3 ms·
Nuclear has generally done a terrible job of offsetting fossil fuels, because it doesn't scale to 100% carbon free grid. It can reasonably offset coal, but nee
by Retric 4y ago
Nuclear has generally done a terrible job of offsetting fossil fuels, because it doesn't scale to 100% carbon free grid.
It can reasonably offset coal, but needs peaking powerplants to meet customers variable demand. Which means it comes into conflict with much cheaper but less reliable wind and solar.
Solving that isn’t simple a question of solving say construction costs. We need to downsize from a 1,000 person workforce at a large scale power plant, and dramatically reduce insurance costs, and dramatically reduce construction costs, and dramatically reduce refueling costs, and dramatically reduce maintenance costs, and dramatically reduce decomisiniong costs. The less any one of those gets cut the more the others must be.
Consider, scheduled maintenance on a nuclear power plant is several weeks at a time. That’s ok if seasonal demand drops significantly and you have other sources to pick-up the slack but the higher your nuclear percentage the larger problem this becomes. It's issues like that which is why most countries have sub 40% nuclear generation and have been like that for decades.
- PaulHoule 4y agoNuclear already offsets more fossil fuels than wind and solar. That could change, but for now it will take at least several years to add enough renewable capacity to offset Diablo Canyon after it closes in California.
- Retric 4y agoWhat’s happening today isn’t enough. Globally Hydropower is still suppling 50% more electricity than Nulcear. ~90% of new generation in the US is carbon free, that’s changing the landscape not simply having the same 3X% of electricity come from nuclear for 40+ years. Quite simply nuclear stagnated in 2000 the world produced 2,590 TWh of nuclear, 31.3 of wind, 0.8 from Grid PV. By 2019 that jumped to 2,789 nuclear, 1,427 wind, and 681 Grid PV. In 2020, renuables where 29% of all commercial electricity generation while nuclear was 10%. PS: Diablo Canyon produced ~12.6 TWh per year at the rate things are going with wind and solar that’s going to be replaced in about 40 days.
- PaulHoule 4y agoSee https://ourworldindata.org/electricity-mix https://ourworldindata.org/electricity-mix which tells a different story.
- Retric 4y agoNo, it's got the same 10% nuclear 15% hydropower for grid power number I just quoted. It even shows 2021 numbers as 2,735 nuclear, 1,813 Wind, and 1,023 solar. So counter to your previous point Wind + Solar > Nuclear. With Hydro at 4,206; Wind + hydro + solar > 2.5 times nuclear. We are at the point where 1 year of solar PV growth (2020 to 2021 = 189 TWh) is more than the last 20 years of nuclear growth (2001 to 2021 = 163 TWh) and solar keeps accelerating.
- PaulHoule 4y agoWhere are these PV facilities being installed? About 10 years ago I saw a few major installation put in in my area (upstate NY) and also I could see solar roof installers all over the place. I don't see anywhere near the activity I saw back then, which I'd expect to see if there was a huge solar boom and it was evenly distributed.
- Retric 4y agoIt’s not evenly distributed because that’s wasteful. Globally: https://solarpower.guide/solar-energy-insights/largest-solar-plants https://solarpower.guide/solar-energy-insights/largest-solar... In the US it’s largely California, Arizona, Texas, and Nevada. https://list.solar/plants/largest-plants/solar-plants-usa/ https://list.solar/plants/largest-plants/solar-plants-usa/ There is a plan to put a 13,000 acre solar farm in Indiana, but generally northern areas get what look like large solar farms but are far smaller scale. Even 50 acres looks massive from up close and can significantly offset local consumption but doesn’t represent a big project.
- hedora 4y agoNuclear kills 10% as many people per watt hour as solar, and << 1% as many as fossil fuels. Also, in places with reasonable regulatory regimes, it is inexpensive. Provisioning enough nuclear to meet peak demand is certainly feasible, assuming you measure in dollars, environmental impact or human deaths. Of course, building a mix of renewables and nuclear would be even better, but let's not pretend clean, essentially limitless power production hasn't been a solved technical problem for 50+ years.
- cycomanic 4y agoThe 10% people statistic is highly misleading because it includes people dying when putting solar panels on the roof. I mean then we should also include people dying in car accidents with nuclear power plant workers when they drive to work.
- notahacker 4y agoIts also highly misleading because the number of people dying putting solar panels on the roof was totally made up; Brian Wang simply made it up by apportioning an arbitrarily large proportion of roofing deaths to rooftop solar, even reasoned through to the bizarre conclusion that if every US roof had panels installed, annual roofing deaths would increase ninefold! Also, he refuses to accept that more than 50 people died as a result of Chernobyl...
- Retric 4y agoYou are quoting inflated rooftop solar numbers that are both wrong and irrelevant as utility companies install solar on the ground. Nuclear actually kills more peolle as it’s a more dangerous construction job and on top of that has the occasional accident. https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/death-rates-from-energy-production-per-twh https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/death-rates-from-energy-p...
- hedora 4y agoOK, but even that graph says we could have 100x more nuclear deaths and be at parity with natural gas plants We'd need 1000x more nuclear deaths per watt hour to match coal. That's multiple Chernobyl's per year. We'd be better off "decommissioning" old plants by yanking out the control rods than we are building more coal plants.
- SECProto 4y ago> Nuclear has generally done a terrible job of offsetting fossil fuels, because it doesn't scale to 100% carbon free grid. The way you've phrased this, it sounds like there is some other zero-carbon energy source that is better at offsetting fossil fuels. Take a look at France's electric grid, and the province of Ontario. They're both majority nuclear (75% and 65% respectively), they're both >90% carbon-free (with much of the remainder, indeed, being gas). Now show me a different grid that has a lower proportion of gas (regardless of whether or not it has any nuclear). Or a different grid that has lower CO2 per MWh. (there aren't any)
- cycomanic 4y agoFrance in the last year had its nuclear reactors only work at 60% due to outages and maintance, they were using the rest of the European grid to compensate.
- SECProto 4y agoAnd in a typical year, France generates 72% from nuclear and exports lots of power to the rest of the European grid. There are serious issues to resolve, but that's why you interconnect grids. The real issue with Frances nuclear reactors: they are all over 20 years old, and 51/58 of them are over 30 years old. If they don't get on building replacements asap, they won't have any functional reactors.
- natmaka 4y agoIn 2004 France started a project aiming at building an industrial seed for its new reactor ("EPR"). Construction started in 2007, for a delivery scheduled in 2012. Its total cost is already nearly 6 times its budget, and will not be delivered before 2023. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EPR_(nuclear_reactor)#Flamanville_3_(France) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EPR_(nuclear_reactor)#Flamanvi...
- SECProto 4y agoNot really 6 times - 3.3 to 12.6 billion is about 4 times. Regardless, Finland started a similar project with the same design around the same time, and they're operational. China, too, started building reactors of the same design around the same time, and they're operational. The UK started a project with the same reactor design, and they're billions over budget and half a decade late (with still years left for those to continue to cascade). While all had delays and overruns, the cause is likely inaccurate estimating at the outset. The same article describes the EPR2 design, which is being done exactly to solve these issues. Regardless, the big problem here isn't specific to the nuclear plant design, but rather public project management (a field I have pretty deep insight into). The same can be seen in most multi-billion dollar projects with high political input and public visibility, whether it be a highway or a bridge or a transit line or an airport.