6 ms·
A good start. It's obvious, for example, that if you call 911 because someone's having a heart attack, that they should dispatch paramedics, not police officers
by kibwen 4y ago
A good start. It's obvious, for example, that if you call 911 because someone's having a heart attack, that they should dispatch paramedics, not police officers. If you call to report a house fire, they should dispatch firefighters. The purpose of the police is to threaten violence and to exercise violence. For any emergency that violence isn't equipped to solve, dispatch a specialist.
- david38 4y agoYou clearly have very little contact with the police. How many extended family members do you have on the force? This has to be the most pretentious post I’ve read all day.
- bicx 4y agoNo family members on the force. I’m sorry you took it that way. I’m not trying to address police brutality (which absolutely exists at a gross level), just what a police force is _supposed_ to be in the ideal sense.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 4y agoIn many places they dispatch police and paramedics for a heart attack. The police officers are trained to provide CPR and have defibrillators in their cars, of course. (The reason they don't just dispatch paramedics because the police can often be there faster, either because they have more units or simply happen to be closer.)
- giraffe_lady 4y agoYeah they might give you CPR and also maybe shoot your dog or check your family for warrants! Win/win right.
- Retric 4y agoThere are real concerns about sending the police in such cases. However heart attacks can very quickly lead to death and should therefore be treated as an all hands on deck situation. When in low population areas an ambulance might be 30+ minutes away, sending the police could save a lot of lives.
- e-clinton 4y agoMaybe we train them to leave to their weapons in the car unless told otherwise?
- googlryas 4y agoThat would never happen, because some non-zero number of people would lure police to their house to kill them.
- Wowfunhappy 4y agoWhy just police? A non-zero number of people have probably lured plumbers to their house to kill them. Should plumbers bring guns everywhere?
- sokoloff 4y agoWhen we get to the point where people are tagging and changing “All Plumbers are Bastards”, then yes, plumbers should carry when entering an unknown situation.
- Wowfunhappy 4y agoSo, I do get it, but it's also a self-fulfilling prophecy. People are chanting "all police are bastards" as a result of police carrying guns everywhere (and the downstream effects, like those guns occasionally shooting innocent people).
- 4y ago
- jakear 4y agoIt’s interesting the extent to which police varies geographically. I’d love for any police officer of Oregon to be at my side in times of trouble, but god forbid any King country officer show up when I’m in need. I’d wager any “blue lives matter” folks would change their mind when presented with urban officers, and on the flip side all “ACAB” people would flip when dealing with rural enforcement.
- feet 4y ago>flip side all “ACAB” people would flip when dealing with rural enforcement Unless they have brown skin In many areas getting pulled over for DWB is a real phenomenon
- jakear 4y agoHave you actual first hand experience of that or are you just propagating the predominant online rhetoric?
- feet 4y agoI'm propagating the first hand experiences that have been personally shared with me
- jakear 4y agoAh yes, hearsay. Got it.
- feet 4y agoAh yes, it didn't happen to you so it never happens right?
- jakear 4y agoEvery input must be scaled by one’s certainty the source is portraying an accurate and honest representation of the underlying facts (if you don’t perform such scaling I have no interest in your arguments). Before you made the above comment, I had my default small but nonzero belief you were portraying your experience accurately and the same for your source. Thus, multiplied together, the information carried little (but still nonzero!) weight. This isn’t me being difficult, it’s quite literally the at the core of any reasonable legal system. After you made this comment, willfully and egregiously misrepresenting what I said for the sake of… I don’t know what… I hold zero belief that you accurately and honestly represent underlying facts in arguments — meaning this thread has reached its natural conclusion. Cheers, have a good day.
- kibwen 4y agoThe idea of doubling up like that to increase coverage may be well-intentioned, but it's complicated specifically with regard to the police. If, say, you train firefighters to pull double-duty like that, then nobody's going to object; as the saying goes, nobody ever wrote a song called "fuck the fire department". For several demographics, the police do not inspire reassurance but instead inspire terror, and the prospect of the police showing up for a medical emergency can dissuade people from calling for help, potentially making health outcomes worse rather than better.
- bombcar 4y agoThere are many areas in the US where the fire department or paramedics will not go without a police escort, because they've been attacked too often when trying to render aid.
- kibwen 4y agoThat's an entirely separate concern. By all means, if paramedics don't feel safe going somewhere, then give them police escorts. The point is not to say "the police cannot come", it's to say "the police should not come unless someone asks for the police".
- googlryas 4y agoThe saying is silly, because there have been a number of instances where firemen are attacked or ambushed.
- JshWright 4y agoFirefighter/paramedic here. These are definitely outlier events. It's not zero risk, but it's close enough to zero to not worry about. That isn't to say violence against Fire/EMS isn't an issue, but the idea that we need cops on every call just in case it's an ambush is silly. One of my first priorities on a scene where there are cops present is to clear the cops as quickly as possible. Nine times out of ten if a cop is going to get involved in something, they're going to escalate things, not cool them down.
- bicx 4y ago> The purpose of the police is to threaten violence and to exercise violence Not arguing against your final point, but the purpose of the police is to enforce the law, which does not ideally _have_ to involve violence or threat of violence. Sometimes it just means giving someone a traffic citation.
- arcbyte 4y agoWithout the threat of violence I'm not accepting a traffic violation.
- feet 4y agoNobody here will kink shame you
- jamiek88 4y agoWho’s gonna make me pay it? Ah. The judge. Backed up with jail. Who’s gonna put me in jail? I mean I’m 6’3 and 230lbs and a right arrogant asshole - I won’t go easy. Officers with guns you say? Okay! I’ll pay.
- bicx 4y agoI mean, it's your choice to make it violent. They should be able to counter _your_ threat of violence effectively, but violence is not the default way that someone gets taken to jail. Ultimately, the law is based on threat of punishment, which can come in many forms. For a lot of us here on HN, being violently thrown into a squad car is less threatening than having your career put into jeopardy by having a mark on your record.
- sneak 4y ago> I mean, it's your choice to make it violent. No, that's the lie that violent people tell. > but violence is not the default way that someone gets taken to jail. Most people do not go to jail willingly. It is always the threat of violence that gets them there. Let's not pretend.
- cannaceo 4y agoPolice are responsible for clearing the scene of any danger before other first responders arrive.
- noahtallen 4y agoIf one is innocent until proven guilty, then using violence against them before their trial is by definition an extrajudicial punishment, even if they ultimately deserve it. This is why we should strongly advocate for non-violent apprehension pretty much across the board. There must be better strategies than shooting at or even killing someone before they get a trial.
- tzs 4y ago> If one is innocent until proven guilty, then using violence against them before their trial is by definition an extrajudicial punishment, even if they ultimately deserve it. Only if the violence is used punitively.
- polski-g 4y agoPolice do not give up their right to self defense when they take the job. If someone is trying to kill it hurt you, you have the right to use lethal force in response. Same thing for police.
- tonymet 4y agoIf you say "my uncle is having a heart attack", the remedy is obvious. If you say "my parents are fighting and one has a knife" – it's not so clear that a social worker will help (or be safe)