4 ms·
Not just generics. Ever get a coupon from a drug manufacturer that drops your copay from hundreds of dollars to $10 or $20? Ever wonder why? It’s because Med
by gumby 4y ago
Not just generics.
Ever get a coupon from a drug manufacturer that drops your copay from hundreds of dollars to $10 or $20? Ever wonder why?
It’s because Medicare gets an automatic discount (I think 20% these days but I’m no longer in the biz) from the manufacturer’s official price. So they simply set the official price at some huge figure and rake in huge bucks from the largest buyer, Medicare.
Then they negotiate with the for profit insurance companies and subsidize the copays so that nobody complains to their congress person.
It’s a huge rip off. Medicare should be paying a discount to the median price actually paid on the open market. But apparent nobody has an incentive to fix this.
- naniwaduni 4y ago> It’s a huge rip off. Medicare should be paying a discount to the median price actually paid on the open market. But apparent nobody has an incentive to fix this. Then they start issuing rebates instead of discounts? Or yeah, sure, everyone's definitely paying $100 for this quantity of this drug, then we kick insurance back $80 for advertising for every unit that makes it to an end consumer through them. There's no easy way out of price discovery when you are the largest buyer, because it becomes more than profitable enough to structure sales to exploit your policy to make up for the loss in doing the structuring.
- Retric 4y agoThat's assuming structing actually works here. It's not hard to define average price as cost after all incentives be they rebates or raffle tickets with “zero nominal value.”
- Spooky23 4y agoThe Federal government and government in general is really good at commodity procurement. The processes and legal requirements give them the ability to price and fairly procure even single source commodities. I’ve done scaled procurements at a very large, not federal level. We were almost always 10-20% lower unit cost than large corporate, and sometimes even better. At the Federal level, the law gives them “most favored” status, and they will sue vendors for fraud if they offer lower prices for the same commodity without lowering the federal cost. “It’s hard” is a common refrain for policy discussions. “That’s bunk” is my reply. Policy without graft isn’t much harder than using high and mighty principles to enrich people at taxpayer expense.
- rayiner 4y agoMost drugs aren’t commodities.
- KMag 4y agoThe GP wasn't asserting that drugs are a commodity. They were arguing against the blanket implication that the federal government can't get efficient price discovery because it's the whale in the market. The GP is pointing out somewhat similar markets where the US is doing very efficient buying, even for single-source commodities (with parallels to single-supplier drugs), despite presumably also being the whale in the market.
- yold__ 4y ago> Then they start issuing rebates instead of discounts? They already do, and it's a huge amount of money. It's how they keep prices opaque. There is a list price (retail price), the pharmacy dispenses the drug, and gets reimbursed a variable amount from the insurance company (called the reimbursement price), usually about 50% of the list price. Then, the insurance company gets a kick-back from the drug manufacturer (usually for non-generic drugs). Medicare also gets these kick-backs, and they stopped disclosing the actual amount around 2016.
- jpgvm 4y agoThis is how most single payer systems work. Australia [1] uses a broader spectrum of metrics but price of drugs in other international markets is a substantial part of it's analysis and negotiations. [1] https://www.pbs.gov.au/industry/pricing/pbs-items/historical/pbpa-manual-may-2009.pdf https://www.pbs.gov.au/industry/pricing/pbs-items/historical...
- Spooky23 4y agoIt’s by design. The republican position was that allowing Medicare to negotiate drug prices would amount to price controls. They also forbade the using of Federal funds to reimport drugs from countries like Canada who negotiate prices. It’s a specious argument with predictable outcomes that were in fact predicted and widely discussed at the time the legislation was enacted.
- maxerickson 4y agoPart D plans are privately administered by companies that are supposed to compete with each other. The prices aren't just whatever the drug companies want.
- ta988 4y agoInteresting how there doesn't seem to be much competition.
- rayiner 4y agohttps://www.kff.org/medicare/issue-brief/medicare-part-d-a-first-look-at-medicare-prescription-drug-plans-in-2022/ https://www.kff.org/medicare/issue-brief/medicare-part-d-a-f... “The average Medicare beneficiary has a choice of 54 Medicare plans with Part D drug coverage in 2022, including 23 Medicare stand-alone drug plans and 31 Medicare advantage drug plans.
- refurb 4y agoThis is correct and Medicare Part D came in under budget due to private negotiation of drug prices. I love how accurate posts on HN get aggressively downvoted off they go against the narrative.
- Spooky23 4y agoThe fact is that a manufacturer sells a product at 80% gross margin to a distributor. Attempting to negotiate with the manufacturer is illegal. The resellers of said product go through an intense competitive process and earn a 2-4% margin. So the plans will offer cheap loss leaders… “free metformin!” and make it up elsewhere. Meanwhile, the government is paying $5/pill for some amoxicillin reformulation or whatever. What “narrative” are you upset about again? Personally, I don’t think getting a stream of risk-free government guaranteed business should yield higher margins than coke dealers.
- ceejayoz 4y agoIt doesn't just let them fuck Medicare, it lets them fuck private insurance too. I'm on a med that's $12k every two months. If I were on a high deductible plan, they'll happily cover that $12k for the first go, because I meet my deductible and then insurance pays the other five doses. The cost to them is basically nil; chances are the actual one mililiter of fluid costs them a marginal $20 or so to make.
- smugma 4y agoLike in software (less so in the cloud days), marginal costs are not particularly relevant.
- ceejayoz 4y agoIt is when covering $20 of marginal costs gets you past to a bunch of non-marginal costs.
- jahewson 4y agoThe marginal cost of a cup of coffee is basically nil but I don’t expect a free cup every day from Starbucks.
- ceejayoz 4y agoOther way around. Starbucks gives you the first cup free, because it means the rest of your cups that year are free to you - you've hit your deductible and soon after your out-of-pocket max - but Starbucks gets to charge insurance $500/cup for them. If they didn't have the program, no one would pay the first $500 because it's out of pocket, and Starbucks gets nothing. By forgoing the first $500 of revenue they get the rest.
- sokoloff 4y agoHow do I hit my deductible if I didn’t pay for the first dose?
- refurb 4y agoThis isn’t how it works. You can’t use co-pay cards with publicly funded insurers like Medicare and Medicaid. It’s regarded as “inducement”. https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2018/05/09/609150868/why-cant-medicare-patients-use-drugmakers-discount-coupons https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2018/05/09/6091508... Only private insurers can accept co-pay cards.
- yold__ 4y ago> It’s a huge rip off. Medicare should be paying a discount to the median price actually paid on the open market. But apparent nobody has an incentive to fix this. This is utterly wrong. First of all, Medicare Part D covers pharmacy benefits. Part D is supplemental insurance purchased by seniors from a private insurance company. If you are too poor, I think you go on Medicaid. Also, Medicare Part D plans DO pay less than commercial plans. This study is probably complete B.S. because no one knows how much is paid in drug rebates. Manufacturers pay the insurance companies (including Medicare) huge amounts of money (back) for prescription drug utilization coming from their members. In short, it's a legal kick-back. And I'm not kidding, it's a huge amount of money (like 20% - 30% of the reimbursement price) U.S. drug pricing is broken for many reasons, and sorry to call you out, but nothing that you said is true. Everybody gets ripped off by big pharma, not just the government.
- HWR_14 4y ago> It’s a huge rip off. Medicare should be paying a discount to the median price actually paid on the open market. Non-Medicare federal spending often requires you sign a contract that the government gets the best price you give anyone. Blue Cross negotiates a better rate next month? Medicare automatically uses that one instead.
- encryptluks2 4y agoEver get a coupon from a drug manufacturer in exchange for all your personal information and some disclosure for them to share your medical information? That is why.
- chimeracoder 4y ago> It’s because Medicare gets an automatic discount (I think 20% these days but I’m no longer in the biz) from the manufacturer’s official price. So they simply set the official price at some huge figure and rake in huge bucks from the largest buyer, Medicare. Then they negotiate with the for profit insurance companies and subsidize the copays so that nobody complains to their congress person. This is all completely wrong, to a point where I don't even know where to begin to correct it, because there are three separate misconceptions here layered on top of each other. Not only does Medicare get most-favored-nation pricing (ensuring that they pay less than private insurers do), but pharmaceutical benefits for Medicare are provided under Part D, through for-profit insurance companies. Furthermore, it is illegal to use copay assistance from manufacturers for brand-name drugs if you are using Medicare or Medicaid.