2 ms·
Nuclear kills 10% as many people per watt hour as solar, and << 1% as many as fossil fuels. Also, in places with reasonable regulatory regimes, it is inexpens
by hedora 4y ago
Nuclear kills 10% as many people per watt hour as solar, and << 1% as many as fossil fuels. Also, in places with reasonable regulatory regimes, it is inexpensive.
Provisioning enough nuclear to meet peak demand is certainly feasible, assuming you measure in dollars, environmental impact or human deaths.
Of course, building a mix of renewables and nuclear would be even better, but let's not pretend clean, essentially limitless power production hasn't been a solved technical problem for 50+ years.
- cycomanic 4y agoThe 10% people statistic is highly misleading because it includes people dying when putting solar panels on the roof. I mean then we should also include people dying in car accidents with nuclear power plant workers when they drive to work.
- notahacker 4y agoIts also highly misleading because the number of people dying putting solar panels on the roof was totally made up; Brian Wang simply made it up by apportioning an arbitrarily large proportion of roofing deaths to rooftop solar, even reasoned through to the bizarre conclusion that if every US roof had panels installed, annual roofing deaths would increase ninefold! Also, he refuses to accept that more than 50 people died as a result of Chernobyl...
- Retric 4y agoYou are quoting inflated rooftop solar numbers that are both wrong and irrelevant as utility companies install solar on the ground. Nuclear actually kills more peolle as it’s a more dangerous construction job and on top of that has the occasional accident. https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/death-rates-from-energy-production-per-twh https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/death-rates-from-energy-p...
- hedora 4y agoOK, but even that graph says we could have 100x more nuclear deaths and be at parity with natural gas plants We'd need 1000x more nuclear deaths per watt hour to match coal. That's multiple Chernobyl's per year. We'd be better off "decommissioning" old plants by yanking out the control rods than we are building more coal plants.
- Retric 4y agoBelieve me I want those numbers to drop, that said we aren’t building more coal plants. The most recent coal power plant was 0.017GW in Alaska which happened to be near a coal mine and the location was a poor fit for nuclear, solar, wind, or gas. That might be concerning except the state is already down at 10% coal generation. Every other coal project has been canceled, with none being constructed or even planned at this point. Coal’s share of production fell from 51% in 2001 to 20% and it just keeps dropping. In absolute numbers it’s a more modest 40% drop, but still falling. Nuclear is unfortunately a poor replacement for peaking power plants like natural gas. The technology isn’t at issue just the costs relative to solar/wind backed battery systems.