4 ms·
That's good news, but no matter how cheap it is, solar only works when the sun shines. The real impediment to a solar/wind economy is energy storage, which is s
by DennisP 15y ago
That's good news, but no matter how cheap it is, solar only works when the sun shines. The real impediment to a solar/wind economy is energy storage, which is still very expensive and hard to scale.
A good post that runs the numbers and conveys the scale of the problem is here:
http://physics.ucsd.edu/do-the-math/2011/08/nation-sized-battery/ http://physics.ucsd.edu/do-the-math/2011/08/nation-sized-bat...
And another that takes a close look at wind is here:
http://bravenewclimate.com/2011/10/29/gws-sg-es/ http://bravenewclimate.com/2011/10/29/gws-sg-es/
We can definitely use solar for about 20% of our energy, with fossil or nuclear plants backing it up. But until we fix the storage problem, the only route to a post-carbon economy is nuclear.
- divtxt 15y agoExisting storage technologies are insufficient to replace fossil fuels by multiple orders of magnitude. Here's a nice summary: http://www.theoildrum.com/node/8405 http://www.theoildrum.com/node/8405 The bottom line: storage will need some serious R&D to find a secret sauce using fuel cells or nanotech or something.
- barranger 15y agoexcuse my ignorance with these questions, but this is something I've been wondering every time I see an article like this (specifically the batteries needed for solar). 1) shouldn't we be concentrating our efforts on reducing the requirements from the grid to near zero for new housing builds? Newer builds will (hopefully) also incorporate the latest in conservation technologies (better performing insulation, etc) resulting in a lower energy requirement regardless of the source. One would also imagine that new home builders implementing solar solutions would see cost benefits from scale. 2) wouldn't the efforts of concentrating on new home builds have a two pronged benefit on everyone else? Not only would technology advances become available for retrofit projects, but the reduced strain on the grid could potentially reduce the costs grid wide? 3) what would be the benefit of having a centralized solar installation? Any solution that centers around having a mile square cube (from the linked article) seems a bit silly to me, wouldn't houses having their own battery solution make much more sense? Having individual batteries would allow for a market for these solutions and, one would hope, from the competition within this market, new and better solutions would emerge.
- DennisP 15y agoPretty sure he's not advocating actually making a mile square cube of battery. He's just illustrating the scale of the problem. It's the same amount of battery no matter how you divide it up. Efficiency is definitely some low-hanging fruit. It only gets us so far, though. Rooftops are probably the most effective place to deploy solar, but housing is only one piece of the puzzle.
- onemoreact 15y agoThat post was written by someone with a vary superficial understanding of these issues. For example Hydro power already provides a lot of 'grid storage' and is totally missing from his analysis. Also, photovoltaics are far less impacted by clouds than you might assume with partially cloudy days offering similar power levels to sunny days. And even on days where it rains constantly you get some power and often see an increase in wind power output. Smart grids enable many applications like large scale cooling to shift of demand without building new storage infrastructure on the supply side. Not to mention simply shifting maintenance cycles can shift a lot of 'supply' to different parts of the year without building any infrastructure at all. Add it all up and Wind + Solar meet total energy demands and have near ideal capacity factors with ~2-4 new hours of total grid energy storage. VS. the 6 days which he assumes. PS: http://arstechnica.com/science/news/2010/04/it-looks-like-time-to-build-an-atlantic-seaboard-wind-grid.ars http://arstechnica.com/science/news/2010/04/it-looks-like-ti...
- DennisP 15y agoThere's a limit to how far you can expand hydro. There aren't that many more places to build dams. You can expand a little more by putting reservoirs at higher elevations specifically for storage, but that's expensive. Even at 4 hours of storage, the scale we need is a bit mind-boggling. Your link is really interesting though. That's the kind of analysis we need. I see too many articles that just talk about rated capacity with no consideration of actual output or reliability. My second link does similar analysis for Australia, and there it doesn't work out so well. The wind drops low over wide areas for days at a time. In any case I have nothing against renewables, as long as they don't use up too much land...offshore wind is perfect. But I think we should be building GenIII and better nuclear reactors, too.
- onemoreact 15y agoHydro is already used for peaking power, at most we would retrofit things it increase peak power output where it's reasonable to do so. Building 4 hours of storage is a rather extreme step that's also extremely unlikely. California already has a 40c/kwh cost differential between peak summer demand and the middle of winter, but nobody is building massive grid energy storage to smooth that out. Even over the course of a single day you could make 10c/kwh just from grid storage but nobody is building it. Rather we add peaking power plants because base load power + storage costs more than peaking power plants and that's likely to continue to be the case even in a world dominated by solar + wind power plants.
- 00joe 15y ago20%? Over 60% of our electricity is consumed when the sun shines. Currently we get less then 1% of our power from solar. Storage will not matter for a very long time.
- grayrest 15y agoJust heard about this the other week, but if the SMU study [1] from a week or so ago is true, I don't see why geothermal couldn't provide the base load. I've seen related articles claim that no new tech is required and there's an enhanced geothermal facility that just opened in Australia. Strikes me as...simple. [1] http://blog.smu.edu/research/2011/10/25/vast-coast-to-coast-clean-energy-source-confirmed-by-first-google-org-funded-geothermal-mapping-report/ http://blog.smu.edu/research/2011/10/25/vast-coast-to-coast-...
- ww520 15y agoI remember seeing some research into using nanotech to create multi-surface structures that can capture lots of hydrogen. Hopefully we'll get some break through in that area.