2 ms·
Underrated comment. This is like a "correlation is not causation" side of "this ML worked so this must be how a brain works" needs to be hit on the head, time a
by ggm 4y ago
Underrated comment. This is like a "correlation is not causation" side of "this ML worked so this must be how a brain works" needs to be hit on the head, time and time again.
Maybe we can teach an ML to whack-a-mole until we see ideas pop out which the ML doesn't think are repetitive correlation/causation/model-is-working effects
- mjburgess 4y agoEven more severely, I think this is pseudoscience -- though a genuinely borderline case "with real value". All theyre doing is feeding in pixel patterns and object information for specific scenes, and then calling the models ability to detect general correlations in those scenes "solidity", "inertia", and the like. Any time where patterns in correlations are taken as an explantory model, we have pseudoscience. Yes, inertia/solidity/etc. is the right answer for why physical objects show those visual correlations. But pixel patterns in some images are NOT models of inertia, solidity, etc. Just as correlations in pixel patterns in the sky is not a model of gravity. The right model, eg., is F=GMm/r^2 which are variables not even present in the data. So no correlative model of a night sky will ever be a model of gravity.