3 ms·
The second part doesn't seem correct; a huge amount of new development in Denmark is done by people on transfer income. For example, a number of research result
by _delirium 15y ago
The second part doesn't seem correct; a huge amount of new development in Denmark is done by people on transfer income. For example, a number of research results that later were commercialized have come out of Masters theses (there's even a whole arrangement where you can do a thesis in collaboration with a company), and a number of companies were funded initially by some kind of government benefits, sometimes officially and sometimes unofficially (since you lose benefits once you're officially "working for a startup"). Even when the money doesn't go directly to the startup, it provides a backstop so people feel more free to take risks starting a company.
I guess it'd be interesting to read a study quantifying it, but I'd be surprised if it were really true that not much research comes out of people on transfer incomes, especially if you include the people who used transfer incomes to bootstrap the early stages of a startup.
- mseebach 15y agoSo, student subsidies are the odd one out here, because they're not money you're given to survive, they're given in exchange for a specific activity. They do, however, count as transfer income, and the source I have for 60% didn't break it down. Yes, unemployment benefits can provide a backstop that enables entrepreneurship, but Denmark has more generous benefits than most other countries, yet the levels of entrepreneurship don't follow. Any other direct subsidy towards entrepreneurship (although often misguided) aren't transfer income in the sense being suggested by the GP. The people who can just sit around and come up with exciting new research or who can become successful entrepreneurs are generally also the kind of people who can get a job if they want or need one.
- oelewapperke 15y agoStudent subsidies are less than 1% of all social security spending in Denmark. Also, most of even that 1% it is wasted. The majority of people fail, even with this more than generous government support.