3 ms·
The article totally fails to mention the elephant in the room: graduate school costs! Moreover, the public debate over student loan forgiveness typically fails
by lapcat 4y ago
The article totally fails to mention the elephant in the room: graduate school costs!
Moreover, the public debate over student loan forgiveness typically fails to mention that graduate students owe 50% of all student loan debt, despite being only 25% of all student loan debtors.
Getting a PhD often takes many years, and the PhD completion rate for incoming graduate students is very low. Even after you get a PhD, it can be difficult to get a tenure track job. For those who get on the tenure track, you'll probably be fine financially, but for everyone else... going graduate school can ruin your life. You may waste the best years of your life while accumulating a debt you can never pay off, without even an official graduation certificate to show for it.
College, including graduate school, is so much more expensive now than it was decades ago. And people forget that the post-WWII generation could use the GI Bill to pay for both undergraduate and graduate school.
- RickJWagner 4y agoThat's one of the reasons I oppose taxpayer-funded debt dismissal. It's just not right to ask low-income taxpayers (including those who didn't go to college) to pay off the debts of those who did go-- and have a higher earnings potential. It's also a great dis-service to those who have paid into Social Security for decades and now face a looming shortfall. Those people actually paid in and are going to have to deal with a benefit reduction, while the student borrowers took out and may potentially have their debts funded by the same taxpayers!
- lapcat 4y ago> It's just not right to ask low-income taxpayers (including those who didn't go to college) Low-income people don't actually pay much taxes. In fact their primary tax payment may be the fixed-rate Social Security FICA that you mention, not the progressive income taxes after deductions and credits. Moreover, what about the low-income student who have to go into debt to go to school, while the rich kids have their parents pay for everything? This is my point in relation to the article: who can afford to even get a PhD nowadays except the kids of financially well-off parents? That's one of the reason richer kids are coming to dominate academia. > a higher earnings potential My point is that the difference between actual and potential is the difference between a comfortable life and a lifetime of debt that may follow you to old age and death. There's basically no return whatsoever on your investment if you spend years in a PhD program but don't finish. It's all money down the drain. Meanwhile, graduate students are exploited by universities for very cheap teaching labor.
- slt2021 4y agothis is not true. PhD coursework qualifies for Masters degree. Almost all PhD dropouts (on 1-2 year) - dropout with masters degree and a very nice industry job offer in hand.
- lapcat 4y agoWhich industry? The English literature industry? The history industry? The philosophy industry?
- slt2021 4y agophd students from low income background are not doing eng lit/hist/phil phd, never seen one. It is mostly people from affluent backgrounds who go there. but I have seen more than enough econ phd dropouts who left academia with MS in Econ and a finance industry job offer. same for most of the engineering PhDs.
- lapcat 4y ago"It is mostly people from affluent backgrounds who go there." This is the whole point of the article, "People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate academia"! What do you mean by low income though? There's low income and there's affluent, but there's also the big middle class between those two.
- MontyCarloHall 4y agoMost graduate school debt is due to master’s degrees and professional degrees (e.g. JDs, MDs, MBAs). The vast majority of PhD programs are fully funded, fully covering tuition and providing a (modest) stipend.
- lapcat 4y agoCitation please? For reference, I was in a PhD program in the humanities at the University of Wisconsin, and it was definitely not fully funded.
- MontyCarloHall 4y agoSure: https://www.air.org/sites/default/files/downloads/report/STEM%20Graduate%20Funding%20Brief%20%20Sept%202014.pdf https://www.air.org/sites/default/files/downloads/report/STE... In STEM fields, 10% of PhD students reported using external (non-university) funds as their primary source of grad school funding; 10% of those externally funded students (1% overall) reported using loans as their primary funding source. In non-STEM fields, the proportion of non-funded PhD students is higher, at 35%, of which about half (17% overall) used loans as their primary source of funding. Given that the majority of PhDs in the US are in STEM, it is correct to say that the vast majority of American PhD programs are fully funded.
- lapcat 4y ago> In STEM fields, 10% of PhD students No. The link is a study of PhD recipients not PhD students. This is a crucial distinction, because my main claim was about the effects of attending graduate school on non-recipients. It's quite likely that PhD recipients are better funded than non-recipients, which funding helps them to complete their PhDs. In my academic department, there were many more students than there were sources of funding such as teaching assistantships, research assistantships, lectureships, and fellowships. > In non-STEM It's not clear to me that the study was comprehensive. It says STEM and SBE (social, behavioral, and economic), but does SBE mean non-STEM? Why didn't they just say non-STEM? Does SBE include Art, English, History, and Music, for example? > Given that the majority of PhDs in the US are in STEM ~65% of PhDs awarded are in STEM, but only ~25% of Masters degrees are in STEM. This may say a lot about the PhD completion rate. At my school, a Masters was often rewarded on the way to a PhD, so it was kind of a (mostly worthless) consolation prize for those who didn't finish their PhD. Anyway, the study is primarily about the "primary source" of funding, which is not quite the same as full funding. The linked study was heavy with survivorship bias. Sadly, grad school dropouts are mostly forgotten and ignored by society.
- ls612 4y agoThis isn’t due to Economics Phds. In my program (and in every other top program) we get full funding plus a stipend so we don’t need to go into debt. And completion rates are very high, out of a cohort of 20 usually only 1 or 2 a year can’t pass their prelims. The filter is at the admissions stage, which is nearly as bad as for the ivies. For comparison, at the University of Minnesota (a state school with a top 15 Econ department) we get 400 applications to the PhD program a year and admit 50, of which 20 are expected to actually come.