4 ms·
>Few of us urgently depend on email just this hour. I agree that you shouldn't be manically refreshing your email every 5 minutes, but my mail service being do
by gruez 4y ago
>Few of us urgently depend on email just this hour.
I agree that you shouldn't be manically refreshing your email every 5 minutes, but my mail service being down for a few hours would definitely be a major inconvenience if I needed to get a 2fa code during that time. Same if I needed to look at my email to view my tickets for an upcoming event.
- usr1106 4y agoThat sounds like an fragile setup if you depend on a single email account to get 2FA codes. I have them configured typically on my office workstation (reachable remotely if everything works), on my laptop, on my phone, and I have the static backup codes in my password manager which is also distributed over several indpendent machines. Of course if you have to respond to incoming tickets within a guaranteed short timeframe that gets a problem if nothing can come in. Make your risk assessment in advance: Can I live without it for a while, in the worst case even until I have an alternative provider? If so then just do so when an outage happens. If that's not acceptable for your case you need to have an independent backup before the first outage.
- favourable 4y agoIt's a misfeature using e-mail for 2FA login codes. TOTP is far more reliable. Any service doing e-mail only 2FA should be called out and questioned. Never assume a user has access to their email at all times.
- usr1106 4y agoRight, I must admit I had never heard of email being used for 2FA codes. Is that some kind of standardized protocol or something completely homegrown? In the far past (and still today with 2 banks) I use hardware/smartcard based solutions. But everything vaguely IT world seems to use TOTP. They typically advertise it as Google Autenticator, but I use different FOSS implementations on both PC and phone and they have worked 100% smoothly.
- gruez 4y ago> Right, I must admit I had never heard of email being used for 2FA codes. Is that some kind of standardized protocol or something completely homegrown? If you don't have 2fa explicitly set up and browse with VPN enabled, you'll frequently get sites that want you to authenticate via email. Amazon does this, for instance.