4 ms·
There's a whole genre of simple mathematical models that excuse centuries of well documented oppression. Like the 'only a small amount of desire to live near s
by ZeroGravitas 4y ago
There's a whole genre of simple mathematical models that excuse centuries of well documented oppression.
Like the 'only a small amount of desire to live near similar people leads to self-segregation' thing.
You know what else leads to segregation? Actual laws that enforce it at the point of a gun with legal and extra-legal terrorism.
If only there was some way to tell which of these occurred in real history.
- fartsucker69 4y agoI don't know what point you're making. Should those models not be allowed to exist? Usually the way this goes is that a scientist proposes a model to describe something, and it's fine. When it goes wrong is usually when the public picks up that science and uses it to do something horrible. The thing about self-segregation behaviour you mention is a basic fact of life, you can see it everywhere, all the time, chances are you've done it to yourself if you've ever been embedded in a different culture for any amount of time. It's interesting and potentially useful to build a scientific model out of it for analysis or other purposes. There's no problem at all with it until some politician thinks it allows them to be bigoted and oppressive. If the actual 'science' implied in any way that people should be oppressed based on the models, it was obviously bad science and would not have stood the test of time in any case.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoI've created a simple mathmatical model that suggests they wouldn't get created in the first place, so we no longer need to discuss whether banning them was a good idea or not, it just happened naturally, and there's nothing anyone could have done to change that.
- yekoc 4y agoAnd the obviously hyperbolical nature of that model still doesn't prevent you from creating it or from it leading to potential further research oppurtunities (in fact,please do release the paper that results from such,I'd love to read it.) and following logically from that it still doesn't prevent anyone from creating a model that disagrees or from following any potential research opputunities that such would lead to. The validity of a mathematical model is dependent solely upon it's internal (and,depending on the extent of the research,external) consistency.Whether it possess any form of 'accuracy to the real world' only comes into play when people who don't understand this attempt to use it to justify their preconceptions.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoHere is the model: Individual agents have a mild preference for publishing only models I agree with. They will never publish anything that I 2/3 disagree with (I rank all published papers in order of preference and the bottom 1/3 fail this test) and will immediately retract anything they have published that I disagree with to that extent and replace it with something I do agree with a random amount that places it in the top 66%. We start with them having published things that I randomly agree or disagree with. No other factor than my agreement will have any impact on their decision to publish or retract. Surprisingly, with only this mild preference people will automatically self censor and not publish any models I disagree with. In reality, it's a series of laws that stops them, but we've just proved it's natural so really do those laws even matter?
- dhruvdh 4y agoIt would help if you read the parent comment and made a response to its contents. In so far, you've just validated his point - as a member of "the public" not understanding science and using partial truths to reinforce previously held beliefs. The point I think the parent is trying to make is that the problem is not scientists creating models, the problem is people not understanding the models and using it as an excuse to be vicious; or politicians using an untrue view of models to further their own agendas.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- zozbot234 4y ago> Like the 'only a small amount of desire to live near similar people leads to self-segregation' thing. > You know what else leads to segregation? Actual laws that enforce it at the point of a gun with legal and extra-legal terrorism. "Tell me you don't understand social science, without telling me you don't understand social science." The point of these models is not usually to argue for the status quo. Often they're made as a simple sanity check. For instance, if even small incentives towards aggregation can lead to self-segregation, this changes the policies we would choose to try and create a different outcome.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoIt's not a small incentive though. It's a toy model where the only thing that the agent cares about is how many of his neighbours are the same color as him. Every single person in this model society will immediately move house if 1/3 of their immediate neighbours are the wrong color and not move to any such neighbourhood for any reason, since there are no other motivations in the model. Which apparently was considered a 'mild' preference by the person who made the model, in the middle of the civil rights era. It basically renders any immigration inpossible for example, is that really a mild preference?
- zozbot234 4y agoIs it really that surprising that people might have wanted to model "preferences for segregation" in the middle of the civil rights era? That's when controversial policies such as school busing were started, and the implied argument for those was not very different from the one that's surfaced by this model - segregation was understood as self-reinforcing, and only very strong policy choices could drive a "mixing" outcome.
- topynate 4y agoYou are referring to Schelling's model, and the threshold he found for segregation wasn't 1/3 but 2/3 'wrong', i.e. that everyone prefer not to be in a minority of less than 1/3. This was just was striking about it – that even if every individual is happy with being in a minority, the population can still segregate. I'm not aware that he ever referred to the degree of preference in his model as 'mild', or small. It's relatively small, compared to what you might otherwise expect – I think most people would have guessed that it took a preference of 1/2 to produce self-segregation.