3 ms·
Sentencing has always had unprovable stuff considered. Your friends and family will come in to tell what a wonderful person you are, none of it verifiable and o
by ceejayoz 4y ago
Sentencing has always had unprovable stuff considered. Your friends and family will come in to tell what a wonderful person you are, none of it verifiable and often entirely bullshit.
- notch656a 4y agoBeing wonderful or not wonderful isn't a crime though. His sentencing included presumption of an unproven crime. The US justice system is explicitly based on not considering someone guilty of a crime until proven guilty. You have no right to not be considered a wonderful or horrible person, but you do have a right to not be considered guilty of the crime until convicted.
- ceejayoz 4y ago> The US justice system is explicitly based on not considering someone guilty of a crime until proven guilty. For a criminal conviction, the standard is "proof beyond a reasonable doubt". For sentencing, judges can consider evidence under a different standard, "preponderance of the evidence". As prosecutors introduced evidence of the murder-for-hire allegations in trial, the judge was permitted to consider it.
- saurik 4y agoFWIW, that probably shouldn't be taken into consideration either? I'd argue they should "clean room" the sentence by having a second judge read an assessment of the evidence by the first judge and have them conduct the sentencing, lest sentences be more about how people look than what they did (and allowing laws to continue to be overly harsh but with enough last minute exceptions that no one "important" has reason to complain).
- akira2501 4y agoYour behavior before, during, and after the crime are incredibly relevant to your sentencing. The court is trying to determine the best course of action to prevent repeating the behavior and minimize future potential harms, these things must be considered. This is not a "one size fits all" or "strictly by the numbers" question, and we are not benefited as a society by treating it that way.
- 3a2d29 4y agoBased on this argument, shouldn’t Ross’ murder-for-hires be included in sentencing then? Clearly he didn’t just build a drug website, he was fine ending lives for it. A slap on the wrist (even if his family thinks he is a good guy) wouldn’t deter him much, it would seem.
- akira2501 4y agoThey didn't charge him with them, but if you read the sentencing transcript [1] you can see it was definitely considered those facts and the specific facts of each murder for hire plot when arriving at a judgement. And the first judge very much agreed with your assessment. [1]: https://freeross.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/05/Sentencing_2015-May-29.pdf https://freeross.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/05/Sentencing_2...
- randombits0 4y agoThen why is Liberty wearing a blindfold? Unequal is not justice.
- akira2501 4y agoThat's because she weighs facts without prejudice, not that she ignores them entirely; which, is likely why she also has the scales. Or are you suggesting the message is truly "justice is completely blind?" If a defendant has been convicted and then goes on to hold the court publicly in contempt gets a harsher sentence than someone who is truly reticent and has taken actions to attempt to restore their victims even before sentencing.. I don't see how justice has been unequally applied. The two defendants _are_ unequal. That's the point.
- randombits0 4y agoBut the offense against the people is the same. Don’t impose social engineering at the sentencing level. It’s not up to the judge. The judge is an idiot, just like us. Now I understand your position and even agree with it to a point, the idea that justice is blind means judgment is without consideration of undue influence. Like many things, balance is the best approach. Minimum sentences came about when the prior sentences were perceived to be unreasonable. Don’t get me started on prison reform, though. Blind or not, US prisons are inherently unconstitutional.
- HWR_14 4y agoFor what it's worth, although it has some judgement call inputs, sentencing at the federal level usually adheres to a guideline formula. I believe that also happened in this case.
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> Sentencing has always had unprovable stuff considered. Your friends and family will come in to tell what a wonderful person you are, none of it verifiable and often entirely bullshit. True, but I see a bigger problem with sentencing being based on conduct that the defendant was acquitted of. The concept is supposed to be that if you were acquitted, you didn't commit the crime.
- ceejayoz 4y agoHe wasn't acquitted of the murder-for-hire stuff. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ross_Ulbricht#Murder-for-hire_allegations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ross_Ulbricht#Murder-for-hire_...
- thaumasiotes 4y agoThat's just as much a refutation of your comment as it is of mine. Remember saying this? >>> Sentencing has always had unprovable stuff considered. But still, looking outside this trial, sentences being handed out based on acquitted conduct is very much a thing that happens, and it shouldn't be allowed.
- ceejayoz 4y agoThe issue at play there is the different standards for conviction vs sentencing. The standard for conviction is "beyond a reasonable doubt". The standard for something to be considered in sentencing is "perponderance of the evidence". As such, it's possible for a judge to take a look at a case where a conviction couldn't be obtained, but consider the evidence to be compelling enough to use in sentencing for something else.
- thaumasiotes 4y agoSorry, but "we don't have enough evidence to claim that you did this, but we do have enough evidence to put you in jail for five years" is not a coherent perspective. And it's not relevant anyway. Once you're acquitted, you didn't commit the crime. Hazy evidence that you did commit the crime might be something the sentencing judge can legitimately consider, but it's necessarily overruled by the fact that you didn't commit the crime, which is something the sentencing judge must consider.