3 ms·
Our best minds are working on this amazing near-magical new technology.. which will end up being productized into an Instagram Filter service to dynamically inj
by metadat 4y ago
Our best minds are working on this amazing near-magical new technology.. which will end up being productized into an Instagram Filter service to dynamically inject a stained glass unicorn in place of a horse in a video.
That's cool and all, but also really stupid and a pointless distraction compared to how novel the underlying mathematics and science are. This will quickly become a commodity and humans will acclimate to seeing such tricks.
The content produced won't even be considered particularly impressive.
Damn. I was hoping the singularity would be better.
- naillo 4y agoI think now is a good time (now that they're out of research zone and actually working) for a flood of new people to enter this space and try to come up with more creative ideas than that. It's an exciting time for cool ideas and cool projects if we take off our cynicism hat for a bit.
- metadat 4y agoHow is this going to be accessible to the new wave of people you're imagining? I'd be all for it! Just not clear on a plausible path for how this better future comes to pass.
- naillo 4y agoWell you will have to do some work to understand them (read papers etc). But distilled (from larger models) versions of these things are fairly capable of being computed even on the web etc. There's definitely cool low hanging fruit here (though it's not plug and play import a library). The main thing is that these have been proven to be as powerful as they are (last year it wasn't clear they'd be able to get this good), so with some effort there's definitely cool stuff to be built. I'm excited (and working on it myself).
- skybrian 4y agoYes, lowering the cost of special effects means that they're not that special and there will be lots of crap. On the other hand, it lowers the cost of filmmaking, so there should be storytellers who use this to good effect, where the special effect isn't that noticeable but serves the story? Though, a question is whether the good storytellers can be found easily? It seems like the situation is similar in fan fiction.
- zitterbewegung 4y agoThe thesis "Best new minds" is not even correct. If the "Best new minds" didn't create things like social networking and instagram we wouldn't even have the data sources to build upon these new algorithms to even work. Also, without a bunch of video game makers actually pushing graphics cards we also would have the hardware to do these things. So the "best new minds" accidentally enabled more "best new minds".
- avgcorrection 4y agoSo what? 1. Their priorities are wrong so they are not the best minds 2. If (1) is false because the best minds can have stupid priorities, then The Best Minds is not the be-all-end-all of everything
- TaylorAlexander 4y agoI see it differently. As a robotics engineer I know the biggest impediment to robotics development is getting computers to understand the real world. The work on multimodal neurons, which see the word cake and know to associate it with images of cake, is a key stepping stone along the way to a fully functional embodied AI that can solve difficult real world problems. CLIP, DALL-E, and all these off shoots are representations of what we can pull from these efforts today. But long term this work will be incorporated in to bigger and more capable AI systems. Just think: when I ask you “walk in to the workshop, grab a hammer and a box of nails, and meet me on the roof to help me secure some loose shingles” your mind is already imagining the path you will take to get there, what it will look like when you locate and grab the hammer and nails, and you’ve filled in that to get on the roof you have to meet me in the back yard to climb the ladder, which I never mentioned. All these tiny details your mind can do effortlessly take huge efforts like CLIP to sort out how to make it work. And even CLIP is only text and images. There is a lot more to go from there. A lot of people focus on DALL-E and the artifacts that come out along the way, but these are not the destination, just little stops showing the progress we are making on a much larger journey.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]