sans-serif logos. I agree, I think this designer is just a particularly shitty designer, but he's a shitty designer that's just copying the broader trend of minimalist design laziness. I think the last section in that linked HN article (https://velvetshark.com/articles/why-do-brands-change-their-logos-and-look-like-everyone-else https://velvetshark.com/articles/why-do-brands-change-their-...) perfectly points out what went wrong in the Tropicana redesign as well: > There’s nothing bad in wanting your logo to look simpler, better, mobile-ready, or universal enough to appeal to the broadest possible audience. > But don't throw the baby out with the bathwater. > Shoot for simplicity and legibility, but keep your distinguishing features. Don’t throw away what the brand has been working on for decades. > Otherwise, you may end up in a situation where you could slap any logo on any product and hardly anyone would notice a difference:
- noir_lord 4y agoYears and years ago we used to have a supermarket here called Kwik-Save (here been the UK) and they had a range called No-Frills. Their packaging was absolutely genius because it instantly stood out on every shelf. https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Da0flNiWkAAUda7.jpg https://pbs.twimg.com/media/Da0flNiWkAAUda7.jpg Other than the font it seems like everyone wants to got that way, of course if you move with the crowd you can't stand out from it.