11 ms·
Experian, you have some explaining to do
- latchkey 4y agoI'm still waiting for my payout from the hack in 2017 [1] (not that I expect to ever see anything from it). [1] https://www.ftc.gov/enforcement/refunds/equifax-data-breach-settlement https://www.ftc.gov/enforcement/refunds/equifax-data-breach-...
- pbuzbee 4y agoThis page really drills into you how pathetic this settlement is. Less than $3 per affected person for something that affects over a hundred million people. And as if to rub salt in the wound: > 3. I don’t want Equifax to have my data. What can I do? > Equifax is one of three national credit bureaus. These companies collect information about your credit history, such as how many credit cards you have, how much money you owe, and how you pay your bills. Each company creates a credit report about you, and then sells this report to businesses who are deciding whether to give you credit. You cannot opt out of this data collection. However, you can review your credit report for free and freeze your credit.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- plorg 4y agoI signed up for the identity monitoring offered as part of the class-action lawsuit for the 2017 hack. Now I get an email whenever the developmentally disabled guy who works at Hardee's moves to a new apartment, because 15 years ago he tried to have sex with a teenager when he was 20. Yeah, obviously not good, but what the hell does it have to do with my identity? None of these people have lived within half a mile of me, and they have no connection to me or any of the identifying data that Experian associates with me. And I know who they are, because they are already half the content of the police Twitter. Their website has an FAQ item asking specifically what unrelated sex offenders have to do with identity protection, and the answer is, "Many of our customers like getting these alerts". Literally no attempt to answer the question that they voluntarily added to their website. It turns out you literally cannot turn off sex offender notices (within an unspecified distance of your home) without turning off all notices for activity under your name, address, or SSN.
- paulmd 4y agoMy mortgage servicer recently moved to a new system where it apparently has different password standards than the old system, and the frontend will filter it, and doesn't work properly with password managers, and it locks the account after 3 incorrect passwords. The only way to reset it is a call-in system which does not support mortgage accounts - it will not take a mortgage account number or SSN or a third-party-bank checking account number as being a valid identifier. So basically it is impossible for mortgage-only customers to ever reset a password once it's become locked out. Just start opening CFPB complaints and do your best to push all the buttons in the way that sets off the maximum alarm bells. Yes, this is preventing me from making my payment, why do you ask? Got a call from an "executive support team" two days later. Her answer was to just batter my way through the phone system until I got an operator because it was definitely, totally the right number... should go back and see if they ever actually fixed it, I ended up just knuckling under and using a short, insecure password that their system would actually accept, maybe I should see where the CFPB complaint is. But if you don't let up, CFPB complaints are a big deal and will absolutely get movement, they've definitely resolved "intractable" (read: bank couldn't be bothered reading the case notes after a half dozen times repeating it to them, even when I repeated it all for them) issues for me in the past. (I am on autopay but genuinely if something went wrong with my credit union or the mortgage system and I needed to get in, I would be fucked. Sure I could pay by check/paper coupon but I'd have to cancel the autopay first and I don't know if I can do that on the coupon either... it's really only the inertia of a few things still working right that actually did prevent problems with payments in general, so actually "problems with payment" isn't real far off.)
- lelandfe 4y ago> having an active account at Experian may be the only way you find out when crooks have assumed your identity. Because at least then you should receive an email from Experian saying they gave your identity to someone else How does this keep happening... It's pretty remarkable the gallery of blunders a simple HN search gets you for "experian": https://hn.algolia.com/?q=experian https://hn.algolia.com/?q=experian
- genocidicbunny 4y agoIt keeps happening because there are no consequences for it happening. If the c-levels at Experian were sent to prison for a few years each time this happens, you can bet your last dollar they'd put measures in place to prevent this sort of thing.
- lbriner 4y agoThat's a nice soundbite but it doesn't work like that irl. If in some dystopian future, the C-levels could be given 2 years for what could amount to a basic human error in an otherwise well-run organisation, no-one would do the job and a whole sector of the economy would probably go bust. Having worked in a handful of companies, at least some of them try to do the job properly but are restricted by employee turnover, lack of consistent skills across the software sector, negligence at any level, incompetence - even if not malicious, tired engineers, ancient software systems that would be impossible to replace in any reason time etc.
- erwincoumans 4y agoSure, but not adding the option for two-factor authentication for Experian is much worse than just a basic human error.
- wffurr 4y agoSimple solutions to all of these that ultimately land on the desk of leadership: >> employee turnover, lack of consistent skills across the software sector, negligence at any level, incompetence - even if not malicious, tired engineers Pay better, give raises that keep up with the market, and train your people. Basic stuff. >> ancient software systems that would be impossible to replace in any reason time etc. Second best time to start is now. Ancient software systems with tons of legacy cruft and obsolete tech aren't going to get any better. All this costs money, which is the real problem. If there's a market wide failure, as there seems to be in credit reporting, then serious consequences for cheating out on this stuff to undercut your competitors at the cost of security seems fully justified.
- nynx 4y agoIncredible how bad the security posture is for companies like this. This should be illegal.
- lbriner 4y agoWhat should be illegal? Not having 2-factor auth? Allowing an account change? SOftware is massively complex and not everything has been defined in a way that there is a "right" way and a "wrong" way to do things. What happens if they setup 2-factor and someone loses their phone? What happens if someone needs to change an email address and can't access their old account because an ISP has gone bust or is refusing to give you access? I agree that things should be much better but until there is a book of "this is the right way to do signup/signin/account reset/ etc. " then most of us are trying to do things the best way we know how to and sometimes bad things happen.
- closewith 4y agoIt should be unlawful to process sensitive personal data without adequate security. It already is in the EU, which is why private credit registers are all but extinct in the bloc now.
- rcMgD2BwE72F 4y agoI wish non-EU developers better knew what the GDPR offers (and requires): https://gdpr-info.eu/issues/privacy-by-design/ https://gdpr-info.eu/issues/privacy-by-design/
- collegeburner 4y agoDefine adequate security. Maybe I want to adopt post quantum crypto but now the law doesn't allow it? Or u2f not totp but the law doesn't allow it? Law can hold back security just as much as improve it. Remember how long it took the feds to get off 3DES? Remember all the leaks of personal data (like all military in US or basically everybody in china)? Govts are shit at security.
- 4y ago
- jandrese 4y agoWhile I agree with the article that it is embarrassing that Experian doesn't support 2 factor authentication, I'm not sure it would have helped in this case since the account was migrated without ever authenticating to it. Normally a security breach this egregious would require the attacker to call the help desk, but for some reason Experian has it baked right into the signup process. That is an impressive level of negligence. Someone had to put some serious effort into opening up that security hole.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- adrr 4y agoThere are cases when people lose access to emails. They should require snail mail as additional factor to recover an account and change emails.
- jandrese 4y agoLosing access to email isn't a problem if the mail sent to the old address is just "this account was migrated to X, click here if this was in error to have the change reverted". If the email account has been lost then it is no problem, if the attacker has access to your email too then you're up a creek either way.
- lbriner 4y agoAt a minimum, a good system would email both old and new email addresses saying, "someone has changed the email address, click here if that is wrong". This kind of slapdash approach to security needs to become criminal because companies are clearly not following best-practices and to be honest, as someone who has implemented these sorts of things on a number of legacy systems, it really isn't hard to do.
- richrichardsson 4y ago> slapdash approach to security needs to become criminal 100% this. If there were serious consequences to not taking (customer) account security seriously, perhaps it wouldn't be such a common occurrence.
- magillax 4y agoThis is probably a stupid question but is there any way to avoid Experian altogether and still have/use credit in the US?
- kube-system 4y agoOnly use creditors that don’t report to Experian? You’ll probably have to look outside of traditional creditors to do this. Maybe through a credit union?
- astura 4y agoNo
- bombcar 4y agoYou can throw yourself at the mercy of Dunn and Bradstreet instead, I guess, by creating an LLC to do all your "credit" stuff. Probably not worth it in the long run. Maybe brokerages don't report to Experian? So you could use margin as a form of credit? Unknown.
- aerostable_slug 4y agoIt would be difficult. They aren't just using creditor information. All three big agencies have access to DMV records, a variety of real estate databases, they scan court records from the biggest counties down to tiny municipalities, they buy mailing lists, etc. The data gathered by them goes far beyond your employment, purchase, and credit histories. And it is constantly ongoing (much to the chagrin of small municipal courts who have one old Dell that's scraped multiple times per day, every day). You just don't know it because it's hidden behind a series of machinations that not only generate the credit score we're all used to, but also a variety of B2B products from renter risk to identity verification.
- DamnableNook 4y agoModerately tangential, but I just had my Uber account hacked today. I also used a strong, unique password managed by a password manager. As far as I can tell, my email wasn’t hacked (Google Workspace account backed by a physical security key). My best guess is they scammed support, but I am just taking a stab in the dark. The worst part is, you can’t even talk to Uber support chat unless you put in the account’s current email, phone number, and last 6 digits of the credit card on the account. I have the attacker’s email address, but not the phone number, so I couldn’t even chat with support. They have an “email support” form, but it asks for the same info. I put in what I knew, but I haven’t heard back from support since the attacker took my account this afternoon, and I fear I’m not going to get it back.
- kube-system 4y agoThis page might cater to that situation?: https://help.uber.com/riders/article/i-think-my-account-has-been-hacked-----?nodeId=68905011-d5a0-4311-bd20-25c7dec719bf https://help.uber.com/riders/article/i-think-my-account-has-... Interestingly enough it also says: > We are currently seeing a high number of requests come through this form.
- DamnableNook 4y agoThat’s a great link, thank you for that! Their support page linked from the “email changed” message, under “if you didn’t make this change”, was less than helpful. It just said to log in and change your password, which isn’t really helpful if the attacker changed the password. The link for “if you can’t login” took me to a 404 page.
- abrookewood 4y agoPresumably they kept your credit card on file and are aiming for free rides? Seems risky from their perspective if you can get their phone number.
- DamnableNook 4y agoI luckily only had PayPal connected to my account. I was able to unlink it on the Uber side before the attacker blocked access to my account. I also blocked it on the PayPal side too. So all that work, and all they really got is my ride history and reputation.
- lazerl0rd 4y agoThat reminds me, I recently registered to Experian only to find out ".dev" emails are considered invalid. I had to register an email on one of my ".com" domains then forward over to even register with them. I called up support and they found it confusing as well, but hey ho - I can't even raise a ticket.
- collegeburner 4y agothis is what i keep telling my friends who get .dev .io .ninja or whatever. Spam filters don't care how fun and quirky your domain is. Neither do boomers they won't recognize it as a domain either. Just get the damn .com
- lazerl0rd 4y agoWhilst I agree people should at least have a ".com" backup domain (at least for email use), many services are supporting the less common TLDs nowadays. In particular, ".dev" seems to be supported well in my experience (where Experian has been the only problematic service). As for the spam filters, whilst the domain definitely does play a part in some cases - there's more to it than that. Having the correct security configuration (DKIM, etc.) and a "trusted" mail server (good luck asking M$ for their list, though) goes a long way.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jb1991 4y ago
- Bayart 4y ago>and other remnants of the last century that are non-existent in many European countries And also very much existent in many European countries, in particular the most important ones. Paper tech debt isn't exclusive to the US, any State that is old enough will have that sort of inertia. In my job I see a lot of systems dedicated to ingesting paper documents and normalizing them to newer digital standards, which obviously break constantly in semi-catastrophic fashion and requires regular manual intervention (I know a fellow production engineer who has refused to pay taxes on the Internet for as long as possible due to his experience of the sausage factory). Most of Western Europe seems to exist in that limbo.
- jb1991 4y agoI lived in a major west European nation for a decade and never saw: * paper checks in use anywhere; in fact depositing one from the States was a huge pain, if you could even find a bank that would accept it * any telephone system that authenticated an account number via touch-done dialing -- all had much more secure authentication systems that typically involved use of a custom digital ID two-factor via a specialized app or other mechanisms * any mention of a fax number
- Bayart 4y agoI literally used a paper check last month for my new apartment's deposit. It's still fairly common for some transactions in France. Last I heard, faxing was still a thing in corporate Germany.
- jb1991 4y ago> I literally used a paper check last month for my new apartment's deposit. That's interesting to hear. I didn't know that was still common; this article from 5 years ago suggests Europe doesn't use checks any more, and that's my experience as well. > The love affair with checks may be strictly American — countries in Europe, like Poland, Denmark, Finland, and the Netherlands stopped issuing checks over the last two decades https://www.theverge.com/ad/16774328/american-checks-currency https://www.theverge.com/ad/16774328/american-checks-currenc... A bit more poking around suggests France and Portugal are the main countries in Europe still regularly using checks in common practice.
- xoa 4y agoThis area of finance is utterly, completely backwards and seems like one of the most (evil)successful bits of proper-burden reversal in existence. The entire concept of "identity theft" as it exists now is 100% pure industry propaganda. Nobody is cloning bodies and transplanting brains or something. It's not that anyone is "stealing my identity" it's the financial institutions don't bother to verify it and then somehow have managed to make a system where this is my problem. If I haven't chosen to have a business relationship with a given financial institution or credit bureau, and they choose to give somebody else financial services, it shouldn't matter if that person used my name or widely circulated information about me, anything less then full biometrics/video for signup and establishing mutual certificates and cryptographically signed interactions thereafter should be presumptively invalid. If Person M lies to a Bank A about their info claiming to be Person A and tries to escape their commitments sure they've committed fraud, but if the Bank A then tries to go after Person A then the bank are literally accessories to fraud and should face criminal prosecution or at the least massive financial penalties (with both expenses and punitive fines paid to Person A). If the banks want to have private credit bureaus to help them with scaling, abstracting and reducing bias in the risk aspect sure; there are reasonable arguments for that. But said credit bureaus should have no role in identity verification, and if they are lying about people (claiming financial things about them which are not true) that again should be on them, with serious statutory penalties. All the burdens are completely backwards, in turn massively perverting the incentives. And it's eternally infuriating. Some rando applying for a credit line on the opposite side of the country should be Not My Problem, 100% of the time, whether they have my name or address or a random symmetric 9 digit number some government assigned me. All the tools exist for financial institutions to manage their risk/convenience tradeoff, but they're the ones who have the power, information and should have the incentive to do so. They are externalizing onto the general public instead.
- ValentineC 4y agoAs someone who's lived in a couple of countries, I think one reason credit bureaus are so heavily relied on in the US (and UK) is because they lack a centralised identity database that regulated financial institutions are able to draw from. Credit bureaus — as well as the various credit building products that are so common in these countries — are required to play that role.
- pards 4y agoI tried to "plant my flag" at the Canadian sites for Equifax and Transunion. * Equifax failed with a server error [0] * Transunion requires payment [1] At this point, it falls into the Too Hard basket and will not get done. [0]: https://my.equifax.ca/consumer-registration/?lang=en https://my.equifax.ca/consumer-registration/?lang=en [1]: https://members.transunion.ca/tucan_en/orderStep1_form.page https://members.transunion.ca/tucan_en/orderStep1_form.page?
- msdrigg 4y agoTransunion only requires payment for “Premium Services”. I just signed up for a free account and I am able to create a freeze without entering payment info
- coldcode 4y agoHmm I wonder if you could register a new account for the CEO of Experian and take his identity? That perhaps would create some incentive for them to change to better security. As long as its just grubby peons like us, why should they care? Too bad our elite senators and congress folks have no interest in keeping people's identity safe.
- annoyingnoob 4y agoThat is a great idea. All Experian executives and technology folks should have this done to them all day every day until the issue is resolved.
- KMag 4y agoI'm sure they reserve the extra tough prison cells for people who simultaneously commit identity theft and impersonate senators, and I'd certainly not advocate anyone commit crimes. However, I do think that if someone were to steal identities of sufficiently many senators and house representatives, we'd see incentives massively re-aligned within a couple of weeks.
- falcolas 4y agoExperian won’t explain anything to us, because we are not their customers. They talk to us only because laws make them talk to us. They have never shown interest in anything outside their B2B relationships with creditors and employers (remember, they track your employment history plus salaries for future employers’ use).
- fortran77 4y agoExperian should be shut down by the Federal Trade Commission and the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau today. There's no reason after the breach to allow them to have even one more sloppy mistake. The biggest mistake here was not having a link in the old email that says "CLICK HERE if you did NOT change your email" that would undo the email change and put some sort of lock or hold on the account.
- nottorp 4y agoSo this is a security hole, but isn’t the real reason for all these problems the fact that financial institutions don’t check identities properly? There would be no identity to steal if thieves knew that any bank will properly verify they are who they claim to be instead of just handing them money after they recite a SSN…
- admn2 4y agoIs it recommended to sign up for an account that so at the bare minimum we can be notified if someone changes the email?
- brightball 4y agoIt's shocking to me that this type of email change swapping still works. I might have to write up a blog post explaining how to fix it permanently. It's a fairly simple process though. 1. Create a table that tracks every email address change on the account. It can't just be a single field because once compromised, people have learned to just change the email address twice. 2. That table should contain fields for: user_id, email_from, email_to, confirm_key, reversal_key, created_at, confirmed_at, reversed_at, created_ip, confirmed_ip, reversed_ip 3. When an email change is initiated, an email should be sent to the new email address with the confirmation_key to have them verify the new email address before making the change. 4. Once verified, an email should be sent to the OLD email address notifying them of the change and including a link to the reversal_key to use if they did not make this switch, including the IP address and approximate geolocation of the IP address for some context. 5. If the user clicks the reversal link it will clear the confirmation and reversal links of every email change that came after the link that was clicked, ensuring that the original change can always be reversed no matter how many changes were made afterwards, revert the email address change and force the user to update the password. This password change screen should warn them that their account was likely compromised and strongly recommend they enable MFA (if available on the site) to prevent it from happening again. I spent a year working on a site that dealt with a TON of fraud and phishing against the user base. This was one of the biggest issues that we dealt with, but this approach completely resolved the problem.
- b0afc375b5 4y agoThis solution looks interesting. I'm looking forward to that blog post!
- brightball 4y agoWell, I wrote up a quick draft while it was on my mind. Here you go! https://www.brightball.com/articles/automatically-reversing-account-takeovers https://www.brightball.com/articles/automatically-reversing-...
- b0afc375b5 4y ago
- billjings 4y agoThis article explains the terrible experiences I've had with my Experian credit report. I recently acquired a loan, and in the process found multiple fraudulent hard credit checks against my frozen (?) account. Now I know why. My only recourse is I suppose to call my loan originator and advise them against the reliability of Experian.
- KMag 4y agoThe online instructions I found for reaching a human at Experian didn't work. They seem to purposefully change their menus when it becomes too easy to reach a person, as a cost-saving measure. Out of desperation/exasperation, I randomly mashed the phone keypad until I reached a human. I placed a lock on my Experian credit score years ago when I moved overseas with no clear plan to move back to the US. I was living overseas, and read something that a lock only lasts 2 years, so I had the lock PIN sent to a relative and told my relative to just shred the PIN letter. The last I read was that for some states, the lock lasts 2 years, some 7 years, and some indefinitely. In any case, I moved back to the US and my Experian credit was still locked, so I sent a notarized letter from my bank indicating my new address to Experian, in order to initiate re-issuing my PIN. A week or so later, I got an email from Experian saying my address had been updated. I logged in online and saw that Experian then thought that I lived inside my bank! The Experian employee read the bank's address off of the notarized letter, not my address from the body of the letter. There are supposedly 3 ways to reset your Experian PIN: phone, website, and snail mail. The phone system tells you that you actually need to use the website or snail mail. The website, when I gave it my particulars, generated internal errors multiple days in a row, and the error message told me to use the phone or snail mail. They say they'll respond to snail mail within 2 weeks, I think, but it was closer to 6 weeks, by which time I had sent 3 letters and finally resorted to the aforementioned random mashing of the phone keypad. Some executive at Experian clearly heard that Kafka is very popular at many companies now, completely misunderstood, and structured their processes around the complete works of Franz Kafka. I'm totally not surprised that they allow you to just sign up a new account for an existing identity, and when called out on it, claim they have some opaque secret security process that's you know, totally better than not allowing strangers to make duplicate accounts for your identity. Side note: if you move overseas, do your best to keep a US credit card open in the off chance that you move back. Note that you can't even gen a secured credit card issued without a credit check, which is ridiculous. The cash on deposit fully covers the card's maximum balance, so the credit risk to the issuing bank is zero. I had to use my foreign credit cards for my first 2 months in the US while getting my Experian credit lock sorted out. Both Experian and the banks are jointly at fault for that mess.
- PascLeRasc 4y ago