3 ms·
Sorry, but "we don't have enough evidence to claim that you did this, but we do have enough evidence to put you in jail for five years" is not a coherent perspe
by thaumasiotes 4y ago
Sorry, but "we don't have enough evidence to claim that you did this, but we do have enough evidence to put you in jail for five years" is not a coherent perspective.
And it's not relevant anyway. Once you're acquitted, you didn't commit the crime. Hazy evidence that you did commit the crime might be something the sentencing judge can legitimately consider, but it's necessarily overruled by the fact that you didn't commit the crime, which is something the sentencing judge must consider.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Sorry, but "we don't have enough evidence to claim that you did this, but we do have enough evidence to put you in jail for five years" is not a coherent perspective. That's true, but that's not relevant, because that's not the scenario. The standard for criminal conviction is not the standard for “to claim that you did this”, it is the standard to determine the maximum legal criminal punishment. The standard for a judge to assign punishment within the range specified by the statute under which a person was convicted is lower, because by definition the facts which allow the maximum sentence in that range have been established beyond a reasonable doubt. > Once you're acquitted, you didn't commit the crime Legally “didn’t commit the crime” (and thus not allowing separate punishment for the crime) is not the same as “did not do something substantially similar to the crime“ (which therefore might be eligible for sanctions other than separate criminal punishment, such as enhancements within the statutorily authorized range of punishments for another crime, civil liability, or all kinds of different things.) Heck, it doesn't even mean “did not commit a crime with substantially identical elements within the jurisdiction of a separate sovereign with concurrent jurisdiction”, though that's not directly relevant to this case.
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> Heck, it doesn't even mean “did not commit a crime with substantially identical elements within the jurisdiction of a separate sovereign with concurrent jurisdiction”, though that's not directly relevant to this case. I don't think you'll find many people arguing that this is a state of affairs that makes any sense. My position in this thread takes the form "the justice system is doing something that is self-evidently insane". And that's also what I would say here. Being insane in one way doesn't stop you from being insane in another way. > The standard for criminal conviction is not the standard for “to claim that you did this” And this just isn't true. The standard for making the claim is the standard for conviction. As far as the law is concerned, the conviction is how you make the claim. As a person, if you make the claim in the absence of a conviction you'll run into serious legal problems. Unless, apparently, you're handing down a sentence for some other crime, in which case anything goes.
- ceejayoz 4y ago> The standard for making the claim is the standard for conviction. Again, this isn't true. The standard for evaluating a claim is different for conviction versus sentencing. > As a person, if you make the claim in the absence of a conviction you'll run into serious legal problems. No, you won't, at least not necessarily. Libel would be a civil action, and as with sentencing, the standard is lower in a civil trial. This is, for example, why OJ Simpson got acquitted in criminal court but was deemed culpable for the murders in civil court.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> As a person, if you make the claim in the absence of a conviction you'll run into serious legal problems. No, you won't. Heck, as a person, you can make the same claim in court and win a sizable payout based on it with evidence insufficient for a criminal conviction, even if the elements required for civil liability are identical to those for the crime, because the standard of evidence in a civil case is preponderance of the evidence, not beyond a reasonable doubt like a criminal conviction. The high burden of proof required for criminal conviction specifically exists as a narrow purpose failsafe that doesn't apply in other contexts even within the criminal justice system.
- ceejayoz 4y ago> Once you're acquitted, you didn't commit the crime. No. "Not guilty" is not the same as "innocent". Not guilty means they could not prove you committed the crime beyond a reasonable doubt; that it's possible that you're innocent.
- colejohnson66 4y agoCase in point: OJ Simpson. It’s widely believed he did murder his wife, but the recent death of Rodney King and the whole glove affair in court allowed him to be found “not guilty”.
- throwaway654329 4y agoNo, it really is a matter of settled law in America that if acquitted of a charge that you are innocent as you start with the presumption of innocence. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Presumption_of_innocence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Presumption_of_innocence is a useful resource for understanding why a person is innocent unless and until they have been proven guilty. It is surprising that this is even a matter of debate. This is a basic fact taught as part of U.S. compulsory education.